Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Why are majority of the riots in northern towns?

1000 replies

PhoebeMcPeePee · 04/08/2024 12:13

DH & I were watching the riots on the news this morning like most people absolutely horrified.

He's from one of the northern towns affected although we live in the south and started discussing why these riots now (and historically) tend to be more focused on northern towns but didn't really come up with any one thing. Any thoughts on this?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
Livelovebehappy · 04/08/2024 18:24

Omlettes · 04/08/2024 18:18

Erm minor point, the Conservatives have been in power for FOURTEEN YEARS.
Labour 2 months...

But we already know Labours plans. They detailed it in their manifesto. Their plan for curbing illegal immigration via the channel, is to smash the smuggling gangs. Now I’m no politician, but I know that this won’t work - smash a smuggling gang? Others will just step in to fill the gap. The gangs will never be eradicated. I’m sure Labour know this, but are just paying lip service to make people think they’re doing something.

Westfacing · 04/08/2024 18:25

2littlledarlings · 04/08/2024 18:10

There has been plenty of riots in London, Bristol. The ones in Tottenham forgotten?
it’s not that people are racist, areas are FLOODED with communities that are not interested in intergrating at all in instances.
funniest thing I have saw all weekend tho is nobody has posted about the matters going on?? Or the posts haven’t been allowed to be saw but this one has?
It may be people are just fed up by two tiered expectations
btw I am not in agreement with the riots but can understand why it’s happening to a degree.

The riots in Tottenham riots were in 2011 - what relevance are they to the past week?

It may be people are just fed up by two tiered expectations

Can you explain what you mean by this?

FleaDog · 04/08/2024 18:25

Devonbabs · 04/08/2024 17:54

A lot of these towns have high levels of immigrants and there are many cultures living together in quite cramped conditions.

Multiculturalism really doesn’t work. Many of those rioting are ostracised are they are repeatedly told they are privileged and feel they are at the bottom of the pile for any help.

If all of this is to be solved, people who have no experience of the issues being faced need to get off their high horse, listen to the very valid concerns of those rioting and address them.

Intersting points.

I live in a binnof a northern town, linked to the death of Jo Cox.

The mantra of We are far more united and have far more in common than that which divides us.” adopted in the area is lovely in sentiment but a sticking plaster of a slogan for bubbling tensions, deprived areas, housing issues, poverty, dire education provision, growing crime, suspicion of police not handling crime appropriately etc

Areas of town are becoming ghettoised by immigrants that are being placed in substandard private housing that the council wont condemn as they don't have capacity to rehouse tenants.

Examples being chunks of abomded high street area turned into flats that are obviously not fit for purpose, with household furniture set up in the middle of the road as people extend their space, padding pools with children playing in the middle of roads , clothes airers blocking pavements, all "housing" bought for cheap by private landlords as the buildings are in dire states, minumum work onnthem to make thrm habitable, and extortionate rents cgarged to.the council to house tenants.

Crime is out of control, drugs are dealt openly, large froups of mslescongregate in town drinking alcohol and smoking weed - it is too iinsafe for eople to use town so they don't go in, there are very few shoppers, just peopke driving to a service or shop they need, eg opticians, and straight back out of town.

Children's services, social workers, police etc are so overstrectched schools (this will be the same in a lot of areas) are acting in place of these services yet dont have increased funding ir staffing to deal with it - eg schools buying travel tickets for families to get children into schools as families have exhausted support of social services and dont have the means to get children to school.

Trafficking of girls is kniwn inbthe area - safeguarding trainkng for school DSLs fcuses on known hot spot areas, link back to families eith language barriers, no invome etc to see how this is a growing area.

There are 'good' peple who want to see multiculturalism work - however radicalism in all areas (religious groups, disenfranchised young men, manipulation of vulnerable povery driven groups) are the real growing concerns.

But... but... people identifyong this are shot down, they are labelled racist, islamaphobes, thugs...

Some are, but some aren't..

There are very real growing concerns in many nierthern towns that will be copies of the above, and shooting down voiced concerns isn't helping.

I wish I could share information about this but it wouldn't be believed. Governments are aware of the problems, they just arent interested.

I tell my children work.hard and get out of this area and be open eyed about where to move to.

mumedu · 04/08/2024 18:25

FolkestoneMassive · 04/08/2024 18:17

In psychology they call it reaction formation.

So it IS you, Suella. Welcome back to mumsnet.

AvrielFinch · 04/08/2024 18:26

I think many posts on here show just out of touch so much of the middle class are to working class peoples lives in poor areas and a total lack of understanding of the level of poverty.

Leniriefenstahl · 04/08/2024 18:26

Livelovebehappy · 04/08/2024 18:24

But we already know Labours plans. They detailed it in their manifesto. Their plan for curbing illegal immigration via the channel, is to smash the smuggling gangs. Now I’m no politician, but I know that this won’t work - smash a smuggling gang? Others will just step in to fill the gap. The gangs will never be eradicated. I’m sure Labour know this, but are just paying lip service to make people think they’re doing something.

Rwanda cost how many billion. It was ludicrous and unfathomably expensive but you’re moaning about Labour’s plans.

Riapia · 04/08/2024 18:26

Because the right wing rioters come from the south.
Not going to wreck their own areas.

Anonym00se · 04/08/2024 18:28

Hoppinggreen · 04/08/2024 16:55

With Ferret milk

You’re posh! We only have XL Bully piss in ours!

AdviceNeeded2024 · 04/08/2024 18:29

Anonym00se · 04/08/2024 18:28

You’re posh! We only have XL Bully piss in ours!

😂😂

Leniriefenstahl · 04/08/2024 18:29

AvrielFinch · 04/08/2024 18:26

I think many posts on here show just out of touch so much of the middle class are to working class peoples lives in poor areas and a total lack of understanding of the level of poverty.

Yup but they’ve been to Harrogate and York on holibobs and think it’s all like that.…And they only ever move to these places that on the whole are shut off to folk on ordinary or low wages. I always laugh when ex southerners living up north bang on about how amazing life is up here, but of course, you’re living off bishy road or some nice middle class market town full of people like you 😂

suburburban · 04/08/2024 18:29

SpaceHogger · 04/08/2024 15:58

No one should be hurting anyone due to the colour of their skin. That’s appalling.

What about the attack against the soldier last month in Kent, or the murder of the two teens in Nottingham last year? Both by none white people,against white people? Were they motivated by race? Did the attacker/killer choose their victim due to the colour of their skin?

I’m so glad someone has brought this up at last.

Imagine if we interchanged a few things here;

White guy kills 2 black students and janitor
White guy tries to kill black solider and his wife
White guy goes on vicious killing spree at Beyoncé dance class and stabs 13 women and children of colour, killing 3.

It would be labelled a racist attack and our whole country would be lambasted for our intolerance.

Kill a white person, they must have MH issues
Kill a personal of colour and it is racism.

And you know what, it is racism, but why the double standards?

That’s why people in Liverpool and Southport think the police are lying.

Edited

Yes the Nottingham murders were awful

What was he even doing in the UK.

Robin198 · 04/08/2024 18:30

Why aren’t there any riots in Scotland or Wales?

Goldenbear · 04/08/2024 18:30

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 04/08/2024 18:21

This (and @RedToothBrush's similar post) is spot on. These riots are at least partly the result of deep rooted deprivation that goes back decades.

I grew up in London but have lived in 'the north' for 25 years now. Many people down south have no idea of the extent to which many northern areas have been systematically run down and underfunded by successive governments (with the conservative ones being worst - austerity was targeted very unequally, and closing pits with no plan for the future happened under Thatcher), and the impact that has had on communities.

Southerners that dismiss northerners as racist or thick or lacking aspiration (because if they want a good job they should just move to London, right?) are showing themselves to be extremely ignorant - far more so than the people they are mocking.

(And I don't even know where to start with the claim that you can't buy proper coffee in Leeds station... Leeds station has had multiple decent coffee shops to choose from for at least the past 20 years. None of them sell instant coffee.)

It did happen but it must have been on the train to Leeds from other Northern City as I did think they doesn’t make sense. The lack of food choices was their perception as they are used to lots of nice choices on their doorstep in London central. You have literally stated in you post about the deprivation is more profound are you saying this is a reason for the riots or not I don’t really understand your point.

Fullyflavoured · 04/08/2024 18:30

Riapia · 04/08/2024 18:26

Because the right wing rioters come from the south.
Not going to wreck their own areas.

Yes.The Southern right wingers care so much about the North and poverty they go and destroy their towns.

Turophilic · 04/08/2024 18:31

Hoppinggreen · 04/08/2024 17:15

I was helping a client from overseas find a property in Chapel Allerton last week.
Couldn't move for bloody Teslas and fancy cheese shops and chi chi cafes. I am pretty sure you get get non instant coffee too.
I relocate people from all over the world, usually HNWI and sometimes VIP's too and they think Leeds is great. I am very lucky because I get to see it through fresh eyes all the time.
Is is utopia? no
Is there a lack of coffee and nothing but good butchers and burger restaurants? Also no

Although Neil and Danny in the Chapel Allerton butchers are very good if you like that sort of thing (I don't but the rest of the family eat meat). Maybe that's what PP's 'colleague' meant, Danny makes a cracking burger and lamb skewer. I'll be sure to tell him someone from Multicultural London approves.

Tarbett's fishmongers is just outstanding. George and Joseph cheesemongers champion some awardwinning local cheese makers - although it's not exactly The Courtyard Dairy. Hopping's right, it's awash in chichi cafes.

Quite frankly, I think Leeds has enough on its plate at the moment without dealing with Goldenbear's preconceptions.

Because we all absolutely believe that at Leeds station Starbucks, Pret, Cafe Nero, Coffee Room, Panopilis, whatever Bagel Nash is now (Bagel Factory, maybe) and even McDonalds and Wetherspoons had all run out of coffee the day her imaginary friend visited.

And because of this dearth of ground coffee, the North and Yorkshire are condemned to be rioting right wing nut jobs, living on meat and Greggs.

wastingtimeonhere · 04/08/2024 18:31

Working class white boys recognised as now being the most underachieving demographic and having little hope of better futures.
Seeing illegal migrants preferentially being housed at the expense of our indigent young people breeds resentment

Then, lets add in a realistic scenario -
WC Lad grows up, gets low paid but full-time job, meets girl, they move into rental, she has baby, works p/t. He has MH crisis, relationship breaks down, he has to move out, can't afford a flat, houseshare is all he can afford, his ex won't let him see his kid, his MH can't cope, gets evicted, council won't help, gets directed to homeless charity, but as a single male under 35, no accommodation. Gets given a sleeping bag and told to rough sleep.

While pleading for help he sees housing notices in a dozen languages and reports, however, accurate or inaccurate of immigrants being housed, given allowances.
He eventually gets on his feet, but the damage is done. He is now hardened to the world and cynical of authorities.
You can see why anyone seeing this unfolding would think immigrants are being treated more favourably.

Livelovebehappy · 04/08/2024 18:32

Leniriefenstahl · 04/08/2024 18:26

Rwanda cost how many billion. It was ludicrous and unfathomably expensive but you’re moaning about Labour’s plans.

It was. Rwanda was never going to work. It was a shit idea. That’s what I’m saying. We’re going to be screwed over be Labour just as we were with the Tories. That’s the reality of the situation we’re in.

Westfacing · 04/08/2024 18:32

Leniriefenstahl · 04/08/2024 18:29

Yup but they’ve been to Harrogate and York on holibobs and think it’s all like that.…And they only ever move to these places that on the whole are shut off to folk on ordinary or low wages. I always laugh when ex southerners living up north bang on about how amazing life is up here, but of course, you’re living off bishy road or some nice middle class market town full of people like you 😂

Interesting username

oakleaffy · 04/08/2024 18:33

Decisionsdecisions1 · 04/08/2024 12:57

Some really interesting points here.

I was born and raised in Yorkshire and moved to London as an adult. Most of my extended family (parents/siblings) remain in Yorkshire.

As ethnic minorities (my parents were migrants) I grew up thinking living with racism and fear was the norm. When I moved away I realised it wasn’t the norm everywhere.

I’ve never quite worked out why. London has very high levels of child poverty, some of the highest in the country (in part driven by housing costs). It also has a very high level of asylum seekers/refugees. Some areas have high levels of unemployment, particularly among 18-25 year olds. It isn’t one big booming success story.

What is different is there simply isn’t the space for segregation on the level seen in other parts of the country. Most areas are diverse - both ethnically and in terms of wealth - because house prices drive this. Most areas still have very mixed housing stock so 1950s blocks of flats can be on the same street as £1.2m houses,

People travel to work together on public transport. There’s little choice to do otherwise.
Most people send their kids to state schools with a very mixed demographic. Most people have little choice over schools as the catchments are so small.

Dd has had a very different experience to her cousins who lived in their nice village, went to their nice local village school and were driven everywhere by car. It’s only as older teens that they’ve ventured into bigger towns and cities independently.
I worry about how much dd is exposed to sometimes but equally it has made her less likely to view people different from her as ‘other’.

Some really good points here.
I'm white British, but born and bred in London, and only moved to another city to afford housing -but London has always been really diverse.
People of all races, from all over the World live there.

In rural areas, the almost uniform whiteness is noticeable..It's definitely something I notice compared to living in larger cities.

AvrielFinch · 04/08/2024 18:33

suburburban · 04/08/2024 18:29

Yes the Nottingham murders were awful

What was he even doing in the UK.

The Nottingham attack was nothing to do with race. It was a failure of mental health services. He was psychotic i.e. had lost touch with reality. This is what happens when our mental health services get spread so thin they can not properly cope with people who are more seriously mentally ill.

Devonbabs · 04/08/2024 18:33

askmenow · 04/08/2024 18:02

A feeling of unease and unfairness. The British laud fairness above all. And they want it visible!

Unfair policing for fear of being called racist, as evidenced by the grooming gangs scenarios.

People in authority kept quiet, both the Government, Police, Councils.... "because it was all too difficult " They knew who the perpetrators were but allowed our children to be raped and abused by a specific demographic.

"Two tier Kier" has stoked this division with his off the cuff remarks about addressing far right "Thugs" in largely northern towns. They are not all far right, they are questioning, considered people who fear for this country's future and see unfairness.

What about the liberal Thugs desecrating our statues? What about the Jewish residents in London fearful of crossing the streets due to threats by Pro Palestinian thugs.
The London Bubble knows nothing!

In the towns and villages of the North, migrants gravitate to enclaves and are "apart", endeavoring to live by their own rules, in their separate neighbourhoods, carrying on with the practices of their homelands over here in the UK.
I saw potential "otherness" even in the 1980's in areas of Birmingham. Already living lives apart, women living in back rooms, unable to speak a word of English. Ethnic shops overflowing onto pavements , whereas Britsh white shopkeepers would have the local Council on their backs for obstructing safe passage. And it goes on....

Working class white boys recognised as now being the most underachieving demographic and having little hope of better futures.
Seeing illegal migrants preferentially being housed at the expense of our indigent young people breeds resentment.

Lack of hope makes work for idle hands. We need to reopen youth centres, boxing clubs and promote youth wellbeing across all ethnicities. Bring our youth together and maybe there will be hope.
Good male role models need to step up and help.

This perfectly sums it up. What’s more the issues in Birmingham you speak of have moved further and further down the Stratford road - it really is one law for one. During covid, massive groups were gathering in certain house, cars spilling onto the roads (often parked over the pavements) absolutely nothing done. Yet walk to closely to someone in the park down on you like a ton of bricks. Knife crime was prevalent, almost invariably Asian youths, yet you weren’t allowed to say. Swopping houses between family members so, was once the local CofE school, was almost entirely Muslim.

Theres no desire to integrate with the existing population. We were lucky and could leave, we had no ties really, but still had to remove our child from school. We’ve moved to an overwhelmingly white area, it’s so much nicer, shared values, norms and experiences. People interact and talk about shared things and experiences. It feels a community. But yes we were forced out of our long standing home, because we no longer felt there was a community we could be part of.

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 04/08/2024 18:34

Goldenbear · 04/08/2024 18:30

It did happen but it must have been on the train to Leeds from other Northern City as I did think they doesn’t make sense. The lack of food choices was their perception as they are used to lots of nice choices on their doorstep in London central. You have literally stated in you post about the deprivation is more profound are you saying this is a reason for the riots or not I don’t really understand your point.

No, it didn't happen. That, and everything else you posted, was utter bullshit.

You don't even need to go through the barrier and leave the platform at Leeds train station to access more than one proper coffee shop. That's why everyone knows you're talking out of your arse (or your mate was, and you were gullible enough to believe it).

And yes there is widespread deprivation in the north. There are also many decent coffee shops and restaurants in the centre of every major northern city, and have been for years. Both are true.

Just like there are areas of London with intense poverty, but also Harrods and Belgravia.

AvrielFinch · 04/08/2024 18:35

Goldenbear · 04/08/2024 18:30

It did happen but it must have been on the train to Leeds from other Northern City as I did think they doesn’t make sense. The lack of food choices was their perception as they are used to lots of nice choices on their doorstep in London central. You have literally stated in you post about the deprivation is more profound are you saying this is a reason for the riots or not I don’t really understand your point.

Leeds is posh ffs.

Devonbabs · 04/08/2024 18:35

AvrielFinch · 04/08/2024 18:33

The Nottingham attack was nothing to do with race. It was a failure of mental health services. He was psychotic i.e. had lost touch with reality. This is what happens when our mental health services get spread so thin they can not properly cope with people who are more seriously mentally ill.

And you could argue that our public services are spread so thin because of immigration.

Lifeomars · 04/08/2024 18:36

TinklySnail · 04/08/2024 17:08

He hasn’t though, he has spoken to condemn the violence but you carry on blaming Reform for this 🤷‍♀️

Where have I blamed Reform? my comment was about Farage, I know he is the leader but I didn't mention the party he is currently in charge of. In fact I rarely think of him within the context of Reform as I think he just sees his limited company (£25 membership with no voting rights for those who sign uo) as a stepping stone to joining the Tories. Where can I read or view his statement condemning the riots?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.