Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

New article on LM

25 replies

Geronimoleapinglizards · 25/02/2018 12:37

In the Independent

It is profoundly depressing that they haven't covered her lies and half-truths, her lack of work on women's issues and her attempts to block everyone who attempts to engage with her in debate.

It's utter biased rubbish

OP posts:
Badgerthebodger · 25/02/2018 12:48

God that’s rage inducing. I hate the claim that LM gets huge amounts of violent threats on social media - highly unlikely as so many people are automatically blocked. So many lies. Wonder when/if LM is going to go a step too far?

GuardianLions · 25/02/2018 14:57

Don't forget MRAs have lots of 'fake' accounts &sock puppets. It is highly likely they have fake feminist accounts and harass LM.

I saw one called 'Maria Mac' for example spouting the sort of shit that stirring infiltrators come out with.

GuardianLions · 25/02/2018 14:58

For example using words like 'scum' - which feminists never/extremely rarely use.

XXHelenaXX · 25/02/2018 15:06

I have tweeted @mayaoppenheim

"Why did you not ask Lily Madigan about his constant attack on feminists - who are "worse than Tories" and "cause deaths"?"

And sent her a link to this YT

to help educate her on what he means by "terf".

XXHelenaXX · 25/02/2018 15:14

It's essential to brush up ones trans-lation of trans-speak!

"Violent death threats" = someone deadnamed me. That's as good as killing me, hence it's a death threat.

"Horrific abuse" = someone misgendered me.

"Constant harassment" = feminists don't agree with me (on this one subject).

"virulent transphobia" -= saying "women don't have dicks" (in a virus-like manner)

"Madigan makes a concerted effort to speak to politicians. “MP’s may not have known a trans person so I try and speak to them just to have a normal chat not even discuss politics,” she says" = "I don't know anything about politics whatsoever, so we chat about the price of cute clothes".

GuardianLions · 25/02/2018 15:32

Interesting that this thread on Alice Dreger is going on www.mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_rights/3177912-Interesting-experience-of-public-speaking-from-Alice-Dreger - she said there are fake accounts with her name saying 'comically bigoted' things.

There are definitely MRAs behind all this shit. I am sure there are fake accounts in the names of all key gender critical feminists stoking up the gullible trans and their handmaidens.

And it is worth being aware that it works the other way too. Fake 'trans' accounts spouting ridiculous things to wind up feminists.

AssignedPuuurfectAtBirth · 25/02/2018 15:41

LM doesn't get a lot of abuse. He doesn't actually get that many tweets about him at all, which I'm sure is most offensive to his sensibilities.

I know because it's easy to monitor twitter @ I do this because he and others like him like to tell stories. They are too stupid to understand how twitter works though

tobee · 25/02/2018 16:13

Really disappointing to see about Wes Streeting support. I had great hopes of him being the future rational side of Labour after the current shower finally leave the leadership.

tobee · 25/02/2018 16:16

What kind of journalism is this? Not exactly any questions, let alone probing. Not an interview. Just like some feeble publicity puff. It'd be embarrassing for the school mag.

tobee · 25/02/2018 16:18

XXHelena Let us know if you get a response.

daysofpearlyspencer · 25/02/2018 16:59

LM claimed to be a "teenage girl". Reporter never even queried although the article itself stated he was 20!

TERFousBreakdown · 25/02/2018 17:05

@daysofpearlyspencer, maybe Lily is trans-16. Confused

vaginafetishist · 25/02/2018 17:09

Rage. 'My school wouldn't treat me like a girl'. This movement is idiotic.

vaginafetishist · 25/02/2018 17:10

'Violent-ness 'Hmm

LifelongVaginaOwner · 25/02/2018 17:14

It's a terrible puff piece which seems to consist of lots of re-hashed details from previous pieces, particularly ones from Pink News, and no fact-checking.

From the article "Madigan... has been living as transgender for four years now"

From a Huff Post article from 2016 "Lily came out as transgender in a Facebook post in January 2016"

www.huffingtonpost.co.uk/entry/transgender-schoolgirl-solicitor-suspension_uk_5800a8dae4b0010a7f3e6647

At some point presumably someone will realise that Lily is a fantasist. I wonder whether this was arranged by the Labour Party. If so I don't hold out much hope of Lily being reined in any time soon.

mamaryllis · 25/02/2018 17:23

Really interesting to see Trumpian politics in action though. You can essentially make up whatever Bullshit you like, publish it as fact, and the masses suck their teefs and blindly agree with every word. It's very interesting. What's more interesting is that where Don allegedly knows what he is doing (essentially, well, everyone is thick, I can lie and get elected - although the jury is out on whether he has convinced even himself that he is the Messiah now) LM apparently wasn't ever able to differentiate between an outright lie in order to court followers, and has never been able to differentiate cynical ploy from fiction. That's where it strays into the territory of potential personality disorder, which worries me. There is a huge difference between a calculating spokesperson who knows full well that they are lying to achieve a particular effect, and a traumatised or potentially unwell person who believes their feelings are indeed facts and intends to campaign for societal changes based on that. I feel hurt so you must have hurt me. I'm going to ensure you can never hurt me or anyone else like me again.
It reminds me a lot of the latter chapters of Walking on Eggshells, with false allegations of abuse etc. It's very dangerous for both sides, and continuing to give Lily a platform without some very sensible down to earth support isn't helpful for anyone.

So I'm a bit torn. Either LM is cynically using absolute lies for the cause (not completely persuaded, as this would also mean cynical use of vulnerable lady tears) or is indeed a vulnerable individual who really should be supported and not put in a position that they are unable to cope with (erring towards this. The more I see, the more I get echoes of the people I have known with PD).

Or yeah, possibly just immaturity and incompetence being dressed up by journos with mad virtue-signalling.

Lazy lazy journalism either way though. Quite sloppy. It's a bit embarrassing, all this dumbing down. It makes me a bit embarrassed on their behalf. I would expect better from high school students.

tobee · 25/02/2018 17:33

The thing is, I don't think LM knows what support is. Those encouraging LM's political career would call that support. I would not.

TERFousBreakdown · 25/02/2018 19:40

Those encouraging LM's political career would call that support.

It really isn't! LM is throwing temper tantrums all over Twitter. This may work for a little while for a youth politician because of its novelty value. However, it won't make anyone take LM seriously in politics.

LM is really thin on substance, refuses to engage with anyone who even asks questions (never mind people who disagree) and resorts to simply calling people 'TERF' in lieu of an actual argument. LM's actual policy suggestions, if they can be called that, include kicking people out of the LP and 're-educating' women who object to the presence of physical males in women's spaces on religious grounds. LM apparently doesn't realise just how much this smacks of Stalinism - that's never a good thing but particularly not in the LP.

LM wouldn't stand a snowball's chance in hell in the Commons. Why are people encouraging this? In my worst tinfoil-hat moments, I ponder whether it's all a huge elaborate real-life trolling exercise!

tobee · 25/02/2018 19:47

That bit about keeping the green seats warm horrified me! What a ghastly thing to say about yourself and then to report!

I keep thinking surely this is just a fad that will be seen for what it is? But then I thought that about leaving the EU and Candidate Trump. SadAngry. Laws will be rushed through (virtue signalling) when it's so infinitely more complicated than that. And we shall all be fucked!

Pickleshickles · 25/02/2018 22:30

I just replied to a tweet from lily regarding his refusal to respond to a question. I was I shit you not blocked 8 seconds after the tweet.

I'm this close to quitting my labour membership over this dip shit.

tobee · 25/02/2018 22:47

Yes. Constantly asking myself if I will do that. But wondering whether I should stay to add to moderate membership. Just feel totally disenfranchised.

The trans debate is one of many highly dubious things in the party these days.

tobee · 25/02/2018 22:51

I wouldn't be surprised if interested parties work full time on LM's tweets. Momentum? Or have they got some kind of algorithm that detects certain words or phrases?

My CLP have just elected a Momentum candidate as prospective candidate. This was previously an anti Corbyn local party. I despair.

Pickleshickles · 25/02/2018 22:56

I simply said that "you can't be an mp and not respond to questions"

So a keyword search wouldn't have picked anything up. It was clearly read and blocked by a human hand.

Just such an utter embarrassment. Their entire prominence is based on their transition and there is no substance whatsoever.

I'm a massive left winger, I want labour to win but I'm starting to believe that the party is corrupt.

thebewilderness · 25/02/2018 23:04

20 year old male who identifies as a women is treated like women are on social network=Headline News.

tobee · 25/02/2018 23:08

There are a lot of highly unpleasant people pushing Labour at the moment. Who don't have s problem with stooping to intimidation and violence.

Where the hell is there to go? I could never vote Tory. LibDems are a massive joke. I was hoping for a split, although not likely to go well. There was some talk of some moderate party but involving people like George Osborne. No way! Not only is he ideologically appalling, he's actually economically incompetent. But I'm detailing the thread. I fucking hate Corbyn and McDonnel and always have.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page