Philosopher's essay on what is a woman?

[Manderleyagain]

An interesting medium essay by a philosopher Dr Sophie Allen.

If Trans Women Are Women, What is a Woman?

If anyone is registered on medium, it might be worth looking at the comments. The first one is 'everything is going swimmingly in Canada'

medium.com/@s.r.allen/if-transwomen-are-women-what-is-a-woman-d36121bdd926

I'd like to see a discussion between Dr Allen and Ed Davey (see current thread about him).

Thanks to the spammer for resurrecting this. This medium article is from a time before I started reading into this issue, and so it's good to have the heads up.

Very thoughtful article.

Why so many deletions??

A spammer linking to an essay-writing service.

Oh I see!

I liked the article. Laid out well.

I read something the other day that puts things into perspective. It said;

"Of course Transwomen are men, that's their definition. A women cannot become a transwomen, only men can be transwomen"

Thanks for the bump. that is an excellent essay.