What is the thing people sometimes shout during “Sweet Caroline”?

[Tarkan]

I’ve been speaking to some friends tonight and they don’t believe me about this.

It’s NOT “so good” repeated or the “bah bah bah” thing. I’m sure it’s something along the lines of “shut up you’re having a laugh” but only specific areas use it?

I remember knowing this not that long ago but menopause brain means I can’t remember the exact wording and many Google searches haven’t helped. Friends (and DH) think I’ve completely made this up. 🙈

I’ve only ever heard the so good version

Nope, I only know of the ones you've mentioned.

Buckfast Wine

Aaagghh I hate you!
I used to know this.

You sure it’s that song with that response ?
I think you’re mixing up songs.
Now I shall lay awake all night thinking of this.

" I don't believe you, you're making it up! "

Apparently in Scotland they sometimes chant “I don’t believe it, you’re making it up”, but I can’t imagine where in the song it fits in!

I just did a Google search and found this, someone posted they would sing I don't believe you yer making it up https://www.facebook.com/share/p/1DHeLgbb66/

"Buckfast wine" if you're scottish and "i don't believe it, you're making it up" in my circles

This is it!

Thank you! And the others who have said this since too.

I’m actually in Scotland and no one where I am seems to know this. I feel when I first heard it it was maybe Yorkshire or something?

But anyway thanks to all who proved I wasn’t going insane over this LOL.

Right after the line "good times never seemed so good"

Are you thinking of The Fields of Athenry - people shout ‘let the free birds fly’

Thanks for this, I couldn’t fathom how those words would fit in! There’s a video in the comments of a guy singing it.

Ignore me I took too long to think of the song I was thinking of!!!

My money was on the Saw Doctors One more time. Great song.

maudelovesharold
Apparently in Scotland they sometimes chant “I don’t believe it, you’re making it up”, but I can’t imagine where in the song it fits in!
Sweet Caroline
dum dum dum
good times never seemed so good (straight away and faster) I don’t believe you you’re making it up!

So I told everyone and one of the guys said “oh yeah I remember hearing that” so I have extra back up in the room now LOL.

I was thinking of Am I ever going to see your face again, No way, get effed, eff off.
Different song. 🙃

My uncle from Newcastle taught us this!

"Woah, baby, let the free birds fly!"

The answer was there in the last line of your OP. Maybe when you thought they were saying they didn't believe you they were actually trying to tell you the answer

Amazing observation!

Or they were just taking the piss

Haha and I didn’t even remind myself by posting that. 🤣

"Who the f*ck is Alice?"
Okay, I know it isn't the answer to the OPs question, but what song is it?

Living next door to Alice - Smokie

it was Roy Chubbie Brown that introduced the ‘who the f*ck is Alice’ line