Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Dr Laura Favaro is taking City University to an employment tribunal

127 replies

Gasp0deTheW0nderD0g · 01/04/2023 19:16

Relevant thread from last year: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4634273-times-article-on-academia

This is what she says on a well-known gardening site (can't link here, but should be easily found via search engine). Sounds like a very important case. She has an excellent legal team lined up but this will be expensive.

Summary
I'm an academic who has been researching the silencing, discrimination and harassment of female academics who raise questions about gender identity theory, including those that are ‘gender critical’ such as myself. As a consequence, I have been ostracised, subjected to false complaints, had my research stopped, my research data taken away, and I have lost my job. I’m raising funds because I am having to take the case to an Employment Tribunal.

Who am I?
My name is Laura Favaro. I am a Spanish sociologist, schoolteacher, and mum of two little boys. In 2020 we moved to the UK so that I could join City, University of London as Postdoctoral Research Fellow to investigate the disputes around sex and gender that have escalated dramatically since the 2010s.
I have collected large amounts of data on the ‘gender wars’ in academia. You can read about some of the findings in my Times Higher Education article called Researchers are wounded in academia's gender wars. You can also watch a talk , and another one .

There you will find harrowing testimonies by female academics across disciplines and careers stages: too afraid to voice their views, even to work in gender studies altogether; citing not just concerns about their jobs but fears over violence, putting their children at risk, and more. Some of them hold gender-critical views, others simply want to ask questions about aspects of the theory and movement of gender identity or transgender. You will also find the admissions of those who actively support the censoring, bullying and persecution of gender-critical academics in British universities and beyond.

One result of my Times Higher Education piece was that my university, City, received complaints alleging that I had somehow been unethical during my research. These complaints were baseless: City investigated and could find no ethical wrongdoing on my part. But despite this, I have been frozen out, and further such baseless accusations have been taken at face value, leading to the suspension of my research, and the withdrawal of access to my data.

I have been told at City that the university considers my research data to be dangerous, that it is frightened of having the findings made public, that it does not want to become involved in the sex and gender debate – and that things would have been different if I believed that ‘trans women are women’. Indeed, colleagues have described my Times Higher Education article publicly as an ‘attack piece on trans people’, and claimed that my research ‘clearly intended to cause harm’; while internally I have been described as an institutional risk, and even a risk to research participants, with calls to restrict my use of my research data to ensure it is ‘acceptable’.

It is difficult to overemphasize the toll this can take personally and professionally – not least for a more junior and precarious academic.

Please help me fight for academic freedom. Please help me push back against the persecution of academics with feminist or gender critical views. Enough is enough!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
dimorphism · 07/10/2023 10:20

RethinkingLife · 04/10/2023 09:43

I find it intriguing how easy it is to find witnesses to speak out at tribunals that have women at their heart. And just how many of those witnesses are women. Audre Lorde, Mary Daly and so many others might have an opinion on the motivations for that.

The persecution of GC women academics has become normalised.

I'm guessing most of the women denouncing other women are 'do it to Julia' types.

It is very much becoming normalised.

Sisterpita · 12/12/2023 16:16

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Sisterpita · 12/12/2023 16:17

I linked to the crowdfunder by mistake.

Good news Laura has now got access to some of her data.

HagoftheNorth · 12/12/2023 21:09

This case is appalling - any university which tries to control data/analysis because they don’t like what the data is falling so far below any reasonable academic standard.

Once again, the precedent is very important, so once again, women will contribute their own cash to do what the country’s government and institutions should be doing.

maltravers · 12/12/2023 22:23

Sisterpita · 12/12/2023 16:17

I linked to the crowdfunder by mistake.

Good news Laura has now got access to some of her data.

Has City University belatedly realised there may be two sides to the story and “the right side of history” is not the foregone conclusion they once thought it was? Or has LF got hold of the data through legal demand letters do you know? I wonder who owns the rights to the compiled data under LF’s contract with City U …

Sisterpita · 12/12/2023 23:15

@maltravers Here is the update

News on the research dataI am thrilled to be able to announce that I have regained access to the transcripts of the 50 interviews I conducted for my research project on the ‘gender wars’ in academia. City has transferred the data to Bournemouth University, where I am Lecturer in Social Science.
As you may be aware, the interviews are only part of the data I need to complete my research. I had additionally carried out a survey, with the support of a British Academy grant. I have good news here too: City has also now agreed to transfer to Bournemouth University the survey data. I do not know yet when this will take place though.
It has been a year of pursuing the transfer of the interview transcripts to Bournemouth University, and of seeking resolution regarding the survey data. Arriving at this positive conclusion has entailed a monumental amount of effort, time, and trauma. I feel indebted to my solicitor Peter Daly, and of course to you all for allowing me access to legal support.
The litigation continues, focused on the hostile working environment toward gender-critical beliefs I endured at City. This will be examined at the final hearing, starting 16th September 2024.
My team remains firmly confident in the strength of my case. Please, can you share widely my crowdfund page to help me reach the target for legal fees?
Thank you, as always, for your invaluable support,
Laura.

fromorbit · 13/12/2023 10:15

The University are going to lose. That is why they are giving way already. Just as in all the other cases. Seen a bunch of wins recently that list is only going to get longer.

Keep fighting Laura. You have reality and the law on your side.

maltravers · 13/12/2023 12:58

Thank you Sisterpita, just seen this. Keep pushing Laura!

Sisterpita · 13/12/2023 15:30

I think Jo Phoenix’s case is the one that potentially is going to send shock waves through Universities and could lead to a whole lot of settlements.

DisappearingGirl · 15/12/2023 10:48

I've just seen Laura's update too.

Excellent that she is starting to be given access back to her research data. It looks such interesting research too!

I have just contributed to Laura's crowdfunder again.

hamstersarse · 15/12/2023 11:05

I had the misfortune to work with this university a few years ago. They are unbelievably woke and drowning in identity politics groupthink. They were appalling to work with, arrogant and full of their own virtue. I'd love to give details of what they actually did but it would be too outing, but suffice to say it involved the exact type of thinking that is apparent in this case - the place is infested with very bad thinking.

I hope they get some comeuppance

Igmum · 21/03/2024 07:39

Thanks Based - do you have a share token?

anyolddinosaur · 21/03/2024 08:25

Searching her name and crowdfunder is enough to find where to put your seeds.

RainWithSunnySpells · 21/03/2024 08:51

Igmum · 21/03/2024 07:39

Thanks Based - do you have a share token?

Try this. :)
https://archive.is/8nGfz

FrancescaContini · 21/03/2024 08:58

Going to plant a few seeds now.

crunchermuncher · 21/03/2024 09:14

I have dug for this. That article in the Times is terrifying. Bloody hell!

"For example, last year, a London School of Economics postgraduate student conference paper described a scene in which feminists critical of genderism “scream for mercy”. The paper then described the potential threat: “I hold a knife to your throat and spit my transness into your ear”, concluding: “Are you scared? I sure fucking hope so.”

This level of violent threat wouldn't be accepted against any other group.And these are the same people who think it's hateful to correctly refer to a transwoman a man. It's insane.

Her article then goes on to quote a genderist academic who said:
"These gender-critical feminists – they are intellectualising [sex and gender], and I think it’s harmful,” she added.

When asked to describe their arguments, however, she responded: “I don’t know if what I understand or what I think are the issues, are the issues, I’ll be honest with you – I stay out of their way.” This remarkable coupling of condemnation and ignorance regarding gender-critical feminism was fairly common among genderist academics."

crunchermuncher · 21/03/2024 09:15

How can this bullying, censorship and fear be so common place in academia now? WTAF?

Based · 21/03/2024 10:43

Igmum · 21/03/2024 07:39

Thanks Based - do you have a share token?

https://archive.ph/8nGfz

ArabellaScott · 21/03/2024 10:47

Laura is taking City to an employment tribunal for claims including unfair dismissal, direct discrimination, harassment and victimisation.
The stress of the last year and a half has, at times, been unbearable.
‘I’d vomit with anxiety and wake up in the middle of the night drenched with sweat,’ she says. ‘I’d be sitting with my sons reading them a bedtime story and suddenly I’d feel tears streaming down my face and I’d be shaking. What I am most sad about is that I’ve lost so much precious time with my children.’

The crowdjustice link is taking me to a 'page not found', anyone know what's up with that?

ArabellaScott · 21/03/2024 10:48

Must be a problem with teh link.

googling 'Academic freedom for feminists' and/or Laura's name brings up the correct link.

£91,630
pledged of £110,000 stretch target from 2575 pledges

ArabellaScott · 21/03/2024 10:49

Last update from December 2023:

'I am thrilled to be able to announce that I have regained access to the transcripts of the 50 interviews I conducted for my research project on the ‘gender wars’ in academia. City has transferred the data to Bournemouth University, where I am Lecturer in Social Science.
As you may be aware, the interviews are only part of the data I need to complete my research. I had additionally carried out a survey, with the support of a British Academy grant. I have good news here too: City has also now agreed to transfer to Bournemouth University the survey data. I do not know yet when this will take place though.
It has been a year of pursuing the transfer of the interview transcripts to Bournemouth University, and of seeking resolution regarding the survey data. Arriving at this positive conclusion has entailed a monumental amount of effort, time, and trauma. I feel indebted to my solicitor Peter Daly, and of course to you all for allowing me access to legal support.
The litigation continues, focused on the hostile working environment toward gender-critical beliefs I endured at City. This will be examined at the final hearing, starting 16th September 2024.

ScrambledSmegs · 21/03/2024 10:56

Thanks, have done some digging. Are there any UK universities which aren't in the same mess? It seems to be everywhere.

SinnerBoy · 21/03/2024 11:27

This is from the Mail article:

‘I remember showing them examples of abuse online towards gender critical women involving incitements to kill, decapitate, rape or punch them and my line managers would imply that the violence was on both sides,’ she says. ‘But the evidence didn’t show that. I went into this research with my eyes open and with a definite willingness to have my mind changed.’

How many times has that been pointed out on these boards?

Sisterpita · 21/03/2024 12:05

Donated.

Its a long wait until September when her case will be heard.

I am surprised after Jo Phoenix’s win that this case hasn’t been settled.

Swipe left for the next trending thread