Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Genuine question

77 replies

mama1234567 · 23/10/2018 15:49

Hi I am after genuine opinions, I wasn't sure whether to post in here or in health but as it isn't a health question as such I thought maybe here.....if it's the wrong section please just say. I have also namechanged but am a long time user and poster.
A close young male relation of mine was born with a rare genetic issue that basically means that although he is genetically male (this has been DNA tested) he doesn't have a penis, no visible testicles and is incontinent as his bladder didn't form properly. For several reasons not relevant constructive surgery so far has not proved very successful so the current focus is on helping him achieve continence as this is more important for him day to day. He came to me very distressed the other day as someone who he considered a friend and who seems to be involved feminist crowd, basically said he was fine to attend a woman's group as he isn't really male as men have penises.
At school the focus has very much been on biological sex which includes the fact that men have penises, women don't as a means of definition and within the trans debate which they have been gathering opinions on.
Basically I'm just looking for advice as to how to advise him? as you can imagine this is extremely sensitive. And if anyone has a better definition I could share with him?

Thank you.

OP posts:
IdaBWells · 24/10/2018 06:30

I haven't read the whole thread but I find it hard to believe. Firstly because he told a female friend he doesn't have a penis, I am not saying it couldn't happen that a young man would tell his female friend this but I think it's pretty unlikely. I never had a discussion about my genitalia with anyone as a teenager. I find it very hard to believe he would be going around sharing that information so freely.

Although if he is not releasing testosterone as he doesn't have testes and therefore seems more feminine he may have told her as an explanation. Yet wouldn't he be receiving hormone therapy?

I just find it unbelievable that just because he has this condition she would think he should fit in a women's group?! How incredibly insensitive can you be?

This just sounds like a set up to use this condition to have a hypothetical discussion about "does having no penis = being a woman?"

IdaBWells · 24/10/2018 06:39

Ok my apologies OP, I have read more of your thread and see it is genuine.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page