Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

50 Book Challenge 2021 Part Five

1000 replies

southeastdweller · 13/04/2021 22:56

Welcome to the fifth thread of the 50 Book Challenge for this year.

The challenge is to read fifty books (or more!) in 2021, though reading fifty isn't mandatory. Any type of book can count, and please try to let us all know your thoughts on what you've read. Could everyone embolden their titles and/or authors as well, please, as it makes the books talked about easier to track?

The first thread of the year is here, the second one here, the third one here and the fourth one here.

How're you getting on so far?

OP posts:
VikingNorthUtsire · 21/04/2021 09:54

I can never remember which swirly-cover historic woo book is which. I know of them is about the Pendle witches, and as we have a week's holiday booked in that area later this year (fingers crossed!), I will Google which book it is so I can read it while I am there.

Couple of quick updates from me; two long-waiting-list library reservations came through this week:

36. Girl A, Abigail Dean

I didn't feel uncomfortable reading this (sad and upset by the subject matter, yes) but did a bit after hearing a few author interviews, especially with Simon Mayo, which seemed incongruously light-hearted and silly given that this book was inspired by (if not based on) real events.

As a piece of writing though, I thought it was done with subtlety and imagination. I liked the trickiness of the narrative - a bit gimmicky maybe but it worked for me.

37. The Thursday Murder Club, Richard Osman

What is there to say? It's readable, it's fairly well done, it's not as funny as I had hoped. Enjoyed reading it, wouldn't rush to read the sequel.

mackerella · 21/04/2021 10:27

Huge apologies in advance for a mammoth post!

30. The President is Missing by Bill Clinton and James Patterson

Preposterous thriller about a cyber attack on the US which only the POTUS can foil. I was in search of some light relief after The Mercies and this certainly provided.

The hook here is that the book is a collaboration between an accomplished thriller writer and an actual ex-president, and who could resist a combination like that? Clinton has obviously treated the whole thing as both apologia and wish-fulfilment fantasy, with fascinating results: the narrative swerves between earnest justification for the kind of difficult and unpalatable decisions presidents have to make (would you launch a missile strike on a compound where two elusive and wanted terrorists are holed up, knowing that there are children in there? How do you keep your caucus onside without selling out your principles?) and panting adoration of the office of POTUS (and by implication, those who fill it). President Jonathan Duncan is a paragon: ex-military, he served valiantly in Iraq and suffered torture as a PoW, never betraying his country (Clinton is accused of trying to dodge the draft); he is a champion athlete and a star law student; he married his college sweetheart (just as Clinton did) and became a doting father who only child is studying abroad (just as Chelsea did); he is impeached by opportunistic Republican scoundrels but gets through on sheer charm and manly force of will; he has a chronic illness (the weirdly topical immune thrombocytopenia) but doesn't let details like a dangerously low platelet count stop him from saving the country. Unsurprisingly, he turns out to be the kind of president who will run headfirst towards gunshots rather than stay safe and let his agents deal with it, and is even instrumental in cracking the Top Sekrit cyber-terrorists' code where all the boffins have failed. The Mary Sue-ing is par for the course in this type of book, but I did raise an eyebrow when he revealed that his beloved wife had recently and conveniently died from cancer (I wonder what Hillary thinks of this Grin). I assumed this was so he would be freed up to shag an intern a new love interest but he was too busy Saving The World for relationships.

Half of the chapters are narrated from the POV of a pregnant Bosnian mercenary who uses the nom de guerre "Bach" (in tribute to JS, whose works got her through a tough time in Sarajevo), and who has nicknamed her assault weapon "Anna Magdalena". As a Bach superfan, I sympathised with this probably more than I should have done (and have resolved to call myself "Bach" if I ever decide to become an international assassin).

The plot is about ... actually, who cares? It's stuffed full of explosions and weapons porn and lovingly-researched technobabble and chest-beating patriotism and macho face-offs between political opponents: basically, everything that you'd expect in a chunky thriller with gold letters on the front. I just went along with the flow, and ignored such pesky questions as "why is the main terrorist organisation called Sons of Jihad when the narrator is at such pains to assure us that they are extreme nationalists and not Islamists?" and "Why would a genius hacker create malware so sophisticated that the best coders in the US can't disarm it and then undermine it with a password so simple that even an idiot could guess it?"

I listened to this on Borrowbox, and the narration is hilariously bad: Dennis Quaid narrates the President's thoughts with the kind of gravelly tones used in trailers for action movies, several of the characters speak so robotically that I genuinely thought it was synthesised speech rather than real actors, and most of the attempted accents (Israeli, Balkan, Czech, German) are excruciating. Despite this, I found myself glued to the story and spent several days listening during every opportunity I had - while washing up, or gardening, or on the way back from the school run. Obviously, the book is complete tosh, but it was an enjoyable counterbalance to the self-conscious literariness of The Mercies and its ilk, and I'm not ashamed to admit that I lapped up every word! (Clinton and Patterson are scheduled to release a second book later this year, and I'll probably read that one as well Blush.)

CoteDAzur · 21/04/2021 10:39

"nom de guerre "Bach" (in tribute to JS, whose works got her through a tough time in Sarajevo), and who has nicknamed her assault weapon "Anna Magdalena". As a Bach superfan, I sympathised with this probably more than I should have done (and have resolved to call myself "Bach" if I ever decide to become an international assassin)."

You are my spirit twin Grin

Would you believe that I was just looking into getting a temporary tattoo of Bach's seal this morning?

bibliomania · 21/04/2021 10:42

I love that you are prepared with an international assassin code-name, Just In Case, mack.

I'm deep in the Pym biography. It seems to be based almost entirely on her previously-published personal papers (now there's a tongue twister) so nothing very new so far.

bibliomania · 21/04/2021 10:44

For a moment I was thinking of seal as in the mammal, Cote. I was thinking it made a change from dolphins.

No, I don't know why Bach would have had one.

PepeLePew · 21/04/2021 10:49

You're selling me on The President Is Missing, mackerella. I do like a big splashy well done thriller and am very happy to suspend disbelief in pursuit of one. If I ever get a holiday then it shall be on the list for poolside reading.

32 Diary of an MP's Wife by Sasha Swire
This is quite something. Unlike a lot of "tell all" memoirs it really does deliver and I cannot think how uncomfortable it must have made almost everyone featured in it, as even her friends (David Cameron, Amber Rudd, Nicholas Soames) come in for some unrelenting attacks (Cameron in particular comes across as lazy and lecherous with a particular fondness for off colour jokes and clumsy flirting), while the people she doesn't like (Theresa May, Michael Gove, Dominic Cummings) have acid dripped on them from an enormous height. She's bitchy, droll and really funny - and seemingly hellbent on ripping apart any hope the Swires may have had of continuing to be invited to dinner parties in the future. Her politics aren't mine, and she comes across as completely insufferable, but she's wildly entertaining and totally unfiltered (although I picked up a lot of places where I expect there was some judicious retrospective editing to lay the way for what followed). I expect her publishers were absolutely delighted when this landed in her lap. If I stop and think about it for too long it's really quite depressing that we are governed by these people, but when I was able to put that aside I found it extremely diverting. If only it was someone else's country...

CoteDAzur · 21/04/2021 10:52
  1. Firewalkers by Adrian Tchaikovsky

As I have said before in the past 12 months, this author is fast becoming one of my favourite SF writers. This book starts a bit slow but his detailed world building is brilliant and his ideas original as usual.

The story is about young "firewalkers" on a near-future Earth wrecked by higher temperatures, who go out and repair the generators, solar panels, and other vital machinery left behind by elite humans who now live in 'anchored' habitats in orbit. In their dangerous quest to find out what is happening to failed solar panels outside one of the few cities left on Earth, they discover the emergence of a new intelligence and change the course of humanity.

I enjoyed this book even if not quite as much as the author's Dogs of War, Bear Head, and Cage of Souls, and would recommend it especially at its current price of 99p.

CoteDAzur · 21/04/2021 10:53

biblio Grin

A seal would have been quite the curiosity in landlocked Leipzig, Germany.

CoteDAzur · 21/04/2021 10:59
  1. Piranesi by Susanna Clarke

I didn't enjoy this nearly as much as most reviewers on these threads, although I am a big fan of the author's Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell.

It was mercifully short at 243 pages and the last 1/3 or so was OK, but I am not about to forgive Susanna Clarke for at least a hundred pages of nonsense about statues, tides, and fish.

This could have been a great short story or a novella. It just didn't have enough of a plot to stretch across a whole book.

mackerella · 21/04/2021 11:03

Would you believe that I was just looking into getting a temporary tattoo of Bach's seal this morning?

Of course I would, Cote - in fact, I'll get one myself if you do Grin.

The Sasha Swire book sounds very entertaining, Pepe! I'm not going to be anywhere near a poolside this year, sadly, but I've already booked some less glamorous UK-based breaks, and it sounds like ideal book to take camping.

SapatSea · 21/04/2021 11:10

Totally agree about Piranesi , Cote. Thought I might be the only one who didn't absolutely love it.

PepeLePew · 21/04/2021 11:18

I wasn't that enthralled by Piranesi. I read it quickly as it needed to go back the library but it seemed quite long winded for a short book and I didn't ever really engage with the story.

LadybirdDaphne · 21/04/2021 11:37

I liked Piranesi a lot but I felt too much was revealed too soon, which did give a sense of it being overly stretched out.

cassandre · 21/04/2021 11:37

Ooh, interesting review of The Mercies, Mackarella, I'm hoping to read it soon. The inconsistencies in setting do sound annoying, as well as the facile representation of religion.

elkiedee, I really rate Amanda Craig as a writer too; maybe what I said about The Golden Rule sounded too harsh. I enjoyed it, I just didn't think it was her best book either.

Stokey · 21/04/2021 11:38

The salacious part of me quite enjoyed reading the extracts of Sasha Swires's bitchfest in the Times last year so will look out for this Pepe.

LadybirdDaphne · 21/04/2021 11:43
  1. Writing Historical Fiction - Celia Brayfield & Duncan Sprott

Who knows, maybe one day...? Anyway I promise not to churn out anything with a dark swirly gothic cover, witchy wise women (with or without diabolical dogs) or Sarah Waters-wannabe sapphic liaisons...

Hushabyelullaby · 21/04/2021 13:16

[quote Lockdowntherabbithole]@Hushabyelullaby Thank you for this review! I’ve just bought it on my kindle. I’m a bit “thriller’ed out” at the minute. I feel like I’m walking around anticipating murders/stalking and need a different genre!![/quote]
Oh I hope you like it @Lockdowntherabbithole, I always feel pressure if someone else is reading a book I've reviewed, in case they totally disagree with my opinion and I've given a false impression of it. I look forward to reading your review!

Piggywaspushed · 21/04/2021 14:01

Interesting review of The Mercies! I didn't notice most of the plot holes as I was captivated by her writing but I nonetheless agree with everything you say!

I think I was so relieved when I read it last year that it was so much better than other swirly covered witchy books by and about women!

mackerella · 21/04/2021 14:05

Gosh, I hope I haven't put you off, cassandre! As I (hope I) conveyed, it's not a bad book, but I just found it lacking in some way. I know a few people here have read it and liked it. Anyway, I'd be really interested to hear what you make of it, especially as we've both liked the Ali Smith seasonal quartet. In fact, I've just downloaded Spring to read before it gets to June and I won't be able to read it until the following March Grin.

DO IT, Daphne! In fact, perhaps you could write the one about Charlotte Lucas and Mary Bennet running off together (complete with breeches, sensational novels and Ken Follett BREASTS) that was discussed a couple of threads ago?

Soozikinzi · 21/04/2021 14:20

1 Fifty fifty - Steve kavanagh the novelty of not knowing which sister is which wore a bit thin .
2 The Salt path Rayner Wynn fantastic especially if you are familiar with any parts of the coastal path.
3 One summer, America Bill Bryson especially enjoyed this while watching Boardwalk Empire
4 The Autograph man Zadie Smith
5 America Stephen Fry
6 The Dutch House Ann Patchett
7, 19 minutes Jodi Picoult found this too harrowing but I suppose that shows the skill of the author!
8 Small great things Jodi Picoult my favourite of hers
9 Plain truth Jodi Picoult
10Where the Crawdads sing Delia Owens - did live up to the hype !
11 Villa's journey Heather Morris
12 City of friends Joanna Trollope
13 Disrupted Dan Lyons
14 Thinking about it only makes it worse David Mitchell
15 The nanny state made me Stuart Maconie
16 The beekeeper of Aleppo Christy Lefertti
17 Macbeth Jo Nesbo
18 Sense and Sensibility Jane Austen
19 If morning ever comes Ann Tyler
20 Song of Solomon Toni Morrison
21 The Nix Nathan Hill
22 The curious heart of Alisa Rae Stephanie Butland
23 And my favourite Russell Kane's Autobiography Son of a silverback so funny and the only book I've ever read about the kind of real people I know !

But I came on here after reading those who couldn't get through James Joyce to point out that Andrew Scott -the handsome priest in Fleabag - reads the abridged version of the portrait of the artist as a young man on BBC sounds book at bedtime absolutely brilliantly.

JaninaDuszejko · 21/04/2021 14:29

I can't think of Andrew Scott as handsome ever since I saw his face described on MN as Ant and Dec combined Grin. He will always be Moriarty though.

VikingNorthUtsire · 21/04/2021 15:25

Mackarella I'm reading Spring ATM - first read of it for me, I really like Ali Smith.

ChannelLightVessel · 21/04/2021 15:33

Some great review-writing recently, thank you all. How do you get a temporary tattoo?

36. Nervous Conditions - Tsiti Dangarembga
Her Booker short-listed This Mournable Body is a follow-up to this novel (though I think it can also be read as a standalone), so I thought I’d read this first. Also it was heavily reduced on Kindle.
Set in Rhodesia under UDI, the main character, Tambudzai, is a Black schoolgirl determined to pursue her education despite the obstacles put in place by imperialism and a highly patriarchal society. Her extended family provide examples of the difficult choices Black women face.
The novel provides a very interesting insight into a society I know little about, and Dangarembga writes with a nice irony about the racism and self-delusions of white Rhodesia, but sometimes I found her style a bit flat, and the book ends rather abruptly. I certainly intend to read the sequel.

37-39. Space Boy Vols. 2-4 - Neil McCranie
Passed on by DD(12), a SF graphic series. Amy, 16, has spent her life on a mining colony in deep space, but now her father has lost his job (disappointingly, her mother is a housewife), the family must come to Earth, a 30-year journey in cryogenic suspension. As Amy gets used to her new life - McCranie has fun with her encounters with strange new phenomena such as snails and rain - she becomes drawn to a mysterious boy, the eponymous Space Boy, at her new school. The plot hasn’t progressed much (there’s at least 11 volumes), but the characterisation of Amy and her new high school friends is well done.

MamaNewtNewt · 21/04/2021 17:03

I started Piranesi a couple of days ago as I saw so many good reviews of it on here but I'm struggling to get into it. I think I'll persevere as it's so short and so many people enjoyed it, in the hope it gets better.

BestIsWest · 21/04/2021 17:10

@JaninaDuszejko

I can't think of Andrew Scott as handsome ever since I saw his face described on MN as Ant and Dec combined Grin. He will always be Moriarty though.
Never realised this but now you say it.
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread