Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my husband did not go too far and they should just get over it ?

312 replies

ForFancyNavyLion · 20/09/2026 14:03

AIBU to think my husband did not go too far with the comment?

Husband and I have two boys. Our eldest has just started school this September and our youngest isn't even 4 weeks old.When we had our first, DH took 6 months paternity leave because his workplace offers it. He then spoke to work and took another 6 months unpaid. We got used to looking after our son and sharing everything, and honestly it was lovely. My side of family have never really understood it. A lot of the older women in my family made comments about why DH would want to take so much time off and seemed to think it was strange. His family are much more progressive about it. His dad actually said that if he'd had the opportunity to take a year off when his children were young he absolutely would have but it wasn't really a norm back the. Not saying it is the norm now but lots more places are starting to at least offer 6 months paternity.
We've now had our second baby and DH is doing exactly the same thing again 6 months paid paternity followed by 6 months unpaid. It works for us financially and more importantly, it's what we've both agreed we want.

Last week we went to my aunt's house. She's in her early 80s and was meeting our new baby for the first time.At one point the baby started crying and DH took him from me to settle him. DH too does a lot of the nappy changes, feeds, getting up in the night etc because we're both his parents and that's just how we've always done things.My aunt watched DH with the baby and said to him, "Isn't that your wife's job?"DH laughed and and carried on.
Her daughter, who is in her 50s, then joined in and started ranting at DH about how men and women have different roles, how he shouldn't be doing everything for me, etc. DH initially tried to laugh it off but she kept going and eventually he snapped.

He told her: "oh fuck off If you focused more on your weight nosey what I do for my family wouldn't matter to you." The room went completely silent. I was honestly shocked. I agree that she was being incredibly rude and I don't think there's anything remotely wrong with DH taking paternity leave or looking after his own children. But I also think bringing her weight into it was completely unnecessary.

DH says he doesn't regret saying it because she'd been going on at him for ages and he wanted to shut the conversation down. He also pointed out that she had no problem criticising our marriage and parenting while apparently being offended when he responded. I think he could have told her to mind her own business without commenting on her weight.

My family now think DH needs to apologise I have told my mum to just let it go if the aunt and her daughter are that upset about it, its not as though she sees my husband often. This is not the first time someone has snapped at the them, it happened over summer from a different relative.

OP posts:
Glitchymn1 · 20/09/2026 17:36

theyneverchangedothey · 20/09/2026 17:06

Fuck me. 1865 called, they’d like you to return, immediately.

😆 god I miss the laughing emoji! Nailed it.

Morecoffeeneedef · 20/09/2026 17:37

SpecialShark · 20/09/2026 17:01

This opinion won't be popular, but your aunt has a good point. Men and women do have different roles. 6 months paternity.... fine, I guess. But his role in that is to care for you and baby while you get into the swing of motherhood.

12 months off is ridiculous and unmanly. Your husband knows it, and she touched a nerve, which is why he bit back. He should apologise for being rude.

Unmanly! Stepping back in time here.

thatsgotit · 20/09/2026 17:45

SpecialShark · 20/09/2026 17:01

This opinion won't be popular, but your aunt has a good point. Men and women do have different roles. 6 months paternity.... fine, I guess. But his role in that is to care for you and baby while you get into the swing of motherhood.

12 months off is ridiculous and unmanly. Your husband knows it, and she touched a nerve, which is why he bit back. He should apologise for being rude.

Unmanly! snort

Seriously, do give your head a wobble. The ‘role’ of a husband in early parenthood, just like the ‘role’ of a wife, is whatever the couple decides between them as the best system for them as individuals, and for their baby.

I haven’t RTFT but it wouldn’t surprise me if you were a man yourself —and a rubbish father to boot—.

BatchCookBabe · 20/09/2026 17:48

I would still love to know who this magical company is who lets men have 12 months maternity leave? (When the woman is having the same leave?)

Robogob · 20/09/2026 17:56

Ugh, a man telling a woman in her 80s to fuck off is disgraceful. Why couldn’t he let it just wash over him or say something constructive? Also it is a bit unusual to take a whole year off. People are going to have an opinion. Some elderly people lose their filters. Calling her a fat nosey is vile.

Lmnop22 · 20/09/2026 17:57

Two wrongs don’t make a right and weight is an incredibly personal thing to bring up to a person.

They were obviously being unreasonable making comments about your parenting preferences too but that doesn’t make his comment less unreasonable (and in my view worse!)

SparkyBlue · 20/09/2026 18:02

Fair play to your DH. I think he was 100% right in saying what he did. I said something similar many self years ago when someone kept making snide comments relating to my height and my dds height .

Peachghost · 20/09/2026 18:10

Robogob · 20/09/2026 17:56

Ugh, a man telling a woman in her 80s to fuck off is disgraceful. Why couldn’t he let it just wash over him or say something constructive? Also it is a bit unusual to take a whole year off. People are going to have an opinion. Some elderly people lose their filters. Calling her a fat nosey is vile.

He said it to the daughter in her 50s, not the elderly woman. Wouldn't have blamed him though if he did. The 2 women were incredibly rude to him. He let multiple comments wash over him and he did say something constructive, the nasty misogynists wouldn't let it drop.

Peachghost · 20/09/2026 18:13

Lmnop22 · 20/09/2026 17:57

Two wrongs don’t make a right and weight is an incredibly personal thing to bring up to a person.

They were obviously being unreasonable making comments about your parenting preferences too but that doesn’t make his comment less unreasonable (and in my view worse!)

I think parenting is an incredibly personal thing to bring up. Especially when the women kept on making rude comments. I think their comments were far worse and they should have stopped long before the OP's husband returned the personal insults.

Lmnop22 · 20/09/2026 18:17

Peachghost · 20/09/2026 18:13

I think parenting is an incredibly personal thing to bring up. Especially when the women kept on making rude comments. I think their comments were far worse and they should have stopped long before the OP's husband returned the personal insults.

Agree they’re both personal, but the way to deal with a bully making personal comments is not to make personal comments back.

Just leave the house, tell her to be quiet, tell her to stop commenting on the parenting split etc etc. But telling an 80 year old woman to fuck off and focus on losing weight in her own home is unacceptable no matter what prefaced it

ForFancyNavyLion · 20/09/2026 18:35

Starlight7080 · 20/09/2026 16:24

I think its lovely you have the first year together . Its only ever a positive. And very odd your family dont see it that way.
You can only have a go at someone for so long before they snap back. And really if they cant cope with it then they shouldnt be making so many comments about how other people live .
Maybe now they will rethink how they speak to people .

I think the older ones in my family seem to have the view that I should struggle on my own. I had a very tough time mentally with our eldest and so we figured it would be better for us if we were both on maternity leave for a year. My cousin told me she struggled a lot because her ex husband only had 2 weeks paternity leave yet she looks down on my husband for wanting to look after our kids.

OP posts:
ForFancyNavyLion · 20/09/2026 18:42

Lookatmelookatmedontevenlookatme · 20/09/2026 17:13

Yes he went too far. Their narrow minded comments needed addressing but what he said was a personal comment intended to hurt. I think that’s really awful, OP, sorry.

In the 4 years we have been parents he has addressed it. This is not the first time, hopefully it is the last.

OP posts:
RobertaFirmino · 20/09/2026 18:47

If you can dish it out then you can flamin' well take it too! I'm far more outraged about sexism than I am about an overweight person being told they're overweight.

Fivebyfive2 · 20/09/2026 18:54

SwanRivers · 20/09/2026 14:06

He told her: "oh fuck off If you focused more on your weight nosey what I do for my family wouldn't matter to you."

And you've had two kids with this rude prick?

I'm so sorry.

Oh come the fuck on. If it was his dad or uncle being rude and asking again and again why she wasn't doing everything for the baby and how it was a woman's role and the dad being involved was weird, would you have the same issue if op had said "fuck off you fat bastard and take a look at yourself" ?? Be honest now. I bet you wouldn't.

They were being rude and wanted a reaction, then acted hurt when they got on.

@ForFancyNavyLion I'd leave them to it, doesn't sound like you're missing out in much by not seeing them very often.

Sxwer · 20/09/2026 19:01

Fivebyfive2 · 20/09/2026 18:54

Oh come the fuck on. If it was his dad or uncle being rude and asking again and again why she wasn't doing everything for the baby and how it was a woman's role and the dad being involved was weird, would you have the same issue if op had said "fuck off you fat bastard and take a look at yourself" ?? Be honest now. I bet you wouldn't.

They were being rude and wanted a reaction, then acted hurt when they got on.

@ForFancyNavyLion I'd leave them to it, doesn't sound like you're missing out in much by not seeing them very often.

Well said.
If this was being said to a new mother, many would not suggest holding back with telling them exactly where to go, loudly.

He's a good husband, father and partner being severely tested by two crones.

My husband is a quiet man who doesn't say boo to anyone.
We simply wouldn't have returned when this happened.
He wouldn't dream of tolerating this on repeat.

Your husband sounds like a saint and I never say that.

AnnoyedAsAllHeck · 20/09/2026 19:15

If you keep pecking at someone, at some point they're going to turn it back on you.

A PP (@Dandeloosha) summed it up perfectly. He should "apologize" without apologizing.

It's getting to be you're damned if you do and damned if you don't with everything! There is always someone waiting to peck at others.

Congratulations on your baby!

boy GIF
thepariscrimefiles · 20/09/2026 19:21

How old fashioned and out of touch is your aunt's daughter? She's only in her 50s but doesn't understand paternity leave? She's also extremely rude. Does she have children and grandchildren of her own?

Your DH was also rude but I assume that her weight is her Achilles heel that she doesn't like people mentioning. She really shouldn't dish it out if she can't take it.

How close are you to this aunt and her daughter? Would it bother you to no longer have a relationship with them?

Summer26woohoo · 20/09/2026 19:23

BatchCookBabe · 20/09/2026 17:04

12 months off for the father of the baby is odd isn't it? When the mother is having the maternity leave too. Never known this happen in my life, not in the UK.

Dh did with ds3.

He had six months full paid paternity leave, followed immediately by two lots of 12 weeks of unpaid parental leave (everyone is entitled to 4 weeks per child per year and we have 3dc - luckily a new year started mid way through his first lot so he had two 12 week stints back to back). Then followed by a month of full paid accrued annual leave.

It was the best decision we made. With both dc1 and 2 he had about a month off and we couldn't have afforded any more. With dc3 we could afford it and it was a bloody fantastic year with us both off with the kids.

ForFancyNavyLion · 20/09/2026 19:30

Why are some thinking that 6 months paternity leave is odd....quite a few places do it now might as well take it. The other 6 months was unpaid but it worked out better for us and our family.

OP posts:
SparkyBlue · 20/09/2026 19:32

Sxwer · 20/09/2026 19:01

Well said.
If this was being said to a new mother, many would not suggest holding back with telling them exactly where to go, loudly.

He's a good husband, father and partner being severely tested by two crones.

My husband is a quiet man who doesn't say boo to anyone.
We simply wouldn't have returned when this happened.
He wouldn't dream of tolerating this on repeat.

Your husband sounds like a saint and I never say that.

100% agree with you. And in life you always come across these people constantly nut picking with their barbed little comments and usually depending upon getting away with their behaviour as everyone is too polite to tell them to go fuck themselves. DD had it in school two years ago with one girl who would burst into tears when challenged about her nasty comments and say “ah you all know I was only joking”. OPs DH was absolutely in the right in this situation.

Ilovelifeverymuch · 20/09/2026 19:50

SwanRivers · 20/09/2026 14:06

He told her: "oh fuck off If you focused more on your weight nosey what I do for my family wouldn't matter to you."

And you've had two kids with this rude prick?

I'm so sorry.

As opposed to her rude judgemental family 😂

HRTQueen · 20/09/2026 20:04

How hilarious like something out of a sitcom. Many times I have wished to say something like that

Yes he could have risen above her remarks or been less personal about it but we don’t always react as we should or what’s expected of us

If she isn’t willing to apologise I do see why you dh should

FudgeFudy · 20/09/2026 20:06

BatchCookBabe · 20/09/2026 17:48

I would still love to know who this magical company is who lets men have 12 months maternity leave? (When the woman is having the same leave?)

There are a fair few now - Deloitte, Aviva, M&G, Goldmans off the top of my head.

And stuff all the mithering nonsense on this thread - if the OPs pig-ignorant family are going to continually chuck shit at her husband for the heinous crime of...er...having a good job and being a good dad, then they can't get on their high horses if they get some chucked back at them. Team husband all the way.

BatchCookBabe · 20/09/2026 20:09

ForFancyNavyLion · 20/09/2026 19:30

Why are some thinking that 6 months paternity leave is odd....quite a few places do it now might as well take it. The other 6 months was unpaid but it worked out better for us and our family.

I have just genuinely never known any man do this. Like ever. I have known one man have a month off, (2 weeks paid paternity leave and 2 weeks holiday leave.) I have never known any new father have a full year off on paternity leave. It is very unusual. I don't think anyone can say it's normal.

LizzieW1969 · 20/09/2026 20:09

sausageth · 20/09/2026 14:28

This. In buckets.

Yes it's never ok to comment about someone's weight but he was clearly pushed to the limit

^I agree too, it obviously wasn’t great that he was so rude, but they had been completely out of order in the way they were goading him.