Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Judicial review for woman prisoner alleging sexual assault by trans rapist in prison

235 replies

realitycalling · 03/11/2019 08:29

The Sunday Times reporting a long overdue judicial review after an (alleged) sexual assault on a woman prisoner by a male born trans rapist who had been placed in a female prison. (trying to be careful with language given the oppressive monitors who try to control this board).

And they've reported on the Centre Parks issue as well as a prominent article about that major brands like Unilever and Heinz advertising on Pornhub that's awash with child sex abuse. Share token:

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/female-prisoner-takes-government-to-court-after-alleged-assault-by-transgender-inmate-n5wtg2nf7?shareToken=f2e99b28b2f234eb7e84b0c4484e7254

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
yourhairiswinterfire · 22/10/2020 18:05

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

Facefullofcake · 22/10/2020 18:21

Exactly, @MissMarplesGlove

Ive copied and pasted this from 2018 Prick News - I clicked so you don't have to.

These powerful stories from two trans ex-offenders remind us why we need to support trans rights today

Two former trans prisoners have spoken out about their harrowing experiences of transitioning behind bars.

Speaking in the Cholmondley Room in The House of Lords, Karen Lawson and Jasmine Anne Strange shared their impassioned accounts of how they were treated as transgender prisoners, enduring sexual assault, high court battles and being taken hostage in the process of being recognised for their true selves.

Offering their expertise as part of Lord Patel’s Inside Gender Identity report launch, Lawson and Strange told their stories to highlight the need to honour the health and social care needs of transgender people in the criminal justice system.

While a spate of transgender prisoner suicides last year saw a disproportionate amount of offenders take their lives, the 80 estimated transgender prisoners currently in the system are still battling for the right for their identities to be recognised and respected.

Here are Jasmine and Karen’s stories.

Jasmine Anne Strange served a custodial sentence for seven years and four months. She transitioned behind bars, and was subjected to assault and abuse. She now supports other transgender women in prison and helps train prison staff.

I’m an ex-offender. I served seven years and four months in custody. I’m an intersex girl, so for anyone who doesn’t know about it, I was born with ambiguous genitalia. From the age of seven, my father – I’m from a mixed race background – insisted I was to be raised as a boy. So he injected me with testosterone and changed my name, which led me into all sorts of problems, because I couldn’t be the person I wanted to be. I tried to act like a boy, and ended up in prison.

However, because I was very much boyish-looking, going into prison was a bit of a nightmare. The testosterone started to drain out of my system, which led to, as you see today, this nice figure. The thing is, as soon as the prison service knew about it, they didn’t know what to do with me in any shape or form.

I said, look, I just want to move to the female estate. But I never did. After seven years and four months, I was released from a Category A prison; I wasn’t given parole. I lost everything in the beginning, they thought I was going to be a potential sex offender – how that happened when I was going to be in for a robbery, I will never know.

This is the way we were treated back in the day – they can’t understand the difference between gender and sexuality. I’m a lesbian. Just because I’m a woman, it doesn’t mean that I want to sleep with guys. I have done, I didn’t like it.

All my time in custody, it was awful. They treated me in some aspects like a girl when it was right for them. If I was talking to a guy for too long, they’d put me on report, and say it was inappropriate behaviour. I’d say well I’m in a male prison, you won’t move me because you said I’m a boy, because it’s what it says on my warrant! Which way do you want it? The open facility prison was an absolute nightmare. I was sexually assaulted, groped, it was disgusting. It was a double sentence for me. I had to be locked in my own confined space, and I couldn’t enjoy the facilities as any other prisoner would. I couldn’t exercise or go to the library, because I was kept on my own, or with a small band of red band prisoners.

I would just not want to wish the experience I had, all of those years in custody fighting to have this. The women’s team came in to visit me, and they said I wasn’t far enough in my transition to be moved. And I looked down and I thought, okay, right, well if I don’t stand a chance, how does anybody else? But I was a freak of nature in the eyes of a lot of the prison staff. They didn’t know how to deal with me.

There’s a lot of things I’d like to say, but you’d probably leave in tears. There’s things I’d ask for, and you’re not allowed them. I was a bit strong, so I made it through, but other people aren’t as strong, and it’s those people who have lost their lives in custody. People just did not understand them. There were a lot of staff who would take the mick out of us – the staff could be worse than the prisoners at times. I owe my life to the trans community.

We’re not freaks of nature; in my case, I was born with ambiguous genitalia. Does it matter? Does it matter that I’ve lived both sides of the fence? Does it matter that Karen has lived both sides of the fence? We’re human, we have a heart. It beats the same as yours. All we want is to be treated with decency and respect, the same as you would. Whether we’re in custody or not, and that’s how it should stand. A prison officer was dismissed for signing on a piece of paper my deed poll to change my name from male to female. What’s that all about? Why do certain members of staff have to lose their jobs for going against the grain?

My life was hell. I couldn’t do courses, I couldn’t do anything. When I went for my parole board, I was even called a tranny. The judge’s words were “where was this tranny”, and my caseworkers said “she’s sat in front of you.” I got my parole seven days later – what a shocker. But it made hardly any difference to me – it was only eight weeks before I was due to be released. The way they treated me was shocking.

I was also told when I got released that I wasn’t allowed to say anything or I’d be called back into custody. A lot was kept hush-hush; even probation outed me. I went for a course when I got released into the community, and it was an all-women’s course – “ooh probation said you’re a trans lady, so you’re not allowed to do this course.” What’s that all about? Does it matter? I’ve had completion of surgery, which was just my oversized clitoris reduced in size.

That’s all, nothing else, nothing more. It was just because of my father giving me testosterone. I would like everybody in this room who comes across someone transgender to just treat them exactly the same as everybody else. Boy, girl, no difference.

Karen Lawson was the first legally recognised transgender prisoner after enduring a three-year court battle to get her status recognised. She now has a full-time job as a manager and is an active trans rights campaigner.

I was born and raised in a little town called Ballycastle, so that’s Billy Elliot territory. I always knew that there was something different about me but I couldn’t quite figure it out until I was about 10. I came out to my family at that point.

That went down like a lead balloon. So that’s when I started to let out these cries of help, that unfortunately started to take me down the wrong road. I started to get frustrated, angry and wanted to get the help I needed but no-one wanted to listen to me. I got involved with the wrong people, someone took advantage of me and tried to get me to do things for them.

Unfortunately, I got took into custody on April 14 2000. I started living as myself when I was 16, so I went into Forest Bank as Karen, but it was still early days and I didn’t know what to do. I got assaulted, I got knocked out. I then got put down into the segregation unit as an element of protection. I then got moved across to Strangeways when I was an adult. They said until I was 21, they would refuse to help me out. It couldn’t happen in the youth offender estate.

I was given the male uniform, even though I had long hair and I had to wear this beautiful corned beef jumper. There was thankfully a doctor there who was really caring and understanding, and I started on my hormones in 2003.

Obviously, quite a lot of physical changes started to happen, which made me stick out even more. There were cries of “get your tits out for the lads” when I was on exercise. I was also put on the VP wing, which is not the best wing for someone trans. You’ve got all of these lovely guys making approaches. I did get taken hostage when I was at Strangeways, but fortunately, the staff were really good, and one of the staff was a kickboxer. Then they actually created a compact of how my care and management. It allowed me to have at least some of my clothes.

Then the Gender Recognition Act came out. Fortunately with some help from my personnel officer, and obviously, personal evidence of gender dysphoria, I got my gender recognition granted, making me the first trans prisoner within the UK to get a gender recognition certificate granted. When I could turn around to the wing and say I’m now legally female, move me, they really didn’t know what to do.

That still took a three-year high court battle. It took a judge there to say “no, she’s legally female, she needs to be moved in 28 days.” In 2009, I got moved to Holloway. It wasn’t all peaches and roses in the female estate either, but it was great to finally be in that prison with my peers. I didn’t have to wake up and worry about what I was wearing in the morning. Because I’d come from the male estate, there was this supposition that they’d have to take precautions.

For the first three months I was kept in segregation. I was let out on day release visits up to the wing to test how I was getting on. I went to Newhall for four years, and it was a great place for me, because the equality manager was phenomenal. She started to build my confidence up.

I hold down a full-time job, I live up in Leeds now, and I’m happy and confident because it’s all I’ve ever wanted. I might have gone around things the wrong way, but to me I felt isolated. I’ve come a long way since then.

I’m a manager, which is a big achievement of its own. I do a lot with the LGBT community in Leeds, and it’s nice to just to bounce around the street and no one actually judges you. In the prison estate, it’s the prison grapevine, so people hear, and you never blend in fully.

Thankfully, I transitioned quite well, so it’s like I can bounce around the estate and someone can say “that’s another butch lesbian,” which is exactly what I am. The prison estate has come a long way now, and I know I did impact on that with my high court case, but there’s still a long way to come."

^ oddly, this makes no mention of why Karen was actually in prison the second time, apart from, simply saying 'unfortunately I got took into custody'. The whole thing is gaslighting crap (as you all know). Sorry, they are a personal pet hate since I had the misfortune to come across them IRL, presenting as a lesbian who was convicted of killing their ex partner in self defence, and enough of a trustworthy character to do equality talks at the house of lords. Then I found out that wasn't quite the whole story.
Think that's just about got it off my chest.

TweeBree · 22/10/2020 18:47

Wow, such an important case. Will be watching this one closely.

Manderleyagain · 22/10/2020 18:49

How is this case being funded? It costs alot to bring a judicial review. I can't imagine you can get legal aid. I hope the woman has some source of funding, but I don't remember seing a crowd funder (I can't access the article).

NonnyMouse1337 · 22/10/2020 18:57

I'm not sure how it's being funded either. Maybe the website launch next week will shed more light on the case. It's so important.

EyesOpening · 22/10/2020 19:09

I’m a bit confused about those two stories, it’s hard to tell where Strange’s ends and Lawson’s starts, are they both saying they’re intersex?

ArabellaScott · 22/10/2020 19:16

Facefull, I didn't know about this case, so googled.

Karen Jones/ Karen Lawson

'was sentenced to life imprisonment in 2003 at age 21, for the attempted rape of a female shop assistant in Manchester. The attack took place in 2002, five days after Lawson was released early on licence after being jailed for manslaughter.'

(Not linking to above website as I doubt it'll stand, but here's a Mail link:)

www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-5440153/Trans-convict-invited-speak-House-Lords.html

ArabellaScott · 22/10/2020 19:18

Er, that was an accidental smiley - colon/bracket. I don't find anything in this case to prompt a smile.

littlbrowndog · 22/10/2020 20:02

Wow trying to rape a woman is a cry for help 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

littlbrowndog · 22/10/2020 20:03

And killed someone. 🤦‍♀️🤦‍♀️

MissMarplesGlove · 22/10/2020 20:13

And a person with DSD - differences in sexual development - is not trans and is quite different from a transwoman ...

Facefullofcake · 22/10/2020 20:16

Sorry, it's not clear from my epic unformatted cut and paste @EyesOpening

Karen's story begins
"I was born and raised in a little town called Ballycastle, so that’s Billy Elliot territory. I always knew that there was something different about me but I couldn’t quite figure it out until I was about 10. I came out to my family at that point."

I had no idea about any of their history until I googled to find out whether Centre for Women's Justice etc had supported K's self defence claim for their original manslaughter sentence (I thought they genuinely were just a butch woman, I didn't realise they were trans).

They had told me their version of events and charges etc earlier that evening, and I wondered why i hadn't been aware of the case. That was when I realised that I'd not been given the whole story by them.

caughtalightsneeze · 22/10/2020 20:18

I was born and raised in a little town called Ballycastle, so that’s Billy Elliot territory.

Where is Ballycastle? Yorkshire? I googled and the only one I can find is the one in N Ireland. Would be weird if it was in England since Bally is an Irish word. Hard to take a son story seriously when they're obviously not even being truthful about their pre-prison life.

caughtalightsneeze · 22/10/2020 20:19

A sob story, that should say

Facefullofcake · 22/10/2020 20:25

Ballycastle is a pseudonym for the place Dom Cummings famously visited this year, @caughtalightsneeze

caughtalightsneeze · 22/10/2020 20:34

@Facefullofcake

Ballycastle is a pseudonym for the place Dom Cummings famously visited this year, *@caughtalightsneeze*
Ahh, I see.

Off topic I know but why do they use that pseudonym? Does it mean something?

Facefullofcake · 22/10/2020 20:40

thank you Arabella for linking to the back story - I couldn't face going near it again because I couldn't get most of the detailed bits out of my head for months last time.

@EyesOpening Jones isn't / has never claimed to be intersex or have a DSD, just that they are a woman.

Facefullofcake · 22/10/2020 20:46

I'm just so agog that if I hadn't googled, and if I only ever saw the PN article I've pasted, I wouldn't have had a clue that something wasn't right about their story, or that I couldn't/shouldn't
trust them.

The article gives a very very misleading impression of them simply being a victim of the awful bigots and yay for standing their ground, with no other context. I'm finding it difficult to articulate, but they are not a good case to be celebrating as the first person to transition in prison.

awfulawfulawful · 22/10/2020 21:13

As a child and adult sexual abuse survivor the thought of sharing a cell with a rapist/sexual abusive man makes me feel Ill. It is cruel and dangerous. No male prisoner, no matter how he identifies should be put in a women's prison.

anotherhumanfemale · 22/10/2020 21:31

Interesting in the PN article it says that the prison system wouldn't allow transition before age 21 - unless I misread. A male prisoner can't be transferred to the female estate until they're 21+.

Very interesting really. I wonder that happens at 21 to remove the threat to females of a male.

Also interesting that that's what happens when you're in the government's custody..but not at Tavistock. Or school.

EyesOpening · 22/10/2020 21:51

@Facefullofcake

thank you Arabella for linking to the back story - I couldn't face going near it again because I couldn't get most of the detailed bits out of my head for months last time.

@EyesOpening Jones isn't / has never claimed to be intersex or have a DSD, just that they are a woman.

Thanks, after reading the Mail's article, I re-read the PN one and then worked it out which bit referred to who. It didn't help that the first story mentioned Karen so I thought they were talking about themselves in the third person! I now remember reading about the attack on the shop worker before. It's odd isn't it that we're supposed to feel sympathy over the sexual harassment they were subject to but not think about how the women could suffer with male sex offenders housed in the female estate
BlackeyedSusan · 22/10/2020 23:04

precisely. but, you know, lacking theory of mind?

wellbehavedwomen · 23/10/2020 00:03

You know, the sad thing is that I'm not even surprised that Prick News tenderly discusses how, "harrowing" it is for a male who has killed one woman and sought to rape another to serve a sentence for those crimes, and how wickedly unfair it was to send this person to a man's prison.

Women prisoners are some of the most vulnerable people imaginable. Almost all have been sexually assaulted, half in childhood. They genuinely do have recorded levels of suicide attempts at 46%, and suicide completion also drastically higher than the average, and far higher than male prisoners. Most are not violent. They are just 5% of all prisoners and just 3% of sex offenders. Yet nobody gives a shit about their best interests - male women must take priority over female women. And any attempt to question that is instantly attacked with howls of rage by the likes of Prick News, champions of the rights of males to serve their sentences in the women's estate on demand, after killing one woman and trying to rape another.

More male prisoners are in for violent offending than non-violent, and one in five for sex offences. 95% of all prisoners are male, and 98% of all sex offenders are, too. Male patterned criminality is so well evidenced that it's jawdropping anyone has the nerve to pretend it's not an abhorrent attack on women's rights to place males in the female estate - and that is whether the person in question is a violent offender, or not. It's bad for the women prisoners, always. So why doesn't anyone care?

Nobody, ever, anywhere, has claimed that it does not harm women prisoners psychologically to have male people alongside them. There is ample evidence, should anyone care to pay attention, that it traumatises and unnerves them. They are generally survivors of male violence and abuse, many from childhood on, and then they are being locked up with violent male prisoners, and told, "no, they are women." That's adding gaslighting to the horror of what is being done to them.

The fact everyone prioritises the transwomen, while not even bothering to consider that what they are doing contravenes the UN basic guidelines for prisons - which hold that sex segregation is a fundamental human right for incarcerated women - is proof positive that those cheerleading these policies are very well aware that TWANW. If they were women, then their best interests would be treated with contempt, too.

I'm so glad this woman is having her day in court, and I hope she knows how much support she has from other women, in fighting back against this horrible abuse of our sex.

wellbehavedwomen · 23/10/2020 00:05

* just 3% of sex offenders.

Sorry, typo. It's 2%, not 3%.

PurpleHoodie · 23/10/2020 00:50

No.

Men.

In.

Womens.

Prisons.

Anything else is for rape apologists, and nasty bastards. If that's you, live with it. Look in the mirror each morning and acknowledge what you are.

Swipe left for the next trending thread