Which engagement ring would you pick?

[christmasshime]

I am stuck between three rings. I wanted a silver band but love the diamond in the first one. The second one is very pretty imo but there's something about the third one that makes me really drawn to it. Which one do you like best?

None to be honest, didn't like first and others two square, I've just chosen mine, very different

@anothernamechangeagainsndagain would you be willing to post a picture? No pressure

Love the third but wish I had opted to go yellow gold for mine 20+years ago when I bought into the platinum trend, it’s not the right tone metal for my skin colour! Something to consider? X

I like the first one because I prefer yellow gold and more old fashioned looking jewellery. My engagement ring is similar to my grandmother’s engagement ring and I personally like that. I’m not into more modern styles.

I like all three, but it would depend on how high the setting is for me. I wouldn't want anything that sticks up too far, which would be annoying when putting on gloves, or would catch when you put your hand in your jeans pocket.

Second one.

First one is a bit old fashioned

Third one is nice

I love the first. It's unusual and having been married for a while now I always not

*Notice rings which are a bit different! I love the contrast between gold and silver!

2nd

The Art Deco style of no. 3 is simply beautiful, the other 2 are a bit meh.

Also, how much of your finger would the engagement and band take up? Would there be enough room left for an eternity if you like those? Thinking quite far ahead there 😆

Third!

3rd one I don’t really like the other 2

Middle one will looker better with a wedding ring. It’s a lovely ring. Congratulations

The third one by miles

Third one, I love the cut

Third or second one. I actually really like the look of (yellow) gold bands, tbh. The first one is just a bit too cluttered in my personal opinion. But they´re all nice.

I like the first. It has a very classic, vintage look which I like.

The second is ok in my opinion and the third I think is very popular which would put me off.

But only you know OP and they are all actually lovely.

I love the first and the third, but if I had to choose it would be the first.

First one as it's vintage. Also I have several platinum rings and now I prefer yellow gold it's warmer.

Third one. Looks very classy!

I like the first one. It is a classic cut, elegant and timeless.

You might like this thread op 🤣

To show me your engagement rings? http://www.mumsnet.com/Talk/amiibeingunreasonable/4401939-To-show-me-your-engagement-rings

Third one,other two meh.

3rd one