I don’t know which cat to gift my friend!

[AintNobodyHereButUsChickens]

I always planned to give her the siamese. I was keeping the black and my 13yr old claimed the calico one. Whichever one I send, will have its own box. I just haven’t made the 3rd one yet (it’s so much BROWN!).

Now I’ve made them and I’m looking at them, I think my friend would prefer the black one, but I wanted to keep that one for myself! She doesn’t know about them so I don’t really want to ask her which one she wants as that would ruin the surprise. What do I do?

Oops forgot to attach the photo!

Fat thumb hit the sensitive image box 🤣

Omg they are gorgeous! I would be happy with any of those if I was your friends! I’m a terrible one for anthropomorphising so I would be upset to separate them in case they were sad. 😂 is there secret option number 4 and you make another one to give her?

This was so confusing before you posted the photo.

Which is the calico one?
If the problem is too much brown for the middle one, cent you make the box a different colour?

If you think your friend will prefer the black and you want it, can you make another?

I'm sure she'll love any, they are all cute.

Oh they are adorable! Whichever you chose to send her I cannot imagine she will mind as these are lovely!

I was so confused, I thought you were talking about real cats to start with 😅

i love the orange one most

Can’t you just make another black one and keep all 3!

I think the siamese one is great (possibly my favourite), but agree that the box is going to make the whole thing very brown. I think doing the box a different colour would be a good idea. Maybe a steely grey, which would go nicely with the blue eyes.

I was scared for a second 😀 I love the orange one.

I would want the black one but only because I have a real black one

Oh they are fab!

Um, are you quite sure your friend will want a weird knitted cat?

So did I!

OP, I think the siamese cat would look great in a blue box. Blue would match the cat's eyes and would also go well with the cats' fur colour. Poor cat wouldn't look his best in a brown box.
Very cute cats!

I thought we were about to see some pussy of the sensitive photo kind. I like these one more!

I was reading the post and was so confused! 😄😄

I love the calico omg - you made these, you're so talented!

Agree with pp that the siamese one should go in a blue box that matches the eyes x

Send her the middle one (it's eyes are adorable!) but make the box in a different colour otherwise it's a bit too samey.

A nice orange-y red like on the Calico would look good.

Love a crocheted cat.
How do you make their tails stand up?

I like the black one followed by the brown one so I don't think you would be short changing your friend, especially if she doesn't know they exist. Agree with pp about box though.

Florist wire in a heavy gauge, I think I used 18 gauge wire and it works really well!

I can’t really make another one, I don’t have enough of the yarn and it costs a lot to get the eyes, the eyes themselves aren’t expensive but the postage was nearly £4 😬

They are very cute! Give her the one you planned to from the start, I agree a different colour box would look good though!

I sincerely hope nobody ever spends the time to handcraft you anything. It would be a waste.

Yes! Yes she will!!

Can you show us a picture of the Siamese in one of those boxes? Do you have enough yarn to make box in different colour or combination of colours?