Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

If your partner wanted a baby and you didn't, would you have one or leave the relationship?

111 replies

SecretArmySoldier · 13/11/2021 15:32

Just that really. If your partner wanted a child and you didn't - would you have one?

And, if this applies to you and you did this - how do you feel about it now? Any regrets?

This is happening to me right now, I've always been on the fence about kids but lean more towards staying childless. He is adamant he has to have kids. What would you do?

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 14/11/2021 11:00

He says he will be 'hands-on' but when you told him some parenting stories he was "sort of disbelieving" and he is quite rigid and needs his routines?

Recipe for disaster.

GrandmasCat · 14/11/2021 13:31

As a woman without children you may know yourself well and have a clear expectation of what “kind” of mother you will be, but you cannot underestimate the power of those hormones that come with maternity that makes you attach to the kid and put the “survival of the offspring” over everything else.

You may find yourself not enjoying parenthood or trying to find a way to become a SAHM to stay at home with your children.

My best friend, who leaves abroad, is massively career oriented and never wanted children of her own, her husband is not as ambitious in his career as her and always wanted kids, so I was very surprised when she told me she was expecting. So I said “you never wanted children” her response was, “I don’t, I’m bearing this child but once it comes out of me, the child is his. I am NOT changing my life, I will continue to go out to restaurantS, holidays and the theatre, that’s what nannies and babysitters are for. I find it so stupid that so so many women change their life because they cannot detach themselves from the child! He wants a child, he cares for it.”

She kept these views throughout pregnancy, to the point I started worrying if the child would feel rejected. Fast forward 2 months after the birth she called me in tears, to apologise for how stupid she had been and the horrible things she had said, she had spent a month crying because she couldn’t bear the idea of leaving her DD in nursery at the end of her country’s very short maternity leave. Over the next weeks she called me often from the nursery’s car park to help her calming down before work.

It is 11 years since this and she has not changed a bit, she won’t leave her DD with babysitters at all and she is still putting her to bed every night and staying until she falls asleep even when the girl is now 12 years old.

So it is possible to go to the extreme oposite of what you expected.

VladmirsPoutine · 14/11/2021 14:44

It's just too huge a gamble. I'd have to leave because even if he concedes wanting children he still might grow to resent you for it.

billy1966 · 14/11/2021 16:35

@stalkersaga

In the circumstances you describe I'd leave the relationship.

A man can have a child without endangering his body, spending nine months puking, feeding it from his own resources, or changing his life much at all. A woman can't.

Odds are that like most women you'd end up stuck with the vast bulk of shitwork and grow deeply resentful. And that's assuming you don't end up with birth injuries or longlasting effects of pregnancy.

Absolutely this.

There is no way I would have a child that I didn't want.

Do not compromise on this, you could REALLY regret it.

billy1966 · 14/11/2021 16:47

Could HE offer to look after some friends children for an overnighter?

As in ye go and stay in their house and look after their children for a night?

From your point of view it would be interesting to see how he would cope.

Rigid people find children the hardest to cope with IMO.

Their routines take over the house because that's what works.

Happy baby, happy parents!

Some babies are very easy and slot in with your life according to a story I heard,.... but my reality was that strict routine worked best and gave us the most sleep.

We were always obsessed with sleep so did everything to get as much as possible to maximise it.

CatherinedeBourgh · 14/11/2021 20:33

I was there. We were told we needed ivf to conceive, I didn’t want it. Preferred to stay childless.

Dh accepted my choice.

10 years later I got pg. He asked me if I wanted to terminate, I said no.

We now have two wonderful dc and they are by far the best thing that ever happened to me.

anthurium · 14/11/2021 22:01

I was in a situationship/relationship where my ex partner did not want children [in the specific timeframe], I was 12 years his senior. It was heartbreaking but it was neither fair on him nor me to remain in the relationship when the push came to the shove.

I went on to do IVF with a sperm donor aged 39 so I didn't have time to waste ...
He has at least another 10/15 years ahead of him where in the meantime he could change his mind...

I think the most important thing is to not waste other people's time when it becomes apparent it is an impasse.

FictionalCharacter · 14/11/2021 22:28

Would definitely leave. You don’t want them and shouldn’t feel coerced. Nobody knows how they’ll feel after their child is born and how they’ll cope with parenthood, so he might not be the doting dad he thinks he’ll be. He could possibly leave you, so you’d be a single mum. Plus MN is full of threads about partners who were lovely before the kids came along and have turned nasty since becoming fathers.
I just wouldn’t be able to risk all that.
It sounds like a basic incompatibility, unfortunately.

LalalalalalaLand123 · 14/11/2021 23:23

Leave. No question. Only have a baby if you really want one, children are hard fucking work.

amusedbush · 14/11/2021 23:44

I would leave.

DH and I met ten years ago, when we were 21. I decided that I didn't want children when I was about 14 but he was on the fence about it, kind of assuming he would have them one day. As we've got older and travelled and saved money, etc, he is leaning far more toward not having any.

There are a million little reasons that I don't want a child but The Big One, the one that people actually understand and back off when I tell them, is that I'm neurodivergent. It's genetic and I can barely navigate myself through the most basic tasks in life, never mind a child who would likely have additional needs as well.

If DH woke up tomorrow and told me that he needed to have a baby, I would let him go and find that with someone else.

My mum admitted to me that she never wanted us and only had us so my dad wouldn't leave her. She was a shit mum who openly resented our presence because we ruined her career, body and social life. I'm ending the cycle here.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 14/11/2021 23:51

I agreed to try for six months thinking my age would mean it wouldn't happen. Six weeks later I threw up on the way to work. I now have a six year old and a three year old. It's not been easy, pregnancy does not agree with me, I ended up with two emergency sections and a bunch of mental health diagnoses.

It took a while but I'm now happy with the choices I made and I can't imagine life without them. However for the 1st year of dc1's life I hated dh, ds and motherhood. Dh was amazing and his work were hugely supportive. I also managed to make some brilliant mum friends who dragged me out. Without that network, things could have been very different.

Based on the above though, I'd never advise anyone to do what I did. It was a huge gamble and could have had awful consequences for all three of us.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page