Choosing between R44.04 and R129 car seats
Although both R44.04 and R129 car seats are currently allowed by law, opting for an R129 car seat is a good idea because of its stricter safety features and rigorous crash testing procedures.
According to Director of Child Seat Safety, Julie Dagnall, “The European Union Trade agreement has removed the sale and production of R44.04 seats from Sept 2024 in its member countries. England , Scotland and Wales are not part of the EU trade agreement and so R44.04 seats can still be sold in England, Scotland and Wales. Therefore, there's no immediate need to replace your existing R44.04 seat, as it’s still recognised under the Road Traffic law as an approved child seat.”
What safety criteria should I look for in a car seat?
When choosing a car seat for your child, it's essential to ensure it meets the highest safety standards. Here are a few things to tick off your checklist:
1. Check for certification labels
ECE R44.04 certification label:
Look for an orange label indicating compliance with the ECE R44.04 standard.
The label should display:
The standard number (ECE R44.04).
The weight group the seat is approved for (e.g. Group 0+, Group 1).
A circled ‘E’ followed by a number, which indicates the country where the seat was tested (e.g., E11 for the UK).
i-Size (R129) certification label:
Look for an orange label with the ECE R129 standard.
The label should display:
The standard number (ECE R129).
The height range for which the seat is suitable (e.g., 40-85 cm).
The maximum weight the child can be will also be displayed
The circled ‘E’ and country code.
The term ‘i-Size’, which shows it meets the enhanced safety requirements of this newer regulation.
2. Read the manual
Take a look at the car seat's user manual. Trustworthy manufacturers will clearly mention if their product meets ECE R44.04 or R129 standards. Also visit the manufacturer’s website for more information on safety testing and certifications.
3. Look for independent crash test results
The organisations laid out below perform their own rigorous car seat tests and provide ratings based on safety performance.
The good news is that we only recommend the safest baby and toddler car seats on the market that have performed well under stringent safety tests.
Which? (UK consumer association)
ADAC (German automobile club)
OAMTC (Austrian automobile club)
TCS (Swiss Touring Club)
4. Assess the car seats safety features
Look for additional safety features that enhance protection during a crash, such as:
Side-impact protection: the sides of the headrest should have extra padding
Energy-absorbing materials such as expanded polystyrene (EPS) foam.
A five-point harness system for children up to 18 kg, which is roughly around three to four years old.
According to Director of Child Seat Safety, Claire Waterhouse, shielded seats, with an impact shield in the front of the seat rather than a harness are also a safe option for children.
A car seat with an impact shield features a padded shield in front of the child, which acts as a restraint mechanism. Instead of using a traditional harness with straps that go over the child's shoulders and buckle between the legs, the shielded car seat secures the child by using this shield, which is locked into place with the car's seat belt or with its own locking buckles. The shield is designed to provide protection in the event of a crash by distributing the force of impact more evenly across the child's body
5. Test the Installation and fit
Make sure you can install the car seat correctly in your vehicle. Even if the seat meets all safety standards, it can still pose a safety risk if not installed properly. If possible, choose a car seat with ISOFIX connectors, as they help reduce the chances of incorrect installation.
“We always encourage parents to go to a reputable retailer who can show them how to fit the seat. If you can’t get to a retailer, there are some good fitting videos online,” adds Claire.
Read next: Best 360 spin car seats
What is ISOFIX?
ISOFIX is a standardised system for installing car seats in vehicles, designed to make the process simpler and safer. It involves anchor points built into the car, typically located in the gap between the vehicle's seat cushion and backrest.
The car seat is equipped with connectors that attach directly to these anchor points, eliminating the need for a seat belt to secure the seat. Most of the newer car seat models such as 360 spin car seats are ISOFIX-compatible.
ISOFIX offers several advantages, including easier and quicker installation compared to using an adult seat belt. It also reduces the risk of incorrect installation, which can compromise your child’s safety in the event of a collision.
Additionally, ISOFIX-compatible car seats come with indicators or visual cues to confirm correct installation, offering parents or caregivers peace of mind on car journeys.
According to Child Seat Safety, ISOFIX has been mandatory in all new cars sold in the EU since 2006, but many older models also have ISOFIX points. To check if your car has them, look for ISOFIX labels between the base and back of your car seats, consult your vehicle's handbook, or contact the manufacturer.
If you don't have ISOFIX connectors in your car, you can still secure your child safely using a seat belt by threading it through a car seat correctly.
Rear-facing vs. forward-facing: which is safer?
One of the most frequent questions on our Mumsnet forum is, “When can my child sit forward-facing?” Many parents hesitate to keep their child rear-facing until age four or older. However, studies show that rear-facing car seats significantly reduce the risk of injury in car accidents, especially for children under the age of two.
Rear-facing seats provide better support for the head, neck and spine, distributing collision forces over your child's entire back and reducing the risk of serious injury and whiplash.
This is particularly important for babies as their heads (even at nine months old) are still relatively large and heavy in comparison to their body and strength, meaning they’re unable to prevent their head from being thrown forward in the event of a crash if in the forward-facing position.
Axkid car safety experts therefore recommend keeping children rear-facing for as long as possible.
Here are a few more benefits of extended rear-facing car seats
Longer usage: many rear-facing car seats are designed to accommodate children up to four years old or even beyond, allowing parents to keep their children in a safer position for longer.
Better protection in side-impact crashes: rear-facing car seats offer superior protection in side-impact collisions, absorbing the impact and distributing forces more evenly across your child's body.
Reduced risk of car sickness: some parents find their children experience less motion sickness when seated rear-facing, as they see less movement outside the car window.
What Mumsnetters say about rear-facing:
“I rear-faced my son till he was five in an Axkid Minikid [car seat]. He is 99.6th centile height so outgrew it by height rather than weight.” Ikeeponkeepingon
“My almost six-year-old is still rear-facing! Have only agreed to let her face forward in Granny’s car in the last year as she outgrew the up to 18kg rear-facing one they had.” Lou573
Read next: How long should a child be rear-facing in a car seat?