Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shouted at by male midwife mid panic attack

376 replies

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 12:05

Hi all,

Yesterday, I attended the Early Pregnancy Unit for a suspected miscarriage. Due to complex PTSD from a violent sexual assault, I generally can't see male providers without prior notice, and sometimes only with my husband present in regards to female examinations. This has never been an issue. At my usual hospital, this is flagged on my chart to avoid misunderstandings and so I don’t need to explain. However, since I was bleeding, my midwife recommended I go to a closer hospital, where I’d been seen before (without any issues). I take it on board I should have mentioned it, however as I’d been seen before in the unit only a few weeks before and I’d only seen women providers. Again, I accept this was my mistake.

Unfortunately, when I entered the exam room, the midwife was male. I immediately panicked and explained that I didn’t know there would be a man present. He seemed visibly offended and dismissive, telling me to leave the room in an upset tone. Despite being visibly distressed and bleeding from a miscarriage, I ended up trying to comfort him by explaining my history. The situation escalated with him shouting at me, and none of the nurses intervened. They blocked the door and wouldn’t allow me to leave.

I was able to get out and to the reception, where I requested to speak to someone in charge so they could help. The male midwife followed me and continued shouting, saying I had verbally attacked him. He even told me to "get over myself" and shared that he also had a history of panic disorder. I felt utterly humiliated and helpless. Eventually, the lead midwife took me to a quiet room, but no one apologized or acknowledged his behavior.

What’s most upsetting is that during both a miscarriage and after sharing my trauma history, I was shown no compassion or sensitivity by this midwife, which is the complete opposite of the amazing care I’ve always received from the NHS, especially during feminine examinations.

I’m considering filing a formal complaint, but I’m worried it won’t be taken seriously. I was later told that others on the unit are afraid of this man and won’t speak up. I went to PALS, and they advised I file a formal complaint with the hospital, but I'm unsure if it will actually lead to any action.

I’m not entirely sure what outcome I want to see, except that I believe the midwife should have shown more compassion in such a sensitive situation. Has anyone been in a similar situation? Will my complaint be taken seriously, and where is the best place to escalate it?

Thanks in advance for any advice.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/10/2024 17:19

If course I understand why. You don't know me. You don't know what I've been through.

Your personal experiences aren't relevant to my point. You don't have to have a reason to object to intimate care from a man, as a woman.

TrippySkip · 16/10/2024 17:19

ScaryM0nster · 16/10/2024 17:11

It sounds like both you and he could have handled things better in the early stages - and you’re well aware of that.

In his position, as a professional doing his job he shouldn’t have to deal with anything that he perceives as aggression or discrimination and it’s very likely that your initial reaction to him came across as one or both. Not that your reaction was unreasonable, but you were the person prior to that who had the opportunity to prevent the situation occurring. He didn’t.

However - you each then had choices about how you responded. Give the situation, as a professional he should have offloaded things to a colleague / senior staff member immediately. Not tried to continue things. Not doing that was a major short falling on his part. That merits you raising feedback for. If you do it through PALS then they should also be able to support you with finding the most effective way to avoid any similar issues occurring with being assigned to staff that are unsuitable for you.

the being told would have to wait thing is unfortunate, and there was probably a better way to convey the message but in practical terms that will have been what needed to happen. Not as a punishment but purely because he was seeing you because he was available. If you can’t see him you’ll need to wait for someone suitable to become available. There’s a constructive way to convey that message and an unhelpful way though.

aggression or discrimination and it’s very likely that your initial reaction to him came across as one or both

How?? The OP was distressed. She was having a miscarriage and tried to ressure and comfort him. Show me the aggression. He was the one that became aggressive.

And the discrimination line is ridiculous. Any woman asking that a woman sees her for an intimate examination is not being sexist. Not even a bit. And if the male midwife doesn’t understand that, he needs to leave asap.

ahemfem · 16/10/2024 17:20

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 17:18

I am absolutely certain this man shouted at me and shouted at me multiple times. I’m absolutely certain he said he had history of panic attack while shouting at me. I’m absolutely certain without a doubt that no one helped me while I was distressed.

Then please do follow up your complaint as that is unacceptable

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 17:20

piccolorhinoceros · 16/10/2024 16:32

There are a lot of things not adding up. Why were there three nurses in a room with a midwife? If the unit was closing why was the waiting room full? Was OP possibly verbally abusive and unaware of it due to her panic?

I will add that George’s is a teaching hospital. When I saw the next person who gave me my scan and confirmedmy diagnosis there was what I believe to be a student in the room as well as a health assistant. No one identified anyone to me. It’s very likely there were students in the room with him. I have no idea who these people were. I just know there were multiple people in the room.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/10/2024 17:20

Because he has no context and probably just thinks oh another person being sexist.

Then he and badly needs training in patient centred care and understanding consent.

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 17:21

TrippySkip · 16/10/2024 17:19

aggression or discrimination and it’s very likely that your initial reaction to him came across as one or both

How?? The OP was distressed. She was having a miscarriage and tried to ressure and comfort him. Show me the aggression. He was the one that became aggressive.

And the discrimination line is ridiculous. Any woman asking that a woman sees her for an intimate examination is not being sexist. Not even a bit. And if the male midwife doesn’t understand that, he needs to leave asap.

Thank you for this. I wasn’t abusive. I didn’t swear at anyone. And I definitely didn’t shout. I felt like I was choking.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/10/2024 17:22

And the discrimination line is ridiculous. Any woman asking that a woman sees her for an intimate examination is not being sexist. Not even a bit. And if the male midwife doesn’t understand that, he needs to leave asap.

This. And this is why men shouldn't do these jobs, unless they fully demonstrate that they understand women's dignity and boundaries.

TrippySkip · 16/10/2024 17:23

ahemfem · 16/10/2024 17:19

Because he has no context and probably just thinks oh another person being sexist. I'm not saying she was sexist was I. Nuance.

Edited

Again. If a male midwife thinks a woman wanting a same sex midwife for vaginal examinations is being ‘sexist’, he should be sacked. Or at least undergo extensive training. What context do you think is needed??

In any case, she explained and he still followed her aggressively and shouted.

Haggia · 16/10/2024 17:23

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 15:35

It’s not the nurses, it’s the midwife’s behavior I’m upset with. Sure they could have done more of better, like trying to escalate the situation but the midwife acted horribly

If nurses blocked the door to stop you leaving, which is backed up by you very clearly and tellingly describing it as “managed to get out” I would say that’s extremely serious indeed. Were they restraining you?

That doesn’t sound like any kind of protocol, it sounds like holding you against your will.

Also, for the male midwife to chase you and yell at you like that, he must be unhinged.

What hospital is this OP? The staff sound like something out of American Horror Story!

Sorry you have to deal with this aftermath, rather than focusing on your personal grief. I’m sure the last thing you feel like doing is raising a complaint.

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 17:24

ahemfem · 16/10/2024 16:23

I immediately panicked and explained that I didn’t know there would be a man present. what did this look like? Was it loud? Screaming? Or calm? I think if you'd explained you're sorry you have a note on your file about not seeing a male due to a difficult history the situation may have gone differently. With no context I can see why he may have been triggered into just thinking you're being sexist.

However if he'd managed to control his emotions and listen he would have understood I'd have hoped.

Sorry you had to deal with this.

i walked in, saw him, and I started trying to turn around for the exit, said “I am sorry, I didn’t know there would be a man here” while started to hyperventilate. The nurses blocked me here. I think I even leaned over to bend down with my hands on my knees. When I looked up and he looked offended and upset and told me to get out of his room and go wait some more, I immediately started trying to explain bc I was worried I had offended him and I started crying. I didn’t shout. I could barely speak. I felt trapped. Not angry or shouty, but more scared and defenseless.

OP posts:
TrippySkip · 16/10/2024 17:25

*The situation escalated with him shouting at me, and none of the nurses intervened.

The male midwife followed me and continued shouting, saying I had verbally attacked him.

He even told me to "get over myself" *

How any of the gaslighters here can say that it was the OP being aggressive and abusive is beyond me.

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 17:26

Haggia · 16/10/2024 17:23

If nurses blocked the door to stop you leaving, which is backed up by you very clearly and tellingly describing it as “managed to get out” I would say that’s extremely serious indeed. Were they restraining you?

That doesn’t sound like any kind of protocol, it sounds like holding you against your will.

Also, for the male midwife to chase you and yell at you like that, he must be unhinged.

What hospital is this OP? The staff sound like something out of American Horror Story!

Sorry you have to deal with this aftermath, rather than focusing on your personal grief. I’m sure the last thing you feel like doing is raising a complaint.

they kept standing in the way of me trying to exit. One I think put her hands on me to guide me towards the bed for examination. I tried to leave multiple times including initially when I realized he was a male midwife. I tried to explain nicely and tried to leave again. Then I started explaining again and when he started shouting they were in The way of the door.

perhaps they didn’t realize what they were doing but they weren’t helping me leave which is all I wanted to do.

OP posts:
ahemfem · 16/10/2024 17:26

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/10/2024 17:19

If course I understand why. You don't know me. You don't know what I've been through.

Your personal experiences aren't relevant to my point. You don't have to have a reason to object to intimate care from a man, as a woman.

Do I not? OK then..

Canalboat · 16/10/2024 17:26

I would expect an HCP, especially in this kind of role, to have had some experience or thought about this kind of scenario and how they should need to respond. It isn’t so unusual. It is certainly not discriminatory. You should definitely complain about this.

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 17:27

Haggia · 16/10/2024 17:23

If nurses blocked the door to stop you leaving, which is backed up by you very clearly and tellingly describing it as “managed to get out” I would say that’s extremely serious indeed. Were they restraining you?

That doesn’t sound like any kind of protocol, it sounds like holding you against your will.

Also, for the male midwife to chase you and yell at you like that, he must be unhinged.

What hospital is this OP? The staff sound like something out of American Horror Story!

Sorry you have to deal with this aftermath, rather than focusing on your personal grief. I’m sure the last thing you feel like doing is raising a complaint.

It was at St Georges hospital in SW london

OP posts:
ahemfem · 16/10/2024 17:27

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/10/2024 17:20

Because he has no context and probably just thinks oh another person being sexist.

Then he and badly needs training in patient centred care and understanding consent.

I agree

ScaryM0nster · 16/10/2024 17:28

TrippySkip · 16/10/2024 17:19

aggression or discrimination and it’s very likely that your initial reaction to him came across as one or both

How?? The OP was distressed. She was having a miscarriage and tried to ressure and comfort him. Show me the aggression. He was the one that became aggressive.

And the discrimination line is ridiculous. Any woman asking that a woman sees her for an intimate examination is not being sexist. Not even a bit. And if the male midwife doesn’t understand that, he needs to leave asap.

Magical how you seem to know what happened despite not having been there.

if you read my post carefully you’ll see that my comments were all about how things are perceived by the individual.

it’s pretty common for one persons fear to come across as aggression or confrontation to another.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 16/10/2024 17:28

I immediately started trying to explain bc I was worried I had offended him and I started crying. I didn’t shout. I could barely speak. I felt trapped. Not angry or shouty, but more scared and defenseless.

I've actually been in a similar position with a male bully at work and a scenario that went from ha ha bants to really quite intimidating very quickly. He got in front of the door and blocked my exit, either knowingly or not, and I reacted like you. I then burst into tears and hated myself for it.

I believe you and I sympathise Flowers

TrippySkip · 16/10/2024 17:29

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 17:24

i walked in, saw him, and I started trying to turn around for the exit, said “I am sorry, I didn’t know there would be a man here” while started to hyperventilate. The nurses blocked me here. I think I even leaned over to bend down with my hands on my knees. When I looked up and he looked offended and upset and told me to get out of his room and go wait some more, I immediately started trying to explain bc I was worried I had offended him and I started crying. I didn’t shout. I could barely speak. I felt trapped. Not angry or shouty, but more scared and defenseless.

OP I do not think you need to defend yourself further.

Please take time to try and relax and look after yourself a little bit now. Chat to your partner. Start to come to terms with the loss you have suffered today.

Ask your partner to draft a letter tomorrow. Your OP is fine as it is.

People’s opinions here don’t actually matter.

That midwife and the whole department at the very least need some training. When I worked in Perinatal mental health, we were very supportive of women referred to our service who had been victims of sexual assault. We would meet with midwives and try and think about the best way to support the pregnancy and delivery. Trying to understand how a woman might feel about a vagina delivery. Especially an instrumental one. Would a planned section be better etc? That department is dreadful and they did not deliver a patient-centred approach. I am sorry. You are in the right and do not doubt yourself.

Uselessatbeingaperson · 16/10/2024 17:30

Bypass PALS and go direct to the chief exec.

TrippySkip · 16/10/2024 17:30

ScaryM0nster · 16/10/2024 17:28

Magical how you seem to know what happened despite not having been there.

if you read my post carefully you’ll see that my comments were all about how things are perceived by the individual.

it’s pretty common for one persons fear to come across as aggression or confrontation to another.

And a hcp needs to get a grip and distinguish a frightened traumatised patient from an abusive and aggressive one.

diddl · 16/10/2024 17:31

All this could have been avoided by patients being told that there was a male midwife on duty & was that OK or would they rather wait & see a woman?

Uselessatbeingaperson · 16/10/2024 17:31

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TrippySkip · 16/10/2024 17:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What do you mean by this? It’s pretty obvious what she meant. 🙄🙄🙄She thought she was seeing a woman. And then she clocked that the midwife she was going to see was actually a man.

Haggia · 16/10/2024 17:33

ThisBrickWriter · 16/10/2024 17:27

It was at St Georges hospital in SW london

Thanks, I think my post landed just after you mentioned it. I’ve seen it on TV. So all this happened in that waiting room you see on the TV? How awful.

I’m not surprised you panicked, the room must have felt claustrophobic all those people in there.

Swipe left for the next trending thread