Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU or are my in-laws?

138 replies

BluePhone · 25/10/2010 18:26

My in-laws have a house with several bedrooms. We are due to go there for Christmas this year.

SIL and BIL are going too, with their 3 children. We have 2 children, a son, who will be sharing rooms with SIL 2 eldest, and a daughter, aged 1.

The gripe I have is thus. The inlaws want us to share our room (a double room with a double bed, and not a lot of room for anything else, but room for a cot) with our 1 year old daughter.

This would be fine if they didn't have a spare room to put her in, but they do. They have a spare room with a single bed, and room for a travel cot, and they will not agree to let us use it.

They have come up with some fairly weak excuses as to why we cannot use it, like "oh its too near the bathroom" etc etc. There is no solid, decent reason why we can't use the room. We went round and round in circles with them last time and they kept evading us.

The reason we dont want to share a room with our 1 year old is that she is a noisy sleeper and easily destracted. We are likely to wake her, and she us. If we are awake, we are both awake, and she just sleeps a lot better in a room of her own.

I would not expect them to magic up a room that doesn't exist, but as there is one, I am miffed at them not allowing us to use it.

I am willing to "try" 1 night of sharing with her to see how it goes. But if it goes badly, is it worth really pushing the issue of putting her in the spare room so we can get decent sleep over what is the last few days of annual leave my DH has and the first decent break away we have had this year since May? Assuming nobody is using the room?

Do you think its worth making an issue of, or having 5 nights of terrible sleep when there is a perfectly good room there that could be used?

OP posts:
HeadlessLadyBiscuit · 25/10/2010 18:55

On second thoughts I'm going with the gimp mask option - I reckon they've converted the room into a S&M chamber and will pretend they've lost the key when you arrive Wink

Booboodebat · 25/10/2010 19:00

I think mapoftheworld's idea is a good one.

Ask if one of you can sleep in the room 'to get a decent night's sleep every other night'.

That makes it very clear what they're asking of you.

Plus, it's a practical solution of sorts.

agedknees · 25/10/2010 19:07

Is that room really cold at night? I ask this because when we used to stay at pil's, the room my dd had was the box room and was freezing at night (I used to take an electric blanket and tons of duvets for her).

(Trying to think of a good reason for your pil's not letting you use the room).

asdx2 · 25/10/2010 19:08

Perhaps they want dd in with you because they aren't comfortable with the idea you might have sex in their house and think dd will discourage thatHmm

BluePhone · 25/10/2010 19:10

Thanks, will try and answer the points I can remember from reading through then will go back.

They do not use the room, I am certain of it. Its not that it never gets used - its that its not being used this Christmas, and that we are not allowed to use it. There seems to be an expectation that we must share with DD.

Its not that she's a terrible sleeper - simply that she is better off in a dark room with a closed door without people coming and going, and snoring, or turning over in bed.

I like the idea of just transferring her there in the night if she's bad. That is the most practical answer. If she's awake in the middle of the night, or us taking turns to sleep there ourselves. (That does inconvenience them in that there is a set of bedding that then needs washing - whereas the travel cot in there doesn't even produce that).

Whilst I agree in essence that its their house and their rules, I wonder how they would feel if I were to insist they share a room with my DD when they stay here, even though we have a perfectly good spare room.

I tried to make it so we only stayed 2 nights, but DH wasn't having any of it.

When I broach the subject with him, he gets all defensive, like I am being unreasonable.

Which makes me think perhaps I should just sleep in that room, or the lounge, or the car or something and let them all get on with it?

I've basically had a newborn through to one year old this past year. Sleep is getting better, but we also have a 3 year old. Both are basically good sleepers, in the overall scheme of things, but put them together for the past year, and it hasn't been the best year of sleep. To have to share with a child hwo is likely to have us up at silly o'clock and awake througout the night seems unnecessarily unhospitable.

Of course, if we were to go there and it were all fine, the subject is dropped, but I feel I need to broach it, because once it is set in stone that we are going, staying 5 days, sharing, etc, that will be it and we'll all be starting yet another year on a wave of illness and sleeplessness, like we did last year. Okay so we can't stop getting the coughs and colds you get round that time of year, but if everyone can get a reasonable sleep, it seems fair to try.

OP posts:
Stinkyfeet · 25/10/2010 19:11

I don't think it's worth making an issue of. There's obviously a reason why they don't want you to use the room - the fact that they've evaded answering the question indicates that it's a reason that they don't want to share. I would respect their privacy and not badger them about it.

I suspect that one of them does sleep in there, maybe not every night, but often enough that they need it left free.

Shallishanti · 25/10/2010 19:15

agree with stinkyfeet- and so, I would say, definitely curtail your stay. Not being nasty about it, just say, well, we can't cope with more than one or two nights of bad sleep (and maybe getting your dd into bad habits) so it'll be lovely to see you for x and y days, then we'll leave you in peace- sounds like a v full house anyway

needafootmassage · 25/10/2010 19:19

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

sayithowitis · 25/10/2010 19:20

Sorry, but I think you ABU. It doesn't matter whether you think it is silly/controlling/weird or any of the other words that have been used in this thread to describe your ILs. tha fact is that for whatever reason, they do not want you to use that room. It is their house. They are entitled to refuse you the use of that room without having to explain or justify their reasons to you at all. If you are that unhappy, don't go. To make the comment about making them share with your DD is not comparing like with like. Your DD is not their DD, so it is not the same situation at all. I also thgink that walking in to their home and planning to 'outmanoevre' them is extremely U. I wonder what the comments would be like if a MIL came on here and suggested she would do something similar to her DIL? They would not all be telling her to go ahead and do what she wants to do, she would be told very clearly that she should respect her DIL's position. You should afford her the same level of courtesy.

RunawayPumpkin · 25/10/2010 19:26

Try it for one night and if it is a disaster tell them that unless you can use the room you will be going home to get sleep

moomaa · 25/10/2010 19:29

I think YABU, none of your business why they don't think you should go in there, and it would be rude to use the room without permission.

If I had to hazard a guess I suspect they are worried your DD will cry in the night or wake early and want to leave that to you (especially as she is in a strange place) and they may feel it is not fair if your SIL/BIL have a little one in with them (do they?).

KT1324 · 25/10/2010 19:34

All seems very strange, poor you, horrible as its over christmas.. I know this sounds silly but i think you said it was quite near bathroom perhaps in laws are both up a lot in night with bladder issues and think they might wake baby up when they keep going to the loo!! my parents are both up 2 of 3 times a night!!

Where is SIL 3rd child sleeping? perhaps they have already offered the room to them but dont want to tell you??

I would tell DH to try and discuss with one of his parents (which ever one he get son better with to see what problem is)

BeerTrixSixSixPotter · 25/10/2010 19:37

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SkylineDrifter · 25/10/2010 19:42

I agree with sayithowitis - it's none of your business why they don't want you to use the room. You're being offered hospitality, accept it graciously and don't do anything daft like trying to slip the child into the room when they're not looking.

atswimtwolengths · 25/10/2010 19:44

Is it the cost of heating the extra room that's worrying them? Is it the time it'll take to clean it? Are they trying to do a damage limitation on the house, in terms of preparation and cleaning up?

If it's not, I think they are being very unreasonable and very inhospitable. Everyone else can sleep well except you two!

specialmagiclady · 25/10/2010 19:47

I would be feeling the same as you at this point. But I would be BU. May I point out one thing:

IT'S CHRISTMAS TIME! It's 6 weeks away. By making an issue out of it at this point you are setting yourself up for a running battle for the entire run up.

Comply with their wishes for the first TWO nights - first night away from home always ghastly, second often better. If you don't sleep well, slope off for the odd lie-down if you can.

If you are really not coping after a couple of nights, ask if you can pop her either in that room or downstairs. Or even in with all the other children. Presumably they'll all be waking up at dawn in a frenzy. They can keep her occupied!

Don't push your inlaws about this - they will think you rude or weird or something (they probably already do, inlaws being what they are) - relax and cross the bridge when you come to it.

Inertia · 25/10/2010 19:53

Maybe they are hiding Christmas presents in there ?

GoreRenewed · 25/10/2010 19:58

There is some reason why you can't use it that they don't want to tell you. Respect that and don't force your DH to push the issue.

fruitful · 25/10/2010 20:01

Where is SIL's youngest going to sleep? Have they also asked for that room and been refused? Perhaps your inlaws are trying to be fair.

Practicalities - we found that pegging blankets round the outside edge of the travel cot helped - it stopped the dc seeing us through the mesh. And at least one of you can wear earplugs each night.

But I think you need to tell them now that the visit will need to be shorter. At least then they might realise that this is a big deal for you.

DancingOnMyBladder · 25/10/2010 20:01

Where will SIL and BIL's youngest child be sleeping? Maybe they would also like the extra bedroom and so as not to choose between you, they have decided to keep it free.

Or it could be like my mum's spare room over Christmas.... Full of junk Christmas necessities.

DancingOnMyBladder · 25/10/2010 20:01

lol cross posts with fruitful - great minds, eh?

fruitful · 25/10/2010 20:02
Grin
pommedeterre · 25/10/2010 20:04

Well if they are so worried about your dd waking them up don't stay very long. Two nights of unbroken sleep might change your dh's mind and have him scuttling after you as you declare yourself homeward bound for some kip.
YADNBU. I would be on dh night and day to sort this out. Hate, hate, hate that women have to deal with both sets of families because dh's in the main seem unable of setting up boundaries with their parents in adulthood. Ack.

BluePhone · 25/10/2010 20:04

Right, I've basically decided I will not mention the spare room again, if she doesn't sleep well on Xmas eve and Xmas night, I am going home on Boxing day. DH can come too if he wants, if not, that's his decision.

Thanks for your input.

OP posts:
GoreRenewed · 25/10/2010 20:06

" because dh's in the main seem unable of setting up boundaries with their parents in adulthood."

But this is about the boundaries for the ILs too. For some reason they don;t want anyone to use this room. Which is up to them. It's their house.

Swipe left for the next trending thread