This thread is a bit old now, but if you have landed here looking for recommendations, we've recently updated our guides to the best dumb phone for kids and best phones for kids featuring phones tried and tested by Mumsnet parents.
We hope you find this useful.
MNHQ 
--
Ds is 9 thus month and wants a phone. I know, I know......but, he and his brother are getting to the stage of going on bikes rides, wanting to go to the shop, and when we go camping they disappear on their bikes. So I'd quite like a way of contact/tracing.
I know I could get a basic call/text but not sure they will trace also?
Is it possible to let him have a smartphone with parental controls that work? I would obviously limit use.