It's not about being right and wrong and being a 'detective'. DH has applied for mountain rescue in the past but we live a little too far out for it.
It's trying to be very rational about the situation on the information we know and not let it be taken over by theories that are wild.
We are both really quite upset by it - and feel it could easily be kids we know (and care about). DH spends his entire spare time trying to get teens to understand risks of the outdoors but encouraging them to enjoy them. He was a wild teen and got up to all sorts of shit he shouldn't. He WAS one of those kids.
When I came to the thread there was talk of drugs using and all sorts. These kids don't strike me as that at all. They sound good kids who are under prepared or have had a bad accident. And that's a really really common and actually understandable thing - even with experienced outdoor people who frankly should know better.
This story gets to use because it feels close to home and because we empathise with it so much.