I like it if it was one of the former professional, rather than a random celeb.
I'd like Ian Waite, James or Ola Jordan or Brendan Cole. I think a lot of the female professionals would have the same vibe as Shirley though.
I'm not sure why three male judges would be disastrous. It was originally in Len's day and we've got more women on the presenting side now.
It's a shame we can't get rid of bloody Shirley and Bruno.