My sibling is a celebrity part 2

[zedtree]

I don’t know how to tag the previous thread but it became full (mainly with unnecessary comments and speculation)

People were still discussing and asking relevant questions so I am happy to continue the discussion and answer them if people want me to.

As with the first thread I won’t be naming them, answering personal or outing questions about them or engaging with nastiness.

The trouble is once you say it isn't this person then it will be is it that person. Eventually it becomes obvious who it is or OP stops answering and people seize on that as confirmation. I can understand OP not wanting to start that.

People don’t say they ‘are a celebrity’ as a profession. Here’s hoping your sister doesn’t walk around introducing themselves as ‘a celebrity’ 😬
Like I said, they’re your sister, not a celebrity to you 🤷‍♀️

(If they’re encouraging you to keep this thread going, then step up to that sibling role in offering them support back in real life, as they’re obviously struggling in some way if they’ve hatched this desperate AMA plan with you.)

It’s probably some forgettable Love Island non entity

I think I answered a similar question on the first thread but I’m honestly not sure. Half of me thinks they wouldn’t cope well at all and half of me thinks they could end up coping much better.
And it depends who you’re talking to and what day it is, sometimes their public image is fair but you they also get a lot of unfounded nastiness and also maybe some people who overinflate and idolise them

Except that in this case, there has overwhelmingly been one frontrunner in terms of guesses, and no alternate.

The OP is quite happy with people thinking her sibling (real or otherwise) is Katie Price.

Amanda Holden or Holly Willoughby ??

FFS. OP has said that she's not going to name her sibling. Why keep doing this?

Letting everyone obsess that it's Katie Price is quite a good way to prevent this thread becoming nothing but lists of celebs.

Well it's not fully working is it, as your last post - chastising someone for guessing two other people - shows.

Katie Price is a shining example of all that is wrong with "celebrities". Vacuous is a word that comes to mind

1. Do you think they’re paranoid? times where they say people are looking at and talking about them when they don’t actually seem to be to everyone else? or where they have accused someone they know as not being genuine or betraying them without any proof?

1. Are there other celebrities that they don’t like / they know doesn’t like them who they have had to work with and been friendly with in public? Or are there other celebrity who we see working together all the time and would think are best friends but they know actually hate each other in real life?

1. Do they lie on tv/ social media? Have you ever called them out on that?

1. Have they ever spoken about you/your parents/your childhood? Do you feel they were fair and honest about it or did that cause problems?

1. Do you tell them your secrets? Or do you worry they might share them publicly? Do they trust you to tell you their secrets?

1. Are you married? Do you talk to your partner about them and share things about them that are private? Do you worry if you split they could come out and say things about your sibling?

And you think if she says it isn't Katie Price people will just accept not knowing? I think they will just come up with a new front runner

So you do know saying no to KP will just lead to more speculation

How old was your sibling when they decided that this particular career was what they wanted to pursue? Was it a childhood dream that became a reality (like those kids who dream of becoming a train driver or a zoo keeper)?

To be fair, the OP hasn't said it's not any of the multiple other guesses either.

Besides, what would be the point in denying anything? Many people on this thread would assume a denial was a lie anyway.

Eh? That's not what I was saying. Obviously people will still speculate. But no, I don't think it would lead to more speculation in terms of quantity of posts because there is no obvious other guess besides KP that meets much of the info given. Already loads of alternate guesses have been given and proven to not meet the criteria, so I don't know who is left.

But more importantly, I think the speculation should be secondary to the OP not allowing people to think KP's sister is doing this and have a bad view about her if she isn't the OP. That's just decency to me.

I've effectively just answered this in another post but to answer:

No, the OP hasn't denied other guesses, but no one else has been guessed to the same extent or name checked so much.

The point in denying it would be to try and lessen the criticism that someone innocent (Sophie Price) was getting. I agree with PP that the OP wants people to think it's Sophie Price, even if it isn't or if the OP is making this all up.

If it is KP then the OP can't say, and if it isn't, people won't believe her when she says it isn't, so what's the point in posters continuing to ask?

Lizzie Cundy?

🤣 I think it’s been forgotten that ‘celebrity’ comes from the word ‘celebrate’ and too many people aren’t worth any celebration. What a misnomer it is.

Well if it is her why wouldn't she deny it to stop the criticism? We would never know.

Because clearly the OP is happy with how the two threads or going or doesn’t care.

She's probably busy with their tedious "podcast' where Pricey can barely put a coherent sentence together.

She's happy she's being criticised? Bit weird.