Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to hate breastfeeding my baby

307 replies

FeelLikeTweedleDee · 18/10/2010 14:36

It's supposed to be nurturing and an amazing bonding experience. But I despise breastfeeding. I'm one of those malcontent mothers who breastfeed out of duty alone. When I read about mothers who enjoy breastfeeding and who feel sad when their child self-weans I feel like sectioning them.

10 Things I Hate About Breastfeeding:

  1. THE PAIN. They say "if it hurts you're doing it wrong". That's one of the many breastfeeding bluffs you'll hear at antenatal classes (don't want to scare off all the new expectant mothers do we?) Well it hurts me and I've had my latch checked by a thousand professionals. Also I've had thrush. Also I have a very strong let-down reflex. Considering the let-down reflex is normal, and indeed essential, then it's safe to say that breastfeeding hurts and I'm doing it RIGHT.
  1. YOUR BODY IS OWNED BY OTHERS. All through your pregnancy you console yourself by saying "I can't wait to give birth, then I can have my body back to myself". WRONG. As a breastfeeding mother, your baby continues to have dibs on your body.
  1. THE HUMILIATION. Aside from imprisoning themselves in their home for 2 years, breastfeeding mothers have to face the humiliation of breastfeeding in public. Every Tom, Dick and Harry can get a view of your baps. Some may even decide to comment as you sit there and flop an udder out. So not only does your body belong to your baby, it also belongs to the general public too. You may as well sign on the dotted line because ownership ain't yours anymore.
  1. LIMITED WARDROBE. Because someone else owns your body, that means that you have to dress to their tastes. Chest access is key. Say goodbye to that inseason lacy bodysuit you've had your eye on. Say goodbye to most dresses actually. Say hello to Primark vest tops and masculine shirts. Joy.
  1. FORMULA CULTURE. Most people give up breastfeeding after a few weeks. Thus we live in a formula culture. Bottles are everywhere. On Congratulations cards, in soaps, in children's books, on babygros. The result is that most people (your close family included) think that by breasstfeeding you have changed into a strange earth-mother type, and maybe even slightly pervy. And of course you're the only BFing mother at your babygroup.
  1. MRS MARTYR. As a breastfeeding mother you are soley responsible for your baby's continued existence on the plannet. Only you can feed baby. (It's understandable why a lot of new dad's support breastfeeding these days!) Welcome to the world of lonely midnight feeds. Welcome to your partner going for drinks down the pub whilst you stay at home, udders at the ready. But what about expressing I hear you say? For most women the breastpump extracts 3oz. As baby grows she'll want more than that. You make an appointment with your doc but she won't prescribe anything to increase your supply. Time to pop to Holland and Barrett to get some Fenugreek herbs. As a result you end up smelling of curry. Your FFing friends at the babygroup avoid your side of the mat.
  1. SO-CALLED "PROFESSIONALS". Health visitors, midwives, GPs, breastfeeding counsellors - they don't know shit about breastfeeding. But they will love to mindfuck you with conflicting info. "Your breasts have dried up because the pump isn't getting much out". "Just top up with formula, it's fine". "Don't bother feeding past 6 months". Because this is your first time breastfeeding you don't know any better. You trust these professionals. As time passes you notice that a lot of what they have instructed you to do has actually sabotaged your BFing efforts. You swear that you'll learn from these mistakes for your next child. But what about your poor first child - the breastfeeding guinea pig.
  1. GROWTH SPURTS. Every month or so you're going to hit one of these bad boys. You'll be constantly feeing every 1-2 hours. No sooner have you clipped your bra cup back up then your baby demands its next meal. If you were on formula you would simply increase the volume of feed and hand it over to dad/grandma/sister in law/the dog. Also because baby is feeding so frequently you worry that your milk is not enough, and you can't see exactily how much milk your baby is getting. Are you STARVING your baby? Dark throughts creep into the back of your mind. The old lady in the post office gives you evils as your baby screams the place down. "Baby needs her bottle" the old lady comments, tutting and shaking her head. You begin to wonder if she's right.
  1. MONITORED INTAKE. Really looking forward to several double vodkas after giving birth weren't you? After 9 months of t-totalism, a big blow out was just what you needed. Well tough titties. And that medication for your acne? Say goodbye to it and hello to a face that resembles those Cath Kidston pokerdotted handbags.
  1. YOU HAVE NO CHOICE. A large part of motherhood is about making the right choices for your family. Stay at home - go to work, co-sleeping or seperate rooms, dummy or no dummy. And breastfeeding or formula feeding is one of those choices right? WRONG. you have no choice. From the moment of conception we are bombarded with "breast is best". The scientists and the government have made your choice for you. Afterall, you want to do what's best for your child, right? (How can you answer no to that question and not live with guilt).
OP posts:
emy72 · 18/10/2010 22:02

NellyKats, to be fair I don't think pacificwerewolf was bragging about successful breastfeeding, she started saying she didn't like it. She even says she gives her baby formula sometimes!

She is giving just her very personal account, same as the OP has.

Sorry it didn't work out for you, by the way....and well done for expressing for so long, I couldn't have done it.

Nellykats · 18/10/2010 22:11

thank you emy72, I didn't mean to sound agressive, it's just that sometimes the successful breastfeeding mums adopt a tone that belittles the hardship that a lot of women face. It's a bit like me, having conceived my son naturally, telling a couple trying ivf that having sex is the easiest, most natural thing in the world. I know the comparison is a bit weird, but honestly sometimes the anti-formula posters versus the unsuccessful breastfeeders are in completely different planets!

By the way, I always encourage women to breastfeed, I think it's an amazing thing to share with your baby but I try to keep it low when it comes to formula - I also felt like I was poisoning my son with formula and it only depressed me more.

Sorry for ranting a bit! :)

megapixels · 18/10/2010 22:21

My goodness, sounds like you absolutely hate breastfeeding, why the hell don't you stop then?

YABU btw, most of your points are pure BS :).

I loved breastfeeding, I thought it was one of the loveliest feelings in the world to be snuggled upto my babies while they drank from me, but if you feel so totally the opposite, honestly just stop - life's too short.

Nellykats · 18/10/2010 22:23

to me, breastfeeding seems like a kiss from your baby to you, a wonderful thing if you achieve it. But thank god for formula as well.

megapixels · 18/10/2010 22:23

Oh forgot to say, I agree with your point no. 1. It certainly does hurt (not for everyone of course). Only till bf is established though, but still. That is the only minus for bf for me.

Diziet · 18/10/2010 22:25

Oh, HelenLG xxx and FeelLikeTweedleDee... Sad
that's just how I felt with both my boys.
Especially you, Helen.
When they are older, different Food Issues can arise: my 2 both had home made baby food.
Now, all they like to eat is fish fingers, chips, all that kind of thing. I try starving them. I try hidden veg thingys. The eldest is starting to succumb to bribery, at last... but still.
Getting the Little Buggers to eat at all is a struggle and sometimes I feel like shaking the mums of children who are Good Eaters and screaming, "DO YOU KNOW HOW LUCKY YOU ARE???" at them.
I also used to feel this way at those people who said they found breastfeeding easy.
But, hey, I'm a mild-mannered girl who just doesn't do that sort of thing.
I just worry myself silly instead! Smile

mybabywakesupsinging · 18/10/2010 22:40

Dear tweedle,
I have bf 2 dc so far. ds1 for 12 months and ds2 until about 2.5 years (their choice).
It really does get easier. Once they are eating food, I found they had 3 milk feeds a day - morning, afternoon, evening. Ds2 had only 2 feeds from 9 months. You still have some of the problems you mentioned in your op - oh I got so bored of sleeping in a bra and not wearing a dress ever! - but it is a far smaller part of your day.
If you feel you "have" to bf for a longish time because of the guidelines, at least please bear in mind it isn't continual growth spurts, exploding boobs and so on for the duration...
I am expecting dc3 and hope to bf again. But I have made a resolution to go shopping and spend a lot of money on new bras (old ones are horrid) Smile.
good luck with whatever you decide to do.

SpecterBooAlot · 18/10/2010 22:50

Nelly but Pacific is entirely correct - yes, formula can be a fantastic, sometimes life saving, tool, but there is no point avoiding the fact that it is everything Pacific listed.

Tryharder · 18/10/2010 22:53

YABU.

I find BF difficult but can quite honestly say that being able to drink or not and wearing nice clothes or not are not really issues.

Look at it this way: you could swap to formula and then you would have:

  1. massive cost of buying formula,bottles, steriliser, etc.
  1. ff babies tend to be windier, more colicky and more constipated.
  1. You have to drag a bag around with you with ff paraphenalia. Every trip out has to be planned to make sure you have enough formula and bottles to last you.
  1. You have to make up the bottles to new guidelines which takes about 3/4 hour - what happens if your DC is screaming for food NOW?
  1. FF is a hassle - I once tried to give DS1 a bottle on a flight and asked the air hostess to warm the bottle up for me. She blasted it in a microwave until it was boiling. How I wished I was bf at that point...

There are problems with bf that would be solved by ff but then you end up with a different set of problems.

Nellykats · 18/10/2010 22:58

SpecterBooAlot

no it's not

it's not equivalent to powdered milk, that's a ridiculous comparison

it's not potentially harmful, at least not any more than brastmilk could be if you are consuming harmful things. For example, drinking is not a good thing while pregnant, though lots of mothers drink far more than the recommended amount.

If you drink and smoke, you're doing your baby no favours and would probably do better giving them formula.

cory · 18/10/2010 23:01

I didn't feel like the OP does, but I have come on here a fair few times to have a fair few rants about things that I did need to rant about.

I thought that was what Mumsnet was for.

Nellykats · 18/10/2010 23:02

...sorry, I meant to say drinking is not good while breasfeeding rather than pregnant

petisa · 18/10/2010 23:06

OP your list made me chuckle and I agreed with most of the things on your list (ouch, painful letdown is pretty intense, isn't it!)... but I really love breastfeeding! Grin (too knackered to list why)

petisa · 18/10/2010 23:08

Thinking about it I would say mainly it's because I ff dd1 and am finding bf dd2 much easier (so far, should not jinx myself)

SpecterBooAlot · 18/10/2010 23:09

"it's not equivalent to powdered milk" - Hmm Yes, formula is just a magical substance, its not a powdered cows milk with added sugars at all Biscuit

mumsgotatum · 18/10/2010 23:12

Just do formula then...

Nellykats · 18/10/2010 23:14

thank you for the biscuit, I shall dip it in coffee full of powdered milk. Actually no I won't It's my first ever MN biscuit, I shall treasure it!

Are you a nutritionist?

Would you recommend feeding a baby on powdered milk for your coffee? Then I would accept it's the same thing.

HeadlessPrinceBilly · 18/10/2010 23:16

You know point 19 directly contradicts point 5? Hmm
I don't agree with most of your points, and I've BF 3 babies for up to 18 months each (my third is 13 months).
My body is owned by no-one but me. I'm not a martyr, my wardrobe has never really been changed (and WTF is a lacy bodysuit anyway?), I have never been humiliated about BF in public, its quite easy to show nothing much. Pain, well lots of things can cause pain sometimes, doesn't mean its not good. I;ve got a sore arse from riding my bike today, doesn't mean I should stop exercising. Growth spurts, well babies grow, thats a good thing.

Its not always the easiest thing in the world but I think you, and many others, need to chill the fuck out about it. And if you hate it, don't do it. You say theres a formula culture, you're right, you'd be in the majority. So why pretend you don't have a choice when you know you do?

HeadlessPrinceBilly · 18/10/2010 23:18

point 10 even [hblush]

showmewine · 18/10/2010 23:23

Has the OP posted back on here? i was reading this thread earlier..

do some women set them selves ridiculously high standards for things? why? why torture yourself?

I have two friends who got into serious difficulties with BF one ended up in hospital due to infection which became a cyst, both got severe PND

I really struggled with BF and gave up at 3 weeks: we were moving house, i was anemic and my milk looked like water Sad

I hope the OP has had sometime to think about some of the responses it seems to me that OP needs some time out its not just about the baby Smile

Nellykats · 18/10/2010 23:24

only just noticed the halloween faces!

[henvy]

no envy, just wanted to do pay a little homage to my best film ever, the Wizard of Oz, yay!

Nellykats · 18/10/2010 23:25

giving myself a Biscuit for irrelevant comment

iwastooearlytobeayummymummy · 18/10/2010 23:32

Happy mother=happy baby.

If you don't like it stop.

Motherhood is not a competition, and if you
are mixing with mothers that think it is, then give them up as you will have nothing but grief for the next 20 odd years

And we are priveliged to have safe choices in this country regarding the use of FF v. BF

hellymelly · 18/10/2010 23:35

Surely a lot of mothering means putting someone else first anyway? Wiping bottoms and reading the gruffalo when you'd rather be on the sofa with Vogue? Breastfeeding may have a downside,the wardrobe in the early days is a pain,but it is a lot less of a pain than getting up and warming up bottles,rather than cuddling in bed half asleep with a baby happily feeding away.It is also so much easier when the baby is small and you are out and about,nothing to take with you other than wipes and a nappy,as everything else is on your chest anyway.Great.I am still feeding a three year old,and it is sometimes annoying,when she is taking an age to finish at bedtime and Enders has started,but mostly it is just easy,I never even think about it at all.

morganade · 18/10/2010 23:40

i felt the same way as op about bfing, and i switched to mixed feeding from 16 weeks. i would bf first thing in the morning and last thing before bed but ffing during the day and when we were out which turned out to work really well and was the best option for us. if it's making you feel that bad ( and it made me feel that bad too), just stop. you still need to think about yourself as well as dc, and doing something that makes you feel this way can only have a negative effect on your relationship with your baby

Swipe left for the next trending thread