Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Wes Streeting on the nhs.

78 replies

Imnobody4 · 24/04/2025 19:54

From the Times;
Transgender patients could be treated in private rooms in NHS hospitals to protect their “rights and dignities”, Wes Streeting has said.

The health secretary said NHS guidance on same-sex wards is being reviewed in light of the Supreme Court ruling that a woman is defined by biological sex under equalities law

Asked about his previous comments that “trans women are women — get over it”, he said: “I’ve addressed this previously and I don’t mind kind of saying, ‘look, you know, I don’t think that was the right thing to say’.

And actually, I wish I’d listened much earlier. I don’t think we, to be honest, given some of the rough discourse we’ve had on these issues in recent years, I don’t think we lose anything by having a bit of humility to say, ‘actually, I wish we’d listened’.”

https://www.thetimes.com/article/3446833b-e40b-40b8-8168-d49e277ae75a?shareToken=0355c6bdd9c0aaf388bc5b8992a65575

NHS could treat trans patients in private rooms, says Wes Streeting

The health secretary said guidance on same-sex wards was being reviewed in response to the Supreme Court ruling

https://www.thetimes.com/article/3446833b-e40b-40b8-8168-d49e277ae75a?shareToken=0355c6bdd9c0aaf388bc5b8992a65575

OP posts:
Endthisshit · 25/04/2025 12:26

there’s a big problem treating Trans Identified Men as special and giving them their own rooom. I heard a nurse speaking once, LWS i think, she was saying how TIMs were given own room when paintings as extreme risk of infection need them but TiMs were given priority, absolutely shocking, but you know, they are so very SPECIAL

OuterSpaceCadet · 25/04/2025 13:02

Obviously nobody should experience actual discrimination as an NHS patient. Nobody should receive worse treatment because of who they are; unfortunately this actually does happen but to black people and women, not to trans people as a cohort.

After that it's just identity right? And who actually feels as though they keep their identity intact when they are a hospital in-patient? I certainly didn't, giving birth or having an abortion. You just become part of a conveyor belt. Anyone who's had a relative in hospital long term will have seen the degree to which they become institutionalised by the system, despite the nurses being usually lovely.

Much like body hair, small breasts, HRT supply issues, the sheer expense of female grooming.... These things that many women cope quietly with are painted as tragic when a man has to endure them.

NextRinny · 26/04/2025 08:59

Maluki · 24/04/2025 23:16

I am saying that asserting that trans people ill enough to be hospitalised are "men in nighties" moaning about "feeling unsafe" who should be automatically and as overt policy be put in general men's wards is not acknowledging trans people's humanity or their need to be treated with dignity. However I understand that it is also not appropriate for many women to share space with a trans woman for a variety of reasons. EACH has rights. In the past trans people's rights were steamrolling women's rights, and that was wrong. Just reversing that situation so women's rights now steamroller trans people's is not helpful. Both parties are entitled to privacy and dignity when they are vulnerable.

This is not what was intended by the SC ruling, when they explicitly clarified that trans people remain protected under gender reassignment in the equality act. Clearly taking a 65 year old transwomen with advanced bowel cancer who transitioned in 1985, has no penis to be attacking people with and is known to everyone in her community as Jenny and "outing" her as trans, sticking her in a general male ward is not the aim of this piece of legislation. It does not enable Jenny to receive treatment respectful of her identity and with dignity. If it genuinely is as inflexible as that then I assume other legislation will quickly be written to support more flexibility for hospitals. I don't know what that will look like. I am suggesting it won't look like "You are a bloke in a nightie get in the men's ward".

Edited

You can't steamroll a right which never existed.

As much as no woman wants to cause distress to any poor souls. That poor soul's distress does not entitle them to any beds in the female wards (honestly not even the private rooms. Everyone wants one of those. Why should a woman be denied it for a man on a female ward! I'm so over the polite compromises)

Stop trying to police our thinking. Saying we can't state a reality is beyond politically correct speech. We can't say what we see? A transwoman on a female ward is male and in a nightie. It's the reality. There's nothing more humane than seeing what's in front of you.

Everyone here has a man in their life who they think is nice and safe too. No special males in with the women please.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page