Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Secondary school does not allow D.Martens

267 replies

corporategreen · 28/11/2024 11:59

Dd in Y7 - unfortunatelly we picked the wrong school, teachers don’t stay long, behaviour is appaling, bullying is not dealt with and I even found a video on YT of a parent beating up one of her child’s colleagues - a disabled girl (apparently club feet) at the school gates.
Dd says that disable girl is a bully but I don’t know the full story.

Anyway, the school uniform rules say black shoes. I let Dd use her black DM boots. The issue took an issue with it because DMs are not school shoes - but a lot of students wear kickers that looks like boots so I really don’t see a problem.
I’ve had notes sent home and a few meetings to discuss the matter. Everytime I tell then that they should be worried and using their time and energy to fix the real problems the school have, and the shoes Dd wears does not impact her learning.

Then in one of the meetings they asked Dd why she loves her DMs so much and why she is so attached to it and she reply along the lines that it is because it makes her feel safe as they are strong and sturdy and she feels that she can kick bullies if needed.

Now, Dd has never been involved in or accused of bullying and she is going from an confident / outgoing girl to fearful and insecure. I did not know this is how she felt about the DMs.

Now the school is using what she said against us, saying that she should not be encouraged to think about violence even if it is for self defence. Dd’s life now is hell as every school staff now comments on her DMs to her daily, all day long saying ‘those are not school shoes and you are breaking the rules’

I’m trying to convince her to buy a pair of kickers just so the harassment stops and she can actually focus on learning.

Yes I already applied for school transfer.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
corporategreen · 28/11/2024 12:12

BeensOnToost · 28/11/2024 12:05

What do you mean, you're trying to c9nvince dd to wear Kickers instead? Because it sounds like you think you need her permission to tell her what she will be wearing to school.

I think she is completely justified in wanting to wear DM boots. It is not steel toe.
Also the policy say shoes but a lot of the the student wear kickers boots, not shoes. The height on the ankle is the pretty much the same for DMs and kickers

Also I resent that the school is not seeing the big picture - Dd is thinking about self defence and scares of bullies but whatever the school is doing re: bullies is not working. At all. There are fights scheduled around the outside of the school every day.

Behaviour is terrible.

Sure bullying and bad behaviour is also against school rules? Sure it impacts learning more than whatever shoes a student wears?

OP posts:
Ablondiebutagoody · 28/11/2024 12:14

Just stop wasting the schools time and get some shoes that adhere to the uniform policy. How the hell can you have "a few" meetings over such a simple issue?! Crazy.

arcticpandas · 28/11/2024 12:14

cardibach · 28/11/2024 12:05

They aren’t all steel toe capped bovver boots…

I had no idea. Used to wear dm as a teenager specifically because they made me feel safe. If I would have been attacked a kick in the groin would really hurt..

NeverDropYourMooncup · 28/11/2024 12:14

corporategreen · 28/11/2024 12:12

I think she is completely justified in wanting to wear DM boots. It is not steel toe.
Also the policy say shoes but a lot of the the student wear kickers boots, not shoes. The height on the ankle is the pretty much the same for DMs and kickers

Also I resent that the school is not seeing the big picture - Dd is thinking about self defence and scares of bullies but whatever the school is doing re: bullies is not working. At all. There are fights scheduled around the outside of the school every day.

Behaviour is terrible.

Sure bullying and bad behaviour is also against school rules? Sure it impacts learning more than whatever shoes a student wears?

You've not had a boot put into you once you're on the floor, have you?

They're tough and heavy enough to break bones in a way a crappy pair of slip-ons from Shoezone aren't.

AlertCat · 28/11/2024 12:15

Enrol her for martial arts classes, good for girls anyway to learn how to defend themselves.

Wrt the DMs, it may depend on how rigorous they are with other infringements- if it’s the same across the board for other uniform rule breeches, then you will have to change them. If dd is being singled out and other people are flouting the rules, then not so much. They need to bring equal pressure to bear on all the kids who are not in correct uniform.

TheWonderhorse · 28/11/2024 12:16

corporategreen · 28/11/2024 12:12

I think she is completely justified in wanting to wear DM boots. It is not steel toe.
Also the policy say shoes but a lot of the the student wear kickers boots, not shoes. The height on the ankle is the pretty much the same for DMs and kickers

Also I resent that the school is not seeing the big picture - Dd is thinking about self defence and scares of bullies but whatever the school is doing re: bullies is not working. At all. There are fights scheduled around the outside of the school every day.

Behaviour is terrible.

Sure bullying and bad behaviour is also against school rules? Sure it impacts learning more than whatever shoes a student wears?

She can want whatever she wants, but it's against the uniform policy and I have absolutely no idea why this is the particular hill you're going to die on. She needs different shoes.

cardibach · 28/11/2024 12:16

Kickers and DMs are totally different heights of boot.

Secondary school does not allow D.Martens
Secondary school does not allow D.Martens
Tel12 · 28/11/2024 12:17

It's a rule, she needs to abide by it. Pick the right hill to die on, this isn't it.

Paddymcpaddy · 28/11/2024 12:17

Parents like you are part of the problem, how IS the school supposed to improve if every parent thinks their child should be the exception?
Your DD saying she can ‘kick’ in her boots? Pandering to your worries to get away with wearing her cool boots, and what if she did start kicking other pupils? Thats okay is it?

cardibach · 28/11/2024 12:18

Lots of posters seem to have missed the complete change in DM design and marketing. They are just shoes and boots on the whole now. Fashion rather than work type. No steel toe cap (they may still do some with them, but on the whole) and many are much thinner and softer leather than they used to be.
The boots are still boots though, so don’t fit a school shoes policy.

LIZS · 28/11/2024 12:18

Never known a school accept dms as footwear. Her response was ridiculous. She could wear regular shoes and keep them for activities outside school, does she regularly kick others and flout rules?

PigOrChupacabra · 28/11/2024 12:19

Can she wear DM shoes instead? I have worn them for every semi smart job that also involved lots of movement and all through school. Both lace up and buckle are good.

cardibach · 28/11/2024 12:19

PigOrChupacabra · 28/11/2024 12:19

Can she wear DM shoes instead? I have worn them for every semi smart job that also involved lots of movement and all through school. Both lace up and buckle are good.

I keep saying this. Schools don’t usually mind DM shoes, I’ve worked in a lot over 35 years…

BaklavaRocks · 28/11/2024 12:21

The DMs are the least of your problems.

Suck it up, buy her some appropriate school shoes, then think about whether this is really the school for her or whether you should find one that better suits her and you.

PrivacyPussyPasta · 28/11/2024 12:23

Buy her some proper school shoes and stop being a pain.

EdgarAllenRaven · 28/11/2024 12:25

Get her some shoes, but look to change schools ASAP

MsTeatime · 28/11/2024 12:26

Uniform policies are a tool schools use to manage behaviour. Ever notice how the failing schools with tough new heads brought in to turn them around go completely anal on uniform policies and dress codes? Win the little battles and you address some of the issues that cause the bigger problems is the thinking. By causing such a drama over these boots (boots were banned as school uniform even back in the 90s) you are part of the problem you say you want to see fixed.

WhatMe123 · 28/11/2024 12:27

I don't see dm boots as school shoes sorry op

Dishwashersaurous · 28/11/2024 12:27

The school uniform doesn't allow boots. So get her some school shoes and tell her she has to wear them.

All the other stuff is just noise. She's not following the uniform rules

corporategreen · 28/11/2024 12:29

ByHardyRubyEagle · 28/11/2024 12:07

I don’t think the shoes are the real issue here I think it’s your attitude honestly, your daughter also thinks of the school as being full of bullies and you are reiterating this to her. Fair enough if it’s a rough school, but I’m not sure your views are helpful in this situation. I don’t think I can believe a public video or a parent ‘beating up’ a disabled child either.

I sent an email with the video link to the HT.
She replied saying she had no idea the video was out there and she was going to get it removed.

I asked what steps have been taken about the situation and she explained that it is a complicated case involving various family members from both families, including the adults, and that the police is involved. Also both students involved are suspendend.

OP posts:
Hoppinggreen · 28/11/2024 12:31

corporategreen · 28/11/2024 12:29

I sent an email with the video link to the HT.
She replied saying she had no idea the video was out there and she was going to get it removed.

I asked what steps have been taken about the situation and she explained that it is a complicated case involving various family members from both families, including the adults, and that the police is involved. Also both students involved are suspendend.

HT gave you all that information did she?

Another2Cats · 28/11/2024 12:31

corporategreen · 28/11/2024 12:12

I think she is completely justified in wanting to wear DM boots. It is not steel toe.
Also the policy say shoes but a lot of the the student wear kickers boots, not shoes. The height on the ankle is the pretty much the same for DMs and kickers

Also I resent that the school is not seeing the big picture - Dd is thinking about self defence and scares of bullies but whatever the school is doing re: bullies is not working. At all. There are fights scheduled around the outside of the school every day.

Behaviour is terrible.

Sure bullying and bad behaviour is also against school rules? Sure it impacts learning more than whatever shoes a student wears?

"Also the policy say shoes but a lot of the the student wear kickers boots, not shoes."

The actual Kickers boots, like the Kade or Kenzi boot? Not their Hi shoes?

If that's what you're talking about then you're totally right to complain that one brand of boot is allowed but another isn't.

Image of Kickers Kade boot below.

Secondary school does not allow D.Martens
Resitinas · 28/11/2024 12:32

These entitled posts drive me up the wall.

OP, here it is spelled out:

You're responsible as a parent for ensuring your daughter is in receipt of a suitable full-time education.

To fulfil this responsibility, you've chosen to send her to a school.

The school has rules around behaviour and uniform. Very standard. In choosing to send her there, you have also by default chosen to accept these rules.

You must therefore ensure she is dressed in line with the uniform policy of the school or expect there to be sanctions.

Whether or not you feel the boots don't impact her learning is irrelevant. Whether or not your DD feels "safer" in them is irrelevant. Whether or not your DD loves her DM boots is irrelevant. Whether or not you think the rule is stupid is irrelevant. Whether or not every other student in the place is wearing what you think are non-policy shoes is irrelevant. Your concern is your DD.

Follow the rules of the school you chose until such time as you can choose a different option to fulfil your parental responsibility.

adulthoodisajoke · 28/11/2024 12:32

starting to think this is a wind up post

OP seems to be ignoring all reasonable responses

BobbyBiscuits · 28/11/2024 12:33

You can get DM school shoes. They don't have the yellow. But if their boots, like 8 holes plus, it's not uniform compliant. It needs to be a shoe.
Or if she likes kickers get her those. To me kickers have the same level of colour/embellishment as DMs? So just buy plain black DM shoes? But it's not my rules.
They're not complaining about the actual brand, more the colour/style surely?
It's not really the right school if you're not keen on that level of rules. I don't blame you, I wouldn't like it either. But it is what it is.

Swipe left for the next trending thread