Talk

Advanced search

To be upset a woman called my child dirty

(247 Posts)
Shiningbaubles Sun 26-Apr-15 16:35:02

Out at a country park today, dd(5) had a wee in the car park as she was busting. A woman walked past with toddler and baby and she said to her daughter who was asking for a wee 'no, you can wait, just because other children are being dirty doesn't mean you have to!'

AIBU to think this was horrible?

DameDiazepamTheDramaQueen Sun 26-Apr-15 16:38:05

I'd have been upset too, it's not the same as an adult weeing in public and a quick emergency wee is fine in my book!

MythicalKings Sun 26-Apr-15 16:39:42

YABU in that it's her opinion that it's "dirty" to let children urinate in a car park. She's allowed to think that.

SoleSource Sun 26-Apr-15 16:39:44

Yanbu

Horrible cow.

PiperIsTerrysChoclateOrange Sun 26-Apr-15 16:40:06

How far away was some toilets

Nanasueathome Sun 26-Apr-15 16:40:15

The correct term, when having to pee in the park is 'having a nature wee'
Good for the environment

GlitteryLipgloss1 Sun 26-Apr-15 16:40:58

YANBU. When little ones have to go they have to go.

DoraGora Sun 26-Apr-15 16:41:01

Everybody's got a pair of judgy pants. I think some people keep a spare, too. I'd just forget about it.

MagelanicClouds Sun 26-Apr-15 16:41:01

Had to let Ds go up against a tree at a national trust garden recently. It was a 10 minute walk back to the toilets.
Didn't want him wetting himself so I made sure no-one could see and I'm pretty sure the tree didn't mind.
When they're young there's not a lot you can do - they can't hold it in for all that long, so surely letting them wet themselves is worse?

SlatternIsMyMiddleName Sun 26-Apr-15 16:41:04

In that case I was 'dirty' many times during my childhood.

She was talking rubbish.

SoupDragon Sun 26-Apr-15 16:41:50

TBH, I think it's being dirty too.

Which isn't to say I haven't let mine do it in an emergency.

Shiningbaubles Sun 26-Apr-15 16:42:36

Toilets weren't that far to be fair but the problem was we'd have had to walk back, DD just announced she was desperate.

I was really upset and DD was too.

chocomochi Sun 26-Apr-15 16:42:59

YANBU. We've had to do that with our DDs in emergencies too. Just hope your DD didn't hear that comment.

PeachyPants Sun 26-Apr-15 16:44:38

I think she wasn't unreasonable for having that opinion but she was unreasonable to say it in ear shot of you and your DD.

popalot Sun 26-Apr-15 16:44:38

We've done that in an emergency, but hide at the front of the car out of the way. I bet she's done it too!

NotallTravellersarebad Sun 26-Apr-15 16:44:52

Oh well, silly old bats can have opinions. It doesn't mean they matter. Forget her.

insancerre Sun 26-Apr-15 16:45:55

At that age they should be able to wait until they get to the toilet
A 2 year old just put of nappies is different
I think you shouldn't have let her do it
I agree with the woman
What age are you going to stop your child weeing in public?

MovingOnUpMovingOnOut Sun 26-Apr-15 16:46:39

Yanbu. There was no need for her to say that so you could hear and it was horrible to say it in front of your daughter.

I half hope her toddler didn't make it to the loo and she had to clean it up.

Moln Sun 26-Apr-15 16:46:39

To get some prospective was there anywhere more suitable than the car park like behind a tree or bush (seeing you were in a park)? In the car park seems a bit of a odd.

Though YABU anyway, because as MythicalKings said it's her opinion. I imagine everyone has a cut off as to was age it's fine till, hers is possibly school aged children.

Moln Sun 26-Apr-15 16:47:50

*an odd choice

MovingOnUpMovingOnOut Sun 26-Apr-15 16:48:01

Actually I don't really. I'm thoroughly fed up of small person and not so small person wee at the moment and I don't wish it on anyone.

sleeponeday Sun 26-Apr-15 16:48:45

If it was a closely packed car car park, and this was in the middleish with cars on all sides, then I do think that mings a bit, really. If it was a big grassy field co-opted as a car park, and DD was tucked away out of scent or stumble, around one edge near tall grass... then the other mother was being obnoxious.

Nobody wants to splash through anyone else's pee, after all.

Shiningbaubles Sun 26-Apr-15 16:48:45

We got back to the car and she needed to go, to be honest I didn't think anyone would care or object to a little child having a wee!

HourOrTwo Sun 26-Apr-15 16:49:10

If the toilets weren't far I would have told her to wait. If it was an absolute emergency i think its ok to have a discreet wee behind the car, but i'd have held up the car-rug rather than let people see!

Beyond potty-training age, kids need to learn to hold on whenever possible. I would think it a bit odd to see a 5-year-old weeing in a car-park if there were toilets nearby.

The woman was nasty to call her dirty, but I can understand why she was a bit repulsed. Imagine if all kids under the age of 6 weed on ground in public car-parks, it would be very off-putting and unhygienic.

Artandco Sun 26-Apr-15 16:49:34

It's fine

Join the discussion

Join the discussion

Registering is free, easy, and means you can join in the discussion, get discounts, win prizes and lots more.

Register now