Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People commenting on my 6 YO DD weight?

341 replies

mumspiration1997 · 29/05/2024 20:09

I've had 3 different family members commenting on my daughters weight this week. "She's really filled out" "you should watch what she's eating" etc etc . Possibly from a place of concern as they wouldn't be people to be obviously nasty. For context she's 4 stone and average height. Is this a problem? She's a great appetite and an active girl who definitely loves a wee treat but big deal. I'm 9 stone and very active myself so it's not like I'm purposely just laying around setting bad examples. Perhaps maybe I should be making her eat healthier but I mean she eats fruit and ham sandwiches and chicken nuggets and mash and veg and the takeout with the whole family om a sat McDonald's etc. Big deal??!!! She's 6 I was just grateful she has a good appetite. Aibu???? Or r they???

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Mum1976Mum · 29/05/2024 22:38

And my 9 year old weighed just over 4 and a half stone at 136cm. She was almost 50th percentile. 😫

ByNavyOtter · 29/05/2024 22:40

amijustbeingsuspicious · 29/05/2024 21:55

Oh ffs is this for real?

Yep, don't want people like that who are pig ignorant and rude to talk me.

RogueFemale · 29/05/2024 22:43

mumspiration1997 · 29/05/2024 21:59

It's sooo easily done and honestly I hadn't even noticed. But not the end of the world and we can start some healthier habits!!!!

First thing I'd do is just cut out all refined sugar. Eat anything you like, but no refined sugar.

Second, eat vegetables every day.

Third, more physical exercise.

amijustbeingsuspicious · 29/05/2024 22:46

ByNavyOtter · 29/05/2024 22:35

Omg people like you just want to stick the knife in on anyone and say there's an obesity crisis. Please. The poor little girl isn't responsible for that, some absolute cow saying she's filled out to her mum will do more harm than good.

Have you read my comments on this thread? I’ve been nothing but kind and supportive to the OP.

you are honestly mental if you think a few comments she didn’t hear will be more harmful to her than her actually growing up overweight.

perimumma · 29/05/2024 22:51

Don't take any notice OP, if she was tiny and slim would they be telling you to feed her up?

My DD is 5, she 116cm and 3 stone 11lbs. She has a great appetite, eats a varied diet and is very active. They go through phases of growing outward and upward.

Kids have got a lifetime to worry about their weight, they don't need to be thinking about it at such a young age.

Pickledpopcorn · 29/05/2024 22:58

My dd is 3stone at 3 yrs 2 months! I don’t worry as she will do what her sisters did and from age 5/6 be tall and slim

rainbowunicorn · 29/05/2024 22:58

perimumma · 29/05/2024 22:51

Don't take any notice OP, if she was tiny and slim would they be telling you to feed her up?

My DD is 5, she 116cm and 3 stone 11lbs. She has a great appetite, eats a varied diet and is very active. They go through phases of growing outward and upward.

Kids have got a lifetime to worry about their weight, they don't need to be thinking about it at such a young age.

This stands out as probably the most ill informed daft comment on the thread so far. If your child is the weight, height and age that you state then she is also overweight.
The time for learning healthy habits on food and exercise is absolutely in childhood. It is much harder to start thinking about it in adulthood when you are already obese.

MixedRaceMuslim · 29/05/2024 23:02

My daughter is six and three stone.. average height.. I imagine it would even out with growth as long it stays steady..

Msmbc · 29/05/2024 23:07

Avoid sugar free or low fat yoghurts as an alternative as they are full of ultra processed ingredients that are also linked to obesity. Best option is plain yogurt with fruit and/or a drizzle of honey

MumblesParty · 29/05/2024 23:07

I’d drop the supper completely OP. No need for it, and it would be one less job for you!

Roundroundthegarden · 29/05/2024 23:08

9mo twins, that's tough op. Don't be too hard on yourself. FlowersShe's only 6 and still time to make small changes. These people need to stop commenting in front of her, that will be more damaging than her diet.

Investinmyself · 29/05/2024 23:09

A child eating lots of beige sugary carbs and virtually no vegetables and protein realistically isn’t going to suddenly grow tall and slim. In all likelihood she’d continue to prefer beige carbs as she got older.
All credit to Op for saying I’ve not realised and will make a few tweaks. The little girl will be none the wiser.

twohotwaterbottles · 29/05/2024 23:24

Some great advice here OP. Some parents just don't see their children quite the same (rose tinted 😍which is lovely really) as others may do. Now is a great time to make some changes and set her up for a healthy future. Good luck 🙌🏻

Copperoliverbear · 29/05/2024 23:31

No chicken nuggets and more exercise, maybe an after school activity.

DreamTheMoors · 29/05/2024 23:34

My sister was always on the chubby side.
Then, at 16 her body changed and she dropped all the “baby fat” (or whatever it was) and she remained slim forever. Still is.

The problem was our mum — Mum always struggled with her weight and always had my sister join her on some ridiculous fad diet or another — and how my sister didn’t end up with lifelong severe food issues is beyond me.

Grammarnut · 29/05/2024 23:38

Sunnysummer24 · 29/05/2024 20:14

I agree. Can you clearly see her ribs?

Also look up her weight and height centile on the WHO charts. What weight centile was she born on?

Should you be able to see a child's ribs? Would that not mean they were underweight?

FTMaz · 29/05/2024 23:41

I personally think macdonalds once a week is quite a lot. It’s full of absolute crap. It will also depend what’s she’s having there if large portions that could be well over a child’s daily allowance in once meal alone.

MummyCushion · 29/05/2024 23:47

Hi OP, it's great that you have looked into this and want to do something about it. There's so many big kids about and I think many don't realise or bury their heads about it.

My child was quite overweight, but now they are 'normal' according to their BMI. I couldn't really see what I was doing wrong but upon reading around processed foods and the Mediterranean diet I could see there was room for improvement.

The major changes I made were to remove as much highly processed food as possible and introduce more whole foods in their diet.

Cereals were cut out for a long time and now are just an occasional treat. Cordial/squash and fruit juices were cut out and water and milk became the default. Yoghurt offered became Greek yoghurt with berries mixed instead of sugary yoghurts. White carbs were replaced with wholegrain options. I even started making my own bread. Vegetable intake was increased so that pretty much every snack and meal included it. For meals I'd try to fill half their plate with veg. Processed meats like bacon and sausage were cut out. Fish fingers and waffles cut out. Instead I give just normal meat and fish, potatoes, wholegrain pasta, brown rice or couscous etc. I've introduced more lentils, beans, chickpeas and nuts. I don't give a pile of spuds with every meal. I try to treat potatoes like any other veg and give a smaller portion, and increase the amount of less starchy veg.

Once they get used to real foods they will be fuller for longer and not overeat processed stuff that's designed to be overeaten. They won't have blood sugar spikes and crashes without sugar and white carbs.

Snacks are fruit, nuts, crackers, toast, veg sticks, hummus, cheese, breadsticks. I find the least processed crackers and breadsticks I can find. There is a fruit bowl always topped up with apples, bananas, oranges and whatever else looks nice that week.

Breakfasts are more varied and not just a white carb and some fruit. I give homemade wholegrain bread with various healthy toppings, porridge, omelette, even homemade baked beans. Homemade granola with berries and Greek yoghurt goes down a storm.

If we go out I try to bring a packed lunch instead of relying on crap food devoid of nutrients that's sold as kids food in most venues.

Basically anything too processed is now an occasional treat whether that's shop bought croissants, processed meat, takeaway food or a bar of chocolate, and it seems to be doing the trick. My child has grown in to their weight and now has a normal BMI and looks so different to older photos of them where they were obviously overweight.

I would say don't be afraid of talking to your child about the nutrition value of food and how we should try to eat a healthy and varied diet. They cover this sort of thing in school so it shouldn't be a foreign concept to them. If you have any cookery books in the house you can get them out and look at the pictures, you might be surprised to find what she thinks looks good and would be prepared to try. If she doesn't already help you in the kitchen I would definitely suggest this, in my experience it helps kids become more familiar with new ingredients and more adventurous in what they are prepared to try a bit of. Best of luck to you both!

ByNavyOtter · 29/05/2024 23:58

amijustbeingsuspicious · 29/05/2024 22:46

Have you read my comments on this thread? I’ve been nothing but kind and supportive to the OP.

you are honestly mental if you think a few comments she didn’t hear will be more harmful to her than her actually growing up overweight.

You're honestly mental if you don't realise the harm those comments can do. As someone who knows someone that died of anorexia I think you're completely stupid to speak on behalf of everyone to say they can handle these sort of comments. It doesn't take much.

MummyCushion · 30/05/2024 00:17

ByNavyOtter · 29/05/2024 23:58

You're honestly mental if you don't realise the harm those comments can do. As someone who knows someone that died of anorexia I think you're completely stupid to speak on behalf of everyone to say they can handle these sort of comments. It doesn't take much.

The OP hasn't said her daughter was in earshot when these comments were said, and has told us they are coming from concerned family members.

The crazy thing to do would be to never to speak to these people again, who presumably are people she loves and considers her support network. Those comments have prompted the OP to come here and ask for help, find out her BMI and listen to advice from others on how to address her daughters weight.

I've no intention of looking up some tiktok trend but of course anorexia is real and a child's weight must be handled sensitively but there is no indication that the OP's family aren't capable of doing this. The sad fact is there is so much chronic illness and early death that is preventable, relating to the food we are eating and the weight we are collectively gaining, that this vastly over shadows problems caused by someone being told by their grandma that they've filled out a bit and should cut down on the chocolate biscuits. This is why the poster you are wanting an argument with is bringing the obesity epidemic into the conversation, it's a massive problem and it's affecting our children and impeding their ability to live long and healthy lives.

DramaLlamaMumma · 30/05/2024 00:27

perimumma · 29/05/2024 22:51

Don't take any notice OP, if she was tiny and slim would they be telling you to feed her up?

My DD is 5, she 116cm and 3 stone 11lbs. She has a great appetite, eats a varied diet and is very active. They go through phases of growing outward and upward.

Kids have got a lifetime to worry about their weight, they don't need to be thinking about it at such a young age.

Yes, if your child is very slim there will be idiots asking if you feed them 🙃 My 6yo is 3st and tall for her age, BMI under the 9th centile and the amount of “oh does she not have much of an appetite? She doesn’t eat much does she?” I hear, from family to friends to teachers, is insane. What do they want me to do, force feed her? She actually eats plenty. Of course diet and exercise are important, but genetics do play a role and my daughter clearly inherited my husband’s tall and slim body type.

Ladyzfactor · 30/05/2024 01:05

ByNavyOtter · 29/05/2024 23:58

You're honestly mental if you don't realise the harm those comments can do. As someone who knows someone that died of anorexia I think you're completely stupid to speak on behalf of everyone to say they can handle these sort of comments. It doesn't take much.

A lot more people have died of obesity than anorexia. No comments should be directed at the child by an adult but overweight children can be treated awful in school. There is no shame in installing healthy eating habits when young. It's much easier to correct bad habits in small children than older ones

KomodoOhno · 30/05/2024 02:42

Tiredbarbie · 29/05/2024 20:19

4 stone does sound quite a lot for a 6 year old if she is average height. Perhaps you can make some small changes such as cutting out the takeaways and McDonald’s? However I think it’s extremely rude of anyone to be commenting on your daughters weight and I hope they’re not doing it in front of her!

I agree. 4 stone seems too much at that age. But it's awful to comment on.

tamade · 30/05/2024 04:17

@mumspiration1997 I just did a bit of googling, seems like DD is about a stone heavier than what the WHO calls average, whatever that means. Also whilst reading up discovered that my DS is in the same boat. But since he is healthy, happy and active I find myself unable to GAF.

I also imagine that the standard deviation on something like global weights of 6yos is massive and confidence intervals will be large. So even significantly heavier than average may still be quite unremarkable, statistically.

Happyhappyday · 30/05/2024 04:30

My DD is 5.5 and 4 stone. She’s about 115cm tall too. I don’t think she’s overweight but definitely feel like she has some preschool chub, so a full stone more on her would feel pretty heavy I think. I’d maybe offer food less often, let her ask if she’s hungry. More fresh, less processed. Example for what DC ate today: oatmeal for breakfast, some fruit, snack at school which is usually some crackers or seaweed snacks and fruit. Homemade bean burrito, fruit and spinach for lunch. Snack afterschool peanut puffs, fruit. Dinner tonight was out at a nice restaurant, pasta and she had a scoop of ice cream. Last night was pork tacos with avocado, corn etc and similar rest of day.