Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the hilarity just wasn’t necessary?

408 replies

DonnySue · 21/07/2024 20:41

Was at my grandmas earlier with DD (9). My sister, her husband and their kids were there too. We were talking about history and I was absolutely fascinated by it (I love history, especially British history) and at one point I took myself outside into the garden to have a few minutes of thinking and reflection on what we’d been talking about.
DD came out to ask what I was doing and I said “just having a few minutes to reflect on what we’ve been chatting about”.

She went back inside and then I heard howls of laughter coming from the living room. DD had told them what I’d said and they were all in stitches over it. It really ruined my thoughts and I tried to get the topic back up and running but sister kept saying everyone was still reflecting - cue more hilarity.

was what I said really that bloody funny?? Pissed off but also a bit embarrassed 😞

OP posts:
serialcatbuyer · 22/07/2024 00:53

You weren't at a museum though you were just having a conversation. I would expect this from Frasier Crane

Haggisfish3 · 22/07/2024 00:59

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 22/07/2024 00:32

Nothing wrong with thinking and reflecting, no, @Wheresthebeach - but did the OP need to tell anyone?

When her dd asked her what she was doing, why not just say she was out for a bit of fresh air or a few minutes quiet?

Edited

Because why should she not share it? What if dd also has thoughts and wants moments like this? Op is normalising it. Totally fine. There was no judgement attached to the comment from op or her dd.

Starseeking · 22/07/2024 01:10

This reminds me about the lady in the Sistine Chapel, and if my sister did the same as you, I'd laugh too as it sounds like such an odd thing to do that it would be funny (sorry OP).

TheOriginalEmu · 22/07/2024 01:20

No wonder we have such a problem with bullying in schools if this how grown adults are to someone who’s doing NOTHING wrong, just a bit different to what the would do.
the comments on this post and the experience of people laughing at you when you’re clearly not in on the joke is just deeply unpleasant and unnecessary.
you can think ‘oh that’s a bit odd’ without laughing and acting like twat. It’s more odd to be so cruel about someone imo.

this post is grim. I’m sorry @AllProperTeaIsTheft try not to be too upset by these awful people. ❤️

XChrome · 22/07/2024 01:23

TheOriginalEmu · 22/07/2024 01:20

No wonder we have such a problem with bullying in schools if this how grown adults are to someone who’s doing NOTHING wrong, just a bit different to what the would do.
the comments on this post and the experience of people laughing at you when you’re clearly not in on the joke is just deeply unpleasant and unnecessary.
you can think ‘oh that’s a bit odd’ without laughing and acting like twat. It’s more odd to be so cruel about someone imo.

this post is grim. I’m sorry @AllProperTeaIsTheft try not to be too upset by these awful people. ❤️

Totally agree. Laughing at somebody for thinking? Who does that? That's oddly immature behavior for any adult. Being thoughtful, otoh, is not odd.

TheOriginalEmu · 22/07/2024 01:24

fleabites · 21/07/2024 21:20

It's really odd behaviour.
Almost as odd as that Sistine Chapel Screamer Woman.

You could have just made a mental note to return to the topic once you got home and had a moment to yourself rather than take yourself off into the garden to reflect.

But why should she? Is she hurting anyone by what she did? No. It’s really mean to laugh at someone when they’re obviously not amused.

TheOriginalEmu · 22/07/2024 01:28

incognitogenius · 21/07/2024 21:35

The hilarity was totally necessary 🤣 just join in with it too! It will (inevitably!) become a family joke anyway. FWIW I don’t think they were exactly laughing AT you

They absolutely were laughing at her, at the very least once it was clear she didn’t find it funny then the adult thing to do is stop laughing, apologise and move on. Making something a family joke when the butt of the joke isn’t amused is not a family joke, it’s family bullying and it’s deeply unpleasant.

XChrome · 22/07/2024 01:28

DeadbeatYoda · 21/07/2024 23:46

Yep, that's what I wondered too. The hobby, the 'reflection', the difficulty understanding the weirdness of the behaviour. Don't get me wrong, I'm from an ND family so wouldn't have thought much about a situation like this but undiagnosed ASD is certainly coming to mind here.

You have got to be kidding me. You think it's abnormal for a grown adult to want to reflect on the subject of a conversation?
This is not weird. This is what intelligent people do.

CoalTit · 22/07/2024 01:30

Doesn't anyone here relate to the OP's decision to leave the room once the conversation turned to Donald Trump?

XChrome · 22/07/2024 01:34

ThatTealViewer · 21/07/2024 23:03

I have postgrad qualifications in a closely related area. Yes, it’s extremely interesting. Finding it interesting isn’t what’s odd about your behaviour. I also don’t understand why it’s being presented as ‘cleverness’. It’s not ‘clever’, just odd.

You can wonder, ponder, think and research alone. You don’t leave a gathering to sit and do so. It’s strange behaviour. As you must know, as you live in the world and see how other people behave.

I’d have laughed, as well.

Nope. The problem is that many people are shallow and don't reflect on issues enough, so they assume other, more thoughtful people are strange to do so.
I'd go off by myself for a minute if I had loud, giggly people in my house too. You can't think too deeply with that going on.

SheldonsMom · 22/07/2024 01:37

TheOriginalEmu · 22/07/2024 01:24

But why should she? Is she hurting anyone by what she did? No. It’s really mean to laugh at someone when they’re obviously not amused.

Is she hurting anyone? Yes, she is. She kept steering the conversation back to her special interest when her sister was trying to change the topic because she was bored, then when it was finally her sister's turn to talk about something else she up and left because she only wanted to talk about topics of interest to her. It shows a lack of caring about her sister's experience as being of equal importance to hers, a lack of turn taking and reciprocity.

I don't think it was deliberate at all, I would suspect undiagnosed autism, but yes it was selfish and most likely hurtful to others. The laughter is a way of expressing that non-confrontationally.

XChrome · 22/07/2024 01:38

MeowCatPleaseMeowBack · 21/07/2024 23:11

I do, yes. But I don't need to leave in the middle of a social event to sit on my own and digest it.

You're able to reflect on a subject in depth in the middle of a noisy gathering? Sorry, but I'm calling bullshit.

TheOriginalEmu · 22/07/2024 01:44

SheldonsMom · 22/07/2024 01:37

Is she hurting anyone? Yes, she is. She kept steering the conversation back to her special interest when her sister was trying to change the topic because she was bored, then when it was finally her sister's turn to talk about something else she up and left because she only wanted to talk about topics of interest to her. It shows a lack of caring about her sister's experience as being of equal importance to hers, a lack of turn taking and reciprocity.

I don't think it was deliberate at all, I would suspect undiagnosed autism, but yes it was selfish and most likely hurtful to others. The laughter is a way of expressing that non-confrontationally.

You’ve completely made that story up with extra emotive words you’ve decided happened. Nowhere did she say she ‘kept steering it back’ or your use of ‘her sister was bored’ -you don’t know that she was bored or that it was even her sister who brought up trump actually. When the topic turned to Trump, she excused herself politely to have some time to think alone. That’s not hurting anyone.

Maybe OP is autistic, maybe she isn’t. That’s still not a reason to keep poking fun at her and be mean. It’s not ‘non-confrontational to laugh at someone. If neurotypicals want to talk about odd, not saying what you mean is odd. If they were pissed off because she went outside, say so. Use your words like an adult.

XChrome · 22/07/2024 01:55

CoalTit · 22/07/2024 01:30

Doesn't anyone here relate to the OP's decision to leave the room once the conversation turned to Donald Trump?

I relate to it bigly.

TheOriginalEmu · 22/07/2024 02:00

XChrome · 22/07/2024 01:55

I relate to it bigly.

i relate to it biglier than you. I’m the biggest relator of relating in the world. The best too.

aurynne · 22/07/2024 02:03

XChrome · 22/07/2024 01:28

You have got to be kidding me. You think it's abnormal for a grown adult to want to reflect on the subject of a conversation?
This is not weird. This is what intelligent people do.

Spot on.

While all the donkeys bray.

Apolloneuro · 22/07/2024 02:09

Well OP, I don’t think you’re weird. I think you sound intelligent and thoughtful. Unfortunately most people are pretty thick and don’t understand the pursuit of considered reflection.

Just shrug it off. I’m sure they didn’t mean to be unkind. They don’t understand you.

wandawaves · 22/07/2024 02:35

I think your "reflecting time" was really weird, but I wouldn't have laughed at you, that's just mean.
But couldn't you have reflected when you got home?

MrHarleyQuin · 22/07/2024 02:35

They sound like a bunch of ignorant twats.

Like some members of my family would mock my vocabulary- Ooh, that's a long word. Have you swallowed a dictionary?

XChrome · 22/07/2024 02:47

wandawaves · 22/07/2024 02:35

I think your "reflecting time" was really weird, but I wouldn't have laughed at you, that's just mean.
But couldn't you have reflected when you got home?

Why should she wait until she gets home? She took a short break to have a think. Wtf is wrong with that?

XChrome · 22/07/2024 02:54

OP, notice that the people who say it's weird and laughable are unable to rationally explain why. The best they can come up with is; "I wouldn't do that, therefore it's weird."
That's because, unlike you, they aren't thinkers by nature. They're reactors. They just have a knee jerk emotional response to anyone who isn't as shallow as them. They don't think it through. You like to think things through in order to form an opinion. That's to be commended. Ignore these superficial, reactive people.

XChrome · 22/07/2024 03:00

TheOriginalEmu · 22/07/2024 02:00

i relate to it biglier than you. I’m the biggest relator of relating in the world. The best too.

🇺🇲 Emu 2024! 🇺🇸

stonebrambleboy · 22/07/2024 03:13

Future Learn do online courses for free.
I did one on Richard 111 highly recommended.

Clafoutie · 22/07/2024 03:44

Overtired345 · 21/07/2024 21:06

How....weird and intense of you. I'm afraid that is a very unusual reaction and will absolutely bring some eye rolls, if not laughter, in any normal circle

Well, all I can say is thank goodness for ‘unusual reactions’. It means there are still interesting, thoughtful people in the world.

Clafoutie · 22/07/2024 03:53

DeadbeatYoda · 21/07/2024 23:46

Yep, that's what I wondered too. The hobby, the 'reflection', the difficulty understanding the weirdness of the behaviour. Don't get me wrong, I'm from an ND family so wouldn't have thought much about a situation like this but undiagnosed ASD is certainly coming to mind here.

Or the OP could just be an interesting, intelligent, thoughtful person, who doesn’t need diagnosing?

Swipe left for the next trending thread