Help end medical misogyny. Sign our petition.

Help end medical misogyny.
Sign our petition.

Sign the petition

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

A question about Henry Nowak….

301 replies

CurlewKate · 10/06/2026 14:09

Is there any actual evidence to support the suggestion that this completely awful event had anything to do with with “two tier policing” and was a hideous example of appalling policing and in particular, appalling first responding? It is unforgivable that the police didn’t check Nowak properly for injuries. But there was no weapon at the scene and the police were met with 4 people who had called them and were all telling the same story.They made assumptions which they would probably have made regardless of the ethnicity of the people involved. And in 999 cases out of 1000 the assumptions would have been right. The sort of judgement call the police have to make all the time. So it seems to me that it’s not about policy, it’s about incompetence.

OP posts:
CurlewKate · 10/06/2026 20:50

We must be careful not to attribute to conspiracy what is actually a cock up. Even the most appalling cock up in the world.

OP posts:
RonniePickering · 10/06/2026 20:52

Absolutely wouldn’t be classed as a cock up if the roles were reversed and the Sikh man had been stabbed and then arrested before he died.

Let’s not pretend otherwise.

Chiapotayto · 10/06/2026 20:55

I see your point OP. Before I saw the video I was shocked at what happened, but after seeing it, I don’t see it in the same way as others.

The police man arrived to a calm scene, with several people accusing the victim of being the aggressor, with the actual killer showing his supposed injuries. It was night time, one of the people helping Henry said he climbed over the fence and fell off the car. It’s an area full of students who are often drunk. There was no evidence of blood. After watching the video, I don’t agree it’s about race but rather the police taking the scene as they found it.

Where I think they failed is they interpreted his slurred words as someone who was drunk and ignored him when he said he had been stabbed, but it really isn’t as black and white as one person’s word against another, and the police getting it wrong because someone claimed they were racially abused.

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 10/06/2026 20:56

CurlewKate · 10/06/2026 20:50

We must be careful not to attribute to conspiracy what is actually a cock up. Even the most appalling cock up in the world.

A “cock up”?! A boy dies and you call it a cock up? Oh “whoops, we handcuffed him and watched him die, soz, but 4 people said he’d said bad things”
”don’t worry lads, you have the full support of those who know the bad words accusations are so much more serious than his dying. And even if he died, he’s only one boy, it’s not the worst that could happen…”

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 10/06/2026 20:58

@Chiapotayto one of those “helping” him, was that one of the killer’s family?

youalright · 10/06/2026 20:58

Chiapotayto · 10/06/2026 20:55

I see your point OP. Before I saw the video I was shocked at what happened, but after seeing it, I don’t see it in the same way as others.

The police man arrived to a calm scene, with several people accusing the victim of being the aggressor, with the actual killer showing his supposed injuries. It was night time, one of the people helping Henry said he climbed over the fence and fell off the car. It’s an area full of students who are often drunk. There was no evidence of blood. After watching the video, I don’t agree it’s about race but rather the police taking the scene as they found it.

Where I think they failed is they interpreted his slurred words as someone who was drunk and ignored him when he said he had been stabbed, but it really isn’t as black and white as one person’s word against another, and the police getting it wrong because someone claimed they were racially abused.

I agree people need to actually watch the video. On a past thread people where arguing with me about it and the majority of them hadn't actually watched the video.

WatermelonSalad1 · 10/06/2026 21:02

CurlewKate · 10/06/2026 20:50

We must be careful not to attribute to conspiracy what is actually a cock up. Even the most appalling cock up in the world.

I couldn't agree more

But the race inequality policy is now written down so they cannot deny it

youalright · 10/06/2026 21:03

Dollymylove · 10/06/2026 20:29

"Ive been stabbed"
"I dont think you have mate"

How much more do you need?

But he said this as he was lifting his top at the back checking him for stab wounds and couldn't find any then they got distracted by the bleeding on his face and thought he was talking about they then called an ambulance for him then he died. The police didn't just stand there and say i don't think you have mate and shrug their shoulders like people are trying to make out.

EasternStandard · 10/06/2026 21:04

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 10/06/2026 20:56

A “cock up”?! A boy dies and you call it a cock up? Oh “whoops, we handcuffed him and watched him die, soz, but 4 people said he’d said bad things”
”don’t worry lads, you have the full support of those who know the bad words accusations are so much more serious than his dying. And even if he died, he’s only one boy, it’s not the worst that could happen…”

‘Cock up’ indeed. Ffs

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 10/06/2026 21:06

WatermelonSalad1 · 10/06/2026 21:02

I couldn't agree more

But the race inequality policy is now written down so they cannot deny it

so if your child was stabbed to death, while the killer stood by, watching them die, lied to the police who did nothing but shove them in handcuffs on the lies of the killer and his family… you’d say “whoops what a cock up, moving on”,

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 10/06/2026 21:08

youalright · 10/06/2026 21:03

But he said this as he was lifting his top at the back checking him for stab wounds and couldn't find any then they got distracted by the bleeding on his face and thought he was talking about they then called an ambulance for him then he died. The police didn't just stand there and say i don't think you have mate and shrug their shoulders like people are trying to make out.

Their first aid skills must have been shit to not see the knife wounds severe enough to have killed Henry

Chiapotayto · 10/06/2026 21:11

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 10/06/2026 20:58

@Chiapotayto one of those “helping” him, was that one of the killer’s family?

No I don’t think so - think it was a white guy.

Chiapotayto · 10/06/2026 21:13

youalright · 10/06/2026 20:58

I agree people need to actually watch the video. On a past thread people where arguing with me about it and the majority of them hadn't actually watched the video.

Before I watched the video I was outraged and found the entire thing indefensible. After watching the video, it’s not as simple as the killer making an accusation and Henry being handcuffed whilst in a pool of blood, which admittedly was my understanding before I watched it.

WatermelonSalad1 · 10/06/2026 21:14

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 10/06/2026 21:06

so if your child was stabbed to death, while the killer stood by, watching them die, lied to the police who did nothing but shove them in handcuffs on the lies of the killer and his family… you’d say “whoops what a cock up, moving on”,

No, I'm saying we mustn't create conspiracies whether there aren't any

I think that was very clear from my post

But My points to the OP is that this is not a conspiracy the racial inequality policy is very real.

Wededed · 10/06/2026 21:14

sesquipedalian · 10/06/2026 18:39

OP, the whole situation was absolutely unacceptable - if there’s someone who is OK and standing up, and someone else on the ground, you deal with the person on the ground. The police hauled him up and then handcuffed him with his hands behind his back. This could have contributed to his death - this is a comment left on X that was posted by a commenter below an article in the Spectator -

Translated from Polish
🟥 Could Henry Nowak have survived?
Dr. Krzysztof Magier, a pediatrician and former honorary consul of the Republic of Poland in Cowes, analyzed footage from a police body camera showing Henry Nowak's death.
Dr. Magier heads the pediatric intensive care unit, with experience in combat medicine training and a specialized course in treating severe injuries (including gunshot and stab wounds).
He disagrees with the pathologist's and judge's opinion that Henry Nowak had no chance of survival and that handcuffing him essentially changed nothing. On the contrary—there is a high likelihood that the police intervention contributed to his death.
He analyzed the autopsy report, which points to damage to the subclavian vein as the main source of bleeding, and explains where the problem lies.
In a healthy person, venous bleeding occurs under low pressure and often self-limits thanks to the naturally forming clot, while simply approximating the wound edges and compressing the surrounding tissues closes the vein enough to slow or even stop the bleeding.
The body camera footage shows that when police arrived on the scene (likely 5-10 minutes after the injury), Henry was conscious enough to speak quite loudly. He was therefore not yet in a terminal state. After his arms were twisted behind his back and handcuffed, the vein was most likely stretched, the clot torn, and bleeding dramatically intensified. Within just about three minutes, he lost consciousness and died.
People with suspected internal injuries should never be moved or yanked abruptly—such actions can destroy the natural clot and lead to massive internal hemorrhage.
Instead of immediately calling a medical rescue team and handing the patient over to paramedics, the police handcuffed him. If paramedics had arrived first on the scene, Henry’s chances of survival would have been much higher. "50%"—writes Dr. Magier.
Paramedics could have quickly started an IV, administered fluids to increase circulating blood volume, and tranexamic acid to stabilize the clot, and if needed, performed needle decompression (inserting a large, long needle into the lung), because the issue wasn’t so much lack of lung function, but compression of the blood-filled lung on the heart and mediastinum, which blocks circulation.
Worse still, the incident took place just a few minutes' drive by car (2–3 minutes by ambulance with sirens) from Southampton University Hospital—a regional Major Trauma Centre equipped with a full team of specialists, procedures, and equipment. "I am convinced that if Henry had arrived there alive, the doctors would not have let him die"—writes Dr. Magier.
In summary: the aggressive police intervention, instead of saving a life, led to death through improper handling of a severely injured person, even though world-class care was just minutes away. "I fear the Judge and pathologist were too lenient toward the police"—writes Dr. Magier.

Wow that’s awful.

The hospital was 2-3 mins away.

Gosh. The family stood over him for 15 minutes whilst he begged for an ambulance.

They really should all be in jail.

ainsleysanob · 10/06/2026 21:15

“Anyone who thinks black and brown people are treated better, hasn’t been paying attention”

You mean like the 100’s of Brown men whose known crimes, and I do mean appalling crimes, against at least 1400 female children, which were swept under the carpet by South Yorkshire Police and every other authority involved, FOR YEARS, because they didn’t want to seem racist or damage community ‘cohesion’? While little white girls were labelled Prostitutes, Trouble Makers, Liars and their Dads were arrested for threatening behaviour. That’s just in Rotherham. Then there’s Rochdale, Telford, Bradford etc etc etc. Yeah, the brown community in Rotherham for the last 30 years have really had it tough 🙄

Dollymylove · 10/06/2026 21:16

If somekne is lying on the ground, gasping for breath with a mouth full of blood, and trying to tell them they were dying, to me that sounds like a very big clue that this young man was desperately in need of medical help.
But hell, what would I know?

WatermelonSalad1 · 10/06/2026 21:17

Also again, I think posters are commenting without information

I would've thought it was obvious they had to ring the police because otherwise how are they going to explain an injured man on their property

So that's why they rang the police

I suppose in theory, they could all run inside and pretend they don't know anything about it that may be panic, maybe they were expecting somebody to have something on camera

The killer must've known he inflicted a deadly wound as it went all the way from Henry's lungs to his collarbone so he is probably thinking how do I get a man of my property when he's gonna be dead shortly

RedRosesParmaViolets · 10/06/2026 21:17

Theunamedcat · 10/06/2026 14:16

The murderer wasn't even handcuffed or searched he was treated respectfully with kid gloves unlike the victim

This.

Op the wording of the training has been bandied about.

WatermelonSalad1 · 10/06/2026 21:18

Dollymylove · 10/06/2026 21:16

If somekne is lying on the ground, gasping for breath with a mouth full of blood, and trying to tell them they were dying, to me that sounds like a very big clue that this young man was desperately in need of medical help.
But hell, what would I know?

Exactly, and that's the first thing they would've seen when they arrived

If they didn't believe Henry, the householder was telling them that Henry had a mouthful of blood and couldn't sit up even with somebody trying to prop him up!

chocoluv · 10/06/2026 21:22

He was killed by Digwa.
It is very unlikely that he would have survived if the police acted faster.

I do think it was a stressful situation and it all happened so fast.

They handcuffed the person that was drunk and acting erratically, not the person who was calm and being comforted by other people.

I do not blame them as they needed to handcuff the one that was acting in a way that was not calm.

But they should have both been treated as innocent/potentially dangerous and both immediately checked for injuries and weapons.

Many people say the police and prison system are too lax on criminals but I have always disagreed.

I think treating suspects with respect and decency, whilst still keeping everyone safe should be the default.

I find it heartbreaking that he was treated like a criminal when he was genuinely one of the nicest guys ever.

youalright · 10/06/2026 21:23

WatermelonSalad1 · 10/06/2026 21:17

Also again, I think posters are commenting without information

I would've thought it was obvious they had to ring the police because otherwise how are they going to explain an injured man on their property

So that's why they rang the police

I suppose in theory, they could all run inside and pretend they don't know anything about it that may be panic, maybe they were expecting somebody to have something on camera

The killer must've known he inflicted a deadly wound as it went all the way from Henry's lungs to his collarbone so he is probably thinking how do I get a man of my property when he's gonna be dead shortly

You would expect them to do what most murderers do dispose of the body not call the police to the crime scene

RedRosesParmaViolets · 10/06/2026 21:23

@Chiapotayto

I'm not sure what view point they were taking the scene from in your eyes ?
My eyes saw the victim full of energy trying to say his eye was hurt which looks fine ?

The so called perp..is weak on the floor desperately trying to trigger help I've been stabbed. .how many fucking times did that boy need to say it whilst life left him .where was that officers duty of care ??

youalright · 10/06/2026 21:24

ALovelyPinkUnicorn · 10/06/2026 21:08

Their first aid skills must have been shit to not see the knife wounds severe enough to have killed Henry

It was quick and dark. Watch the video

RonniePickering · 10/06/2026 21:25

“I do not blame them as they needed to handcuff the one that was acting in a way that was not calm.”

Haha Lord Jesus, dying and bleeding out and trying to tell the emergency services you can’t breathe and have been stabbed is not acting calm.

Have you heard yourself?