Thoughts anyone? I've just finished it.
My fairly non-spoilery opinion:
Didn't love it, unfortunately. I re-read TTTW beforehand and adored it all over again. Beautiful love story. ALOOO does not have that same amazing thread of love. I felt it was flitting from one set of characters to another. Also the first quarter felt extremely confusing, trying to work out whether she was referencing something in real life or in an alternative version of the present. I could have paused to look things up but didn't want to interrupt my own flow.
Some things she's extremely melodramatic about as well, like I think at one point Trump's election is described as "the beginning of the end" or similar. I'm as anti trump as the next person, but something like that either needs to be self evidently true or else somehow true or relevant in the context of the book, and it was neither - never gets mentioned again- so I found moments like that confusing.
I did like pretty much all the characters and was pleased that Clare was pretty central, not just Alba. And I was pretty gripped by the end... maybe on a future re-read I'll like it more.
also - spoiler alert
dont read if you don't want the spoiler
ok by the end, there's no one in a traditional straight relationship. As a bisexual woman I've read plenty of gay fiction, but that felt really performative and artificial. Particularly in the context of the book being entirely about the future / what will the future be like / how do we navigate the future, it implied to me that AN was trying to express something about "future" relationships. Which struck an entirely false note with me. Felt like the book equivalent of a teenager being in love for the first time and that self involved belief (that we all have) that no one has ever been in love like that and former generations just cannot understand. Whereas in actual fact, all these concepts have already withstood the test of time and been around for as long as humans- not some futuristic way forward.
interested to hear what everyone else thinks?