Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to have been furious at pil for insisting on coming round mine for a dinner when ds1 is sooo poorly

108 replies

springchik · 19/12/2010 19:07

Loong story!We were supposed to be going round pil for dinner today and sil and her family were coming down from up north. Sil cancelled yesterday because of the snow. I would not have gone anyway because ds1 is really unwell. Mil knows this came round yesterday and ds barely stirred from the sofa or acknowledge her - very unlike ds1.

Anyway mil rang yesterday and said sil has cancelled so she'll come to us. I said ds is poorly and I have nothing in and she said dont worry we'll bring it all to you cooked it'll be like meals on wheels. Still I protested but she can be very intimidating

Anyway ds has been getting worse and worse. High temp lethargic not eating. During the night he was in agony with his ear and he had a high temp. This morning at 845 I insisted that dh rang mil and said she could not come as ds is too poorly. He suggested to her dh and ds2 came to them instead and cook the meal she has planned. He rang and suggested just that she wasnt too happy but dh said she agreed to it apparantly.

To cut along story short ds1 saw an oncall doctor at a dropin centre today he has an ear infection dr described it as red raw and said I'm not surprised he's been in such pain. Changed his prescription at noon when I got in and saw dh he said oh and by the way mum is insisting on bringing dinner to us! Shock Tried to ring pil at their home no reply rang her on her mobile and asked what on earth is going on and she hung up.

They came round at about 1 producing a cooked turkey (a week early eh) unpeeled potatoes, carrots, cauliflour, peas etc and announced these are to be cooked. I was furious she said what is your problem. I was so sangry I said i have a poorly boy in there and its rude isnt it to insist on coming round someone elses house turning up with food. She said thats it I'm going I dont have to put up with this. Ds1 cried and said dont go so she said dont worry Im not ggoing anywhere and she stayed and I cooked dinner we ate in the dining room while ds1 was poorly in the living room! Angry

OP posts:
WinkyWinkola · 19/12/2010 23:12

I agree with narkypuffin.

Yes, it's nice that people think they're being helpful but I for one don't want visitors of any kind when one of us is ill. That's the way I prefer it. I don't see why I or the op should have to explain our preferences in our own homes!

The op had asked her pil well in advance not to come over. They ignored that. Very rude on their part. They chose to ignore it and intrude.

Regardless of who the relatives/friends are, they should respect the wishes of the parents who are probably stressed about their ill child. And not add more stress.

TechnoKitten · 20/12/2010 03:17

YANBU (and I'm a staunch MIL defender, I adore mine - and I'm going to be one when the boys are old enough).

Your son was ill, you wanted rest and quiet for him. You asked her not to come round more than once, she refused and came anyway.

The whole byplay with cooking is a smokescreen - personally I cannot stand seeing someone make a hash of cooking things in my kitchen and would have stepped in to cook it before the wrong pans were used on the wrong settings.

However, regardless of who should have cooked what - You. Asked. Her. Not. To. Come.

She. Arrived. Anyway.

So YANBU and I would give her a wide berth for the next few weeks including Christmas until you're ready to deal with her again.

Just because she was disappointed that SIL couldn't make it with snow and you couldn't make it with illness doesn't make it OK!

God if I turn into a MIL half as bad as that I hope my DIL does a Val on me!

Francagoestohollywood · 20/12/2010 07:42

No, Narky, it is nothing to do with it being the Mil.
As far as I am concerned, my answer to the OP is mostly dictated by my personality and perhaps by the fact that I'm not English and therefore less protective of the peace and quiet of my nuclear family.
I don't regard a dinner with relatives as a big deal, and certainly not as a disruption (most of the time Grin).

As I said, I'd have welcomed some company for ds (I don't know about yours, but mine aren't in a great mood when ill and are happy to be distracted by grandparent/friend/whatever) and a turkey. Veggies take 30 mins to make.

But again, this particular Mil might be the work of the devil, and therefore the OP has various reasons for not wanting her around.

pommedeterre · 20/12/2010 08:23

Wait until she's got something on and at home she'd rather not be disturbed for and turn up with lodes of raw veg and tell her they need cooking. Let kids run amok.
I'm only part joking.
I am planning to turn up at my MILs with shit loads of random food crap this xmas as that's what she does to be every time she visits. I also plan to make myself much more at home in my kitchen like she does in mine.
Well...if that's the way they do things... When in Rome...

Muira · 20/12/2010 10:30

Parsnip her ass!! I want that to become the response to everything on MN. I want a parsnip/ass emoticon.

YANBU, OP. Your MIL was doing selfish things under the guise of caring. Pretending to care and caring are so very different.

narkypuffin · 20/12/2010 12:44

Franca it depends how ill they are. If they're not quite right yet but over the worst then fine. If they're still high fever and in a lot of pain it's so hard to settle them that any disruption- even a well meant one- is unwelcome. They actually get worse as they get older Hmm

Not everyone is helpful with children either well or unwell. My sister's MIL has held her GC as tiny babies but seems to have no other interest in any physical interaction with them. She complains that she doesn't see them enough but when she's there doesn't talk to them, play with them, feed them etc. There are plenty of threads on here about MILs- and mothers- who turn up to visit newborns at home and expect to be served tea.

It also depends on the family realtionship. My MIL would happily do the cooking in my kitchen and use DH as an assistant. But in her daughter's kitchen it would turn into a blazing row within 5 minutes because she and SIL both want to be the boss and are both very territorial. Another of her daughters would let her do all the work whilst she spent an hour looking for the right table runner.

For this OP and her MIL I think the MIL was seriously out of line.

schroeder · 20/12/2010 13:16

YANBU How anyone can interpret trampling all over your feelings like this as being helpful I do not know!

Francagoestohollywood · 20/12/2010 13:43

Yes, I understand Narky.
It wouldn't have been a big deal for me, but, having thought about it, I can see why another person might feel stressed and upset by this.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page