Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think separated parents have the best of both worlds?

241 replies

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 12:10

I know - sounds like a goady title and I don’t intend it to.

I am specifically talking about parents who have split and one parent had the children for at least some of the time.

I don’t catch a break. I’m either working, caring for children or on the very rare occasion I am not doing either I’m doing household tasks and they really do need doing no matter how low you make your standards. Life is relentless and if I am honest pretty horrendous.

I know DH should be doing more but I can’t get through to him. We’ve had any number of conversations and they just end in sniping and bad feelings. Please don’t tell me to talk to him; you can’t and it just wastes everybody’s time.

One or my friends has split from her partner and she gets a day every weekend (child goes on the Saturday evening so she gets that ‘off’) and she collects him Sunday evening. Sleeping through one day a week and a lie in the next day with a full day to yourself feels like untold luxury to me at the moment. And she has an evening free in the week too.

I know people will say to do it then if it’s that easy and I have thought about it. But it obviously is a massive thing to break up a family and I don’t think it would make the children happy, just me and in many ways I’m the least important one.

OP posts:
SnowflakeSmasher86 · 16/11/2024 17:01

Ponderingwindow · 16/11/2024 17:00

Just focusing on me, the mother. If I wake up with a debilitating migraine, I can tap DH on the shoulder and tell him he is in charge until we can work as a team again. Having that flexibility and give and take is priceless.

the best situation is marrying someone who believes in an egalitarian relationship. All you need is a spouse who will be in charge of the kids while you get your time to do whatever it is you need or want to do. That is much better than a custody schedule

Yeah, that’s a bit horse/stable door though isn’t it. It sounds like OP’s husband definitely isn’t that type. So where to go from where she actually is? A Time Machine to choose a more involved husband isn’t really an option at this point.

Guavafish1 · 16/11/2024 17:07

Not fair for kids

Errors · 16/11/2024 17:38

Guavafish1 · 16/11/2024 17:07

Not fair for kids

What isnt?

gcsedilemma · 16/11/2024 17:46

I know what you mean OP and I've often thought this myself. However helpful one's partner is, a whole weekend to oneself every fortnight, knowing that the children are happy and safe with their father must be BLISS!!

HarraKiri · 16/11/2024 18:57

gcsedilemma · 16/11/2024 17:46

I know what you mean OP and I've often thought this myself. However helpful one's partner is, a whole weekend to oneself every fortnight, knowing that the children are happy and safe with their father must be BLISS!!

You're assuming "happy and safe". What if they get strapped into their car seats sobbing because they don't want to go?

What if dad's new girlfriend tells your 10yr old daughter that she needs to lose weight, and lets the younger kids gorge on sweets and chocolate, while the 10yr old is given an apple?

If you know your kids are desperately unhappy with him and miss you terribly, but a court decides they must see him once a fortnight regardless, do you still think it's easier when they aren't there? Or do you think your whole "relaxing child free weekend" is spent hurting for your babies who just want to be with mum and can't?

I can't deny I love not being with my ex. I will happily do everything 24/7, if I don't have to live with him, walking on eggshells. But honestly, my life would have been easier as a widow than as a single parent.

I would sacrifice my two nights child free a month, and spend every waking minute with my small kids, if it meant I didn't have to spend my time without them.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 19:14

@HarraKiri that is kind of the point of the thread. I’d be happier, the children wouldn’t be.

OP posts:
Plastictrees · 16/11/2024 19:21

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 19:14

@HarraKiri that is kind of the point of the thread. I’d be happier, the children wouldn’t be.

How do you know they wouldn’t be? Presumably you would be happier. You would have more energy and be more able to engage with them fully. Children will notice this. And notice how things are now.

Don’t use your children as an excuse for staying in a miserable and unfair relationship. Your DH needs to step up. But you don’t seem to think he will, but equally you don’t want to consider leaving. Be careful that you aren’t keeping yourself stuck here. You do have options and choices.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 19:46

I’m not using them as an excuse.

If I left DH, we would (the children and I) have to move to a less affluent, more run down part of town, ds wouldn’t be able to go to the primary school he’s going to next year, I’d have to work full time and they’d be in breakfast and after school clubs five days a week once at school and nursery full time. Longer term they wouldn’t have the stability I want for them. To be honest I’m not convinced children are essentially selfless beings happy to accept less if mum is happy!

OP posts:
Colourfulduvets · 16/11/2024 20:05

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 19:46

I’m not using them as an excuse.

If I left DH, we would (the children and I) have to move to a less affluent, more run down part of town, ds wouldn’t be able to go to the primary school he’s going to next year, I’d have to work full time and they’d be in breakfast and after school clubs five days a week once at school and nursery full time. Longer term they wouldn’t have the stability I want for them. To be honest I’m not convinced children are essentially selfless beings happy to accept less if mum is happy!

Hang on, I thought us separated parents had the best of both worlds?
Doesn't sound like it does it? 🙄

Sugarflub · 16/11/2024 20:17

To be honest I’m not convinced children are essentially selfless beings happy to accept less if mum is happy!

They'll pick up on the resentment and the fact that you're miserable, seeing their dad not bother to support you around the home isn't going to do wonders for them either. Just be honest and say you want the money rather than try to frame it as martyring yourself for the sake of your children.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:17

Ah, you’re back.

Much as I don’t want to bite, what in the above for me isn’t good?

I don’t mind living somewhere less affluent, I’m not going to school, I don’t mind working full time, my ‘days off’ are far harder and more exhausting than my working days.

So what is it you’re poking at now?

OP posts:
FromWalesAndBackAgain · 16/11/2024 20:22

A happy home is priceless

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:24

Sugarflub · 16/11/2024 20:17

To be honest I’m not convinced children are essentially selfless beings happy to accept less if mum is happy!

They'll pick up on the resentment and the fact that you're miserable, seeing their dad not bother to support you around the home isn't going to do wonders for them either. Just be honest and say you want the money rather than try to frame it as martyring yourself for the sake of your children.

Interesting take on things.

I’m very clear it’s not for my financial gain but the children’s. While I don’t earn huge amounts at the moment due to being part time, if I was to work full time my income would be around £50,000. Not exactly dizzy heights but adequate, especially as I had an inheritance young, bought a house outright with it and still have it, though if we were to divorce (we won’t) that would obviously be an asset. So I’m not penniless or in a position where I ‘need’ the money.

I think if you asked DH why he stays, why he married me in the first place, his answer would be ‘sex (not that there’s much of that) childcare and housework’ and I wonder if you’d be as sniffy about that and say ‘just admit you’re only with her because she looks after your children and cleans your house.’ Probably not.

OP posts:
Sugarflub · 16/11/2024 20:34

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:24

Interesting take on things.

I’m very clear it’s not for my financial gain but the children’s. While I don’t earn huge amounts at the moment due to being part time, if I was to work full time my income would be around £50,000. Not exactly dizzy heights but adequate, especially as I had an inheritance young, bought a house outright with it and still have it, though if we were to divorce (we won’t) that would obviously be an asset. So I’m not penniless or in a position where I ‘need’ the money.

I think if you asked DH why he stays, why he married me in the first place, his answer would be ‘sex (not that there’s much of that) childcare and housework’ and I wonder if you’d be as sniffy about that and say ‘just admit you’re only with her because she looks after your children and cleans your house.’ Probably not.

I'd find it equally pathetic if that helps, if not more. Do you think he's only with you for those reasons? Have some self respect for goodness sake! I hope none of your children are girls, they learn so much from modelling relationships they experience in the early years, be sad to not break the cycle and have them accept a man like this, ew.

Plastictrees · 16/11/2024 20:35

You just seem to have a very fixed and negative mind set, catastrophising future scenarios and not considering alternatives.

If you genuinely think your DH married you for sex, childcare and housework then that’s really sad. Some women have no options available to them but you do; you have a decent income, own a house outright, live in an affluent area etc. You seem so resigned and disempowered for your position.

Children internalise and emulate their parents relationship. They absolutely pick up on atmospheres and tensions and resentments. Think what they are learning from you, what you are teaching them. It takes more than finances to have a stable and secure home. You don’t want to change the status quo but you aren’t happy with it either, so it seems you are stuck.

notbelieved · 16/11/2024 20:36

I don’t catch a break. I’m either working, caring for children or on the very rare occasion I am not doing either I’m doing household tasks and they really do need doing no matter how low you make your standards. Life is relentless and if I am honest pretty horrendous

I've been single for 15 years. Yes to all of the above.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:40

I’ve plenty of self respect, but more than that, I’ve got pragmatism. I recognise that much as it would be lovely to be cherished for my beautiful looks and sparkling personality, the reality is that I am an ordinary woman, pleasant enough to look at but nothing remarkable, like hundreds of other women. I am nice enough to be around (well, I was, not sure about now!) passingly intelligent and good at cooking, childcare and housework.

Like hundreds if not thousands of other women. If DH hadn’t met and married me, he’d have met and married someone very similar to me, and I’d probably have met and married someone similar to him.

Marriage may be a romantic concept in modern times but it traditionally was a legal contract and it still is. Squawking at me to ‘have some self respect’ is faintly amusing if only because that’s exactly what marriage is, it’s literally a sexual and financial contract.

OP posts:
Plastictrees · 16/11/2024 20:47

Marriage is not a sexual contract. We don’t live in the Middle Ages. Plenty of people - normal, ordinary people - manage to have marriages that are happy and equal. It is hard when children are young and you have to work at it, but your DH is patently not pulling his weight here. Where is his regard for your feelings? What would happen if you showed him this thread, or just voiced your feelings honestly as you have here?

I think you are normalising his learned ineptness/ weaponised incompetence by telling yourself that wanting more is some sort of silly fairytale. It isn’t. You don’t sound pragmatic, you sound despondent.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:54

@Plastictrees you possibly missed my saying that I do think I am quite depressed at the moment. I can see things objectively if you like and recognise they won’t be like this forever but ‘long enough’ is my feeling.

I work Mondays, Tuesdays and Fridays. Mondays and Tuesdays and Fridays I get up, get the children ready, teeth brushed, dressed, out of the door and to nursery. It’s always a rush but in many ways that’s the easy part, they are fed and cared for there. I then go onto work myself, it’s a frantic job with no breaks to speak of, finish work, back to collect children, home, they are tired, fretful, squabbly, clingy, whiny. Bath time and out of bath, pyjamas, teeth, stories, a thousand squabbles, finally in bed around half seven, and down I come to the carnage that is my house, I also have work to do myself in that time, collapse exhausted into bed, then the night shift starts.

And then it starts again.

I gave a hit of help on Friday, usually, and I know I should not call it help, but I don’t know what else to say. DH usually works from home. Wednesdays and Thursdays should be theoretically a break and yes it’s nice not having to charge out of the house, we do groups and little activities they enjoy and I’m not a monster, of course I enjoy seeing them having fun and they are adorable and loving and loved. But it’s relentless. They take toys off each other, scream, slap one another, tell tales ‘DD pushed me … DD hit me …’ it goes quiet and I find them both immersed in the cupboard under the stairs trashing it or they are in a bedroom being adorable listening to the tonie box and I’m thinking how sweet then someone cries or wails or there is a thud of doom. Even if I start something I can’t finish it. I have absolutely no time for me. I do get that I wouldn’t have much but no time to read, be still and calm, breathe, none.

I’d probably be OK with that but I’m so tired and I think that’s why I’m a bit depressed. She slept through a few times last week after some sleep training (only gentle before anyone annihilates me) and I thought I’d cracked it but she’s waking up again, I’m not sure what to do really. Most nights I only get 4-5 hours and it’s broken. I look grey and washed out, circles under my eyes, I’m snappy and emotional and quick to be offended and upset which is a complete antithesis of the person I was before. I was always chilled, laid back, shrug it off. But the years of bad sleep have taken their toll.

so this is partly depression talking. I know, objectively, soon I’ll have two school age children, I’ll have time, I’ll have a bit more peace, I’ll have an easier time of things, nappies, pushchairs, high chairs and sippy cups will be gone, never to return, my head knows this. My heart - not so much.

OP posts:
Colourfulduvets · 16/11/2024 20:58

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 20:17

Ah, you’re back.

Much as I don’t want to bite, what in the above for me isn’t good?

I don’t mind living somewhere less affluent, I’m not going to school, I don’t mind working full time, my ‘days off’ are far harder and more exhausting than my working days.

So what is it you’re poking at now?

You really are quite an unpleasant person.
I hope you find whatever it is you are looking for and that the nirvana of being a separated parent is everything you think it will be.

ClosetChroll · 16/11/2024 20:59

Parents who stay together have the best of all worlds. Splitting is bad.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 21:02

@Colourfulduvets I honestly think you really have completely misunderstood what the threads about. It isn’t me looking for the nirvana of being a separated parent at all. You seem convinced I’m debating the pros and cons of me leaving, despite me saying over and over that I am not. And then when I point this out to you, you become personally insulting. It is tedious to be honest, really it is. I did a wee search - twelve posts, all of them poking at me, complaining at me, insulting me. Give it a rest Hmm

OP posts:
ThatIsNotMyNameSoWhyAreYouCallingMeThat · 16/11/2024 21:06

SnowflakeSmasher86 · 16/11/2024 17:01

Yeah, that’s a bit horse/stable door though isn’t it. It sounds like OP’s husband definitely isn’t that type. So where to go from where she actually is? A Time Machine to choose a more involved husband isn’t really an option at this point.

Presumably it was obvious after baby 1 though. Or 2 at a push.

Adventurebayholiday · 16/11/2024 21:09

We only have two children, @ThatIsNotMyNameSoWhyAreYouCallingMeThat . Although it does sometimes feel like more!

OP posts:
Colourfulduvets · 16/11/2024 21:11

No I absolutely don't get you at all.
This whole thread is baffling to be honest & I made the mistake of not unwatching it. Off to click that button now.

And my posts to you were not all unpleasant at all. Yes, at the beginning I definitely took offence to your glib comment that your separated friend has it made. But then I tried to offer advice based on my own experience so it seems you have misunderstood me at times too.

I honestly wish you luck with whatever it is you want or are looking for. It seems you don't know but if you do choose to leave I hope it works out and that you enjoy your child free time and your weekend lie ins

Swipe left for the next trending thread