I’m really interested in how this thread has taken shape. My initial post was, in a nutshell, “hypothetically, is today a good day for someone to start a diet, given the amount of festive food in the house? I am eating chocolate.”
I didn’t say I was overweight, or intending to lose weight, or that I was concerned that I was eating chocolate.
The responses now seem to be (paraphrased) “eat the chocolate if you want to, you don’t have to feel guilty, you can lose weight in the new year”
I don’t think I was making any judgement about whether or not it’s ok to for me or anyone else to eat chocolate at 6am at Christmas, nor was I asking for permission to eat it. And yet we are all so conditioned to think we’re not supposed to do it that we give permission to other women, whether or not they’ve asked for it.
And we tell people they can lose weight even if they are not saying that they want to lose weight.
I want to make it really clear that I’m not being shirty about this. I just think it’s really interesting that we all assume that we should feel bad about eating nice things, and also overwhelmingly it seems we want to be nice to strangers on Mumsnet and say (again, paraphrased) ‘you go girl, eat the chocolate, don’t worry, you don’t look fat’.
I have previously dieted to lose weight. I don’t anymore. I eat a fairly sensible range of food now, which is not about weight loss but is an attempt to minimise menopause symptoms. I’m really comfortable with eating lots of chocolate at Christmas but will stop once it runs out. Not as a diet. But as a return to post-Christmas normal eating. I’m in the normal BMI range.
So, to summarise, I wasn’t asking if it was ok to eat chocolate at 6am, but I am very interested by the responses and what it says about the omnipresence of diet culture and our relationship with food.
I hope this post doesn’t read as a criticism. It isn’t intended to be.