My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

is there and 'official' feminist view on prostitution? and what is it?

183 replies

ohnoitshimagain · 27/12/2013 09:48

hi, just signed up and want to get to the bottom of this issue

ok, I'm sure there's not an official view as such, but how about a consensus or just your own personal view on this topic

  1. Should prostitution be fully legalised including brothels?


I believe it should in the modern day, because of freedom

and I'm talking here about female prostitutes and male clients

hope to hear some responses, thanks, btw I"m a man
OP posts:
Report
Grennie · 29/12/2013 14:51
Report
AnyFuckerForAMincePie · 29/12/2013 14:52

Have liked Sheila Jeffrey's FB page and see I have two "friends" there already Smile

Report
grimbletart · 29/12/2013 16:06

I still don't see why the idea of women willingly engaging in sex work seems to infuriate some feminists so much more than women willingly engaging in marriage/longterm heteromonogamous relationships that are unequal.

I don't see why any woman would settle for an unequal marriage either SGB, but given that as a society there are still many women who do not have equality within marriage some may decide that being penetrated by one man a few occasions a week is preferable to being penetrated by scores of losers who may beat you, assault you or give you the latest unsocial disease they may be harbouring because of their promiscuity.

Report
WhentheRed · 29/12/2013 17:53

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

SolidGoldBrass · 29/12/2013 18:22

Basil - there are, actually, quite a few men who set themselves up as sexual healers/therapists and charge for their services. That might be an interesting side-discussion eg are they creepy predators or meeting needs in a worthy fashion?

Report
AnyFuckerForAMincePie · 29/12/2013 18:29

There's one called Brian from Hull, I believe.

Report
AskBasil · 29/12/2013 18:31

Well, I haven't come across many but I do remember one who was linked to on here who went on and on about yoni, though I appear to have erased the details from my mind. Xmas Grin

Er, he came across as a creepy predator, can't think why. Perhaps someone knows of one who doesn't come across that way?

Report
AskBasil · 29/12/2013 18:34

It may well have been Brian from Hull. Grin

Though I couldn't swear to it, I bleached my brain so thoroughly appear to have also erased the memory of his name as well as all his yoni details.

Report
AnyFuckerForAMincePie · 29/12/2013 19:01

T'was him Xmas Grin

Report
AnyFuckerForAMincePie · 29/12/2013 19:02

I believe he also used the medium of pm to offer his "healing services"

I am surprised my GP didn't suggest it when I went to see her about my hysterical tendencies Xmas Wink

Report
CuntyBunty · 29/12/2013 19:51

Is that why the other prostitution thread by the same OP was deleted?

Report
AnyFuckerForAMincePie · 29/12/2013 19:55

Dunno, CB. I didn't see it. What was the reason for deletion given by HQ ?

Report
TheDoctrineOfSanta · 29/12/2013 20:05

Just a breaking talk guidelines one, AF. Possibly because it was a Fred about a Fred or possibly cos OP was gar shiny MNHQ's post Christmas mellow

Report
TheDoctrineOfSanta · 29/12/2013 20:06

Gar shiny???

Harshing.

Report
AnyFuckerForAMincePie · 29/12/2013 20:12

Am not sure I am any the wiser Smile

Report
TheDoctrineOfSanta · 29/12/2013 20:23

I've only had one glass of Wine!

Report
KerryKatonasKhakis · 29/12/2013 21:35

If prostitution is about "care" and helping men with their needs, that should be a job open to anyone. The patient does not get to choose the provider and male "caregivers" should not be refused. There should be no regard to the age, race, weight or other physical characteristics of the "caregiver".

Also, caregivers have health and safety regulations to cover absolutely every task they undertake, from gloves to how many people are required to lift a patient. They receive training on how to carry out the job safely. How do health and safety regulations work in prostitution? How many times can a woman be penetrated in a day without causing injury? How much numbing cream should a woman be permitted to use? How does wearing a condom prevent the transfer of fecal matter from the woman's anus to her urinary tract in anal-to-vaginal sex?

Excellent points Whenthe , especially about who performs the sex work. There is a shocking amount of racism and disablism in prostitution and pornography and there are no laws or rules against it...it's actively encouraged; fetishising Asian women for example.

I doubt sex workers could ever become legal employees because you wouldn't get past the HSE risk assessments or be able to conform with the Equality Act. They would all need to remain self employed, thus no maternity/sick pay/pension/subsidised healthcare/working hour restrictions etc...not much of an improvement.

Speaks volumes OP that you point out that men can't be prostitutes because women, in general, won't pay for it. Who said your clients need to be women? Yeah, you might be hetero but if it's just a job and just an hour by hour rent of your body, why not let a man use it? It's not about your pleasure or attraction (or do you really thing the women are attracted to their punters)...now doesn't that sound fucking grim.

Report
WhentheRed · 29/12/2013 22:25

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

DadWasHere · 29/12/2013 22:34

Dad I think those women's views are also influenced by the constant message that men want sex all the time and are always up for it.

So in their minds, by paying a man to shag them they're doing him a favour - he would do it for free anyway, the thinking goes. (It's not thinking I agree with because I don't buy the myth that men are always up for sex - I don't think they would have been able to rule the world if they were such slaves to it - but that ridiculous attitude is extremely widespread and encouraged by a media which appears to believe that it's desirable for everyone to believe that men are more obsessed with sex than women are.)

Interesting stuff Basil but that was not my partners thinking at all, her thinking was that if you cant get good sexual satisfaction for free its morally OK and sexually satisfying to pay for an arousing and competent lover who, though otherwise uninterested in sex, could 'fuck you properly' (her words). What you talk about is a woman who chooses (like a proportion of men who frequent female prostitutes) to delude herself that their paid partner enjoys the act.

I am aware that women more commonly think men are always up for sex, I know that because I see messages from women around the net who express utter surprise bordering on incredulity when in an otherwise healthy relationship they discover their mans sexual drive is less than their own. However they are, as far as I can judge, significantly fewer than men who discover the same about their female partners. I think the thinking that men 'are always up for it' has a good basis in reality, if not that one particular man then, collectively, that next one in line will be 'up for it'.

Whereas men who are OK with paying for sex are having their ideas and attitudes shaped in a society which sends out very different messages about women. Women aren'tsupposedto enjoy sex, just gatekeep it. Except when theyaresupposed to enjoy it otherwise they're fridid. Or something. So the implications of them handing over money to a woman for sex, are different. Some men get positively turned on by the idea that the woman they are using actively dislikes what they're doing, while others kid themselves the women they use enjoy it because that fiction preserves their sense of themselves as decent men.

I wonder if the women you knew who were OK with the idea of buying sex for themselves, would be quite so keen on the idea if presented with the notion that they would probably be buying it from a young man who had been raped or sexually abused, was emotionally vulnerable and really didn't want to do it but was forcing himself to for the money. Not such a turn on for most women, while for many male punters, not such a problem?

Hrmmm. What you talk about goes to the darkest heart of prostitution, men who use women and dont care a damn what the woman feels or even pretends to feel, or even if she feels at all. Basically rape 'consent' obtained with money. Yes, I think men as a gender would be much more commonly inclined to 'use' a woman to that base level than visa-versa. How common that is within prostitution I don't know.

In general terms I think there is a different mind-trick going on women Vs me, if a male prostitute uses 'pornography in his head' during the sex to maintain an erection the erection itself to the female client can be seen as tangible and near undeniable proof of her sexual desirability and the mans enthusiastic compliance, in a far more effective way than all the fake moans and orgasms of a woman being used by a man.

Random passing thought- I think the idea of sex rejection between the genders is out of whack on both sides but in different ways. I think women take lack of desire for them more personally- 'its not that he does not desire, its that he does not desire me'. Men in the same situation seem to feel that their partner has just lost desire per se, they dont as commonly see it as attached to their desirability unless they feel they have lost the ability to perform intercourse. Or I could be off in thinking that.

Report
Susyb30 · 01/01/2014 23:26

Yes, men will always want sex..and if they aren't able to pay for it if they, in my opinion, could go to lengths that puts women in more danger. Having worked as an escort myself I was sometimes put in situations where I felt very vulnerable and I would definitely have felt safer if it was a controlled environment. Men from all walks of life, pilots, doctors ..you name it..from the man who's feeling lonely, horny, wife away,just had baby and not getting any (oh poor bastards)..believe me you would be shocked at who pays for sex. And yes some wierdos and men who would definitely go out their way to get the sex they crave. Im so glad im out of it now..I found it very degrading and at times I wanted to tell those pathetic men what I really thought of them..did they really think I was actually wanting to have sex with them? Ha.iv got a wonderful partner now and a Beautiful little boy. .but it has fucked my head up..apart from my partner I really do think the majority of men are sad bastards. .and sex obsessed. Its never going to go away..women have a right tobe safe, and protected..whatever they do.

Report
AskBasil · 01/01/2014 23:30

Susyb I think you need to remember that not all men are rapists.

The sort of men who are punters are, but they are a minority (I hope).

Report
ApocalypseThen · 02/01/2014 08:37

Sadly, though, the prioritization of the views/interests/wants of the punterverse types continues, regardless of the consequences for women. This is because it's not just a straight up two way choice and freed

Report
ApocalypseThen · 02/01/2014 08:40

(sorry) freedom debate (as our freedom-loving social science smart-arse seems to think), it's about whose interests, priorities and views prevail.

Regardless of how toxic, the view that women are sex vendors in one form or another (sale, barter or theft) is preferred.

Report
insuburbian · 11/03/2014 14:06

feminists want prostitution illegal, along with fornification.

sex must be between a loving married couple. anything else is violence against women

Report
LurcioLovesFrankie · 11/03/2014 14:22

Insuburbian - I can only assume from your last post that you have never actually had consensual, mutually enjoyable sex. What an absolutely ridiculous thing to post.

What most women want is to have enjoyable sex -whether casual or committed will depend on the individual and the circumstances - with partners of their choosing. Those are the crucial words - of their choosing. Flashing wads of cash at desperate women removes that option from them.

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.