Thank you southeast for the new thread :) Am struggling with what to highlight this year- lots of solid enjoyable reads with admirable elements, few standouts.
- Who They Was, Gabriel Krause
- Our Kind of Traitor, John Le Carre
- The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo, Taylor Jenkins Reid
4. Bricks and Mortar, Helen Ashton
- My Sister The Serial Killer, Oyinkan Braithwaite
- Period, Emma Barnett
- American Dirt, Jeanine Cummins
8. A Spell of Winter, Helen Dunmore
- Beneath the Streets, Adam Macqueen
10. A Very English Scandal, John Preston
11. You People, Nikita Lalwani
12. A Walk in the Woods: Rediscovering America on the Appalachian Trail, Bill Bryson
13. The Pull of the Stars, Emma Donoghue
14. Pilgrims, Matthew Kneale
15. Jew(ish), Matt Greene
16. The Lady in the Lake, Laura Lippman
17. How to Be Right, James O'Brien
18. The Mermaid and Mrs Hancock, Imogen Hermes Gowar
19. Fast Exercise, Michael Mosley
20. Stasiland, Anna Funder
21. Why Germans Do It Better: Tales from a Grown Up Country, John Kampfner
22. Findings, Kathleen Jamie
23. Nine Folds Make a Paper Swan, Ruth Gilligan
24. Less, Andrew Sean Greer
25. Sex Power Money, Sara Pascoe
26. The Wilder Life: My Adventures in the Lost World of Little House on the Prairie, Wendy McClure
27. Charlotte, Helen Moffett
28. Redhead by the Side of the Road, Anne Tyler
29. Boys & Sex: Young Men on Hookups, Love, Porn, Consent and Navigating the New Masculinity, Peggy Orenstein
30. Love After Love, Ingrid Persaud
31. What Katy Did, Susan Coolidge
32. Such a Fun Age, Kiley Reid
33. The Years, Annie Ernaux
Chessie I also have that Queen Mary book waiting on my Kindle after seeing it recommended somewhere. When I get round to reading it, I'll be interested to compare my impression to your review.
34. Meadowlark, Melanie Abrams
Simri and Arjun grow up in an isolated religious community in the US, a community very careful not to be labelled a cult. As they grow into adolescence, the expectations and restrictions placed on them by the community elders become ever more oppressive, until they decide to run away. However, after only a couple of nights in the outside world, Arjun abandons Simri and disappears from her life.
20 years later, she gets a message from him. He's living in another isolated idealistic community, this time a secular one and one where he is one of the founding members. A disgruntled ex-member has made some allegations of child neglect and abuse, and the police and press are asking questions. Arjun asks Simri, now an established photographer with a social media following, if she will visit and take some photos - he is convinced that when people see what his community is really like, they will realise that the allegations must be false.
This was a Kindle First Reads freebie from a while back - these can be quite hit and miss in my experience but I liked this one. The middle-of-nowhere locations in the middle of the empty American landscape are skilfully drawn, and I found the characters and the tensions between them believable if somewhat overwraught (but hey, this is a psychological thriller). I cared enough to feel frustrated that the ending leaves many of the plot threads unresolved - I wanted to answer more of my questions, and that's a sign that I was engaged.
35. The Appeal, Janice Hallett
This was one of those books that seemed to pop up everywhere last year. My ebook loan request came through just as I was finishing Meadowlark and TBH my heart sank, as I was expecting it to be a dark twisty psychological thriller with unreliable memories and vulnerable females (cf a million "Girl" books which have been bestsellers over recent years) - Meadowlark was a bit like that and, while I had enjoyed it, I didn't want another helping so soon.
Fortunately this book turned out to be rather different. For those who haven't read it, or read about it, it's essentially a detective novel in epistolary form. It starts with a note from a senior lawyer to two junior associates - he's sending them a bundle of emails and text messages relating to a case. He wants their fresh impressions so he is deliberately not telling them anything about the case - what the crime is, who (if anyone) has been found guilty.
We then get to the emails, which start with some wonderfully passive-aggressive interchanges between the members of a village Am Dram group, jostling for position as a new production is being cast. You quickly identify that there are a couple of alpha families, some hangers-on desperate to get into the in crowd, a couple of comedy characters, some mysterious new arrivals..... The whole thing, TBH, is like a rather dark and twisted episode of The Archers (and I'm not sure whether that is a compliment or not).
I am quite fussy with mystery/detective plots - when the reveals come, I need them to pick up on details which have been under our noses the whole time (HATE it when a twist introduces completely new information) but I also need not to have guessed too much in advance. This book does well in that regard - you do notice certain phrases which seem a bit off, or details which don't quite match between people's accounts, but for me at least, it still remained a mystery until the second half, where the lawyers start to message one another trying to work out the details. I do wish I had had a paper copy though, as when they start to put theories together, the urge was to go back and look again at the messages sent aroudn that time, to work out whether the theory seemed plausible or not - I got frustrated trying to do that with the ebook, especially in the rather shonky library app.
I've also DNF-ed two good books as follows:
DNF Scoff: A History of Food and Class in Britain, Pen Vogler
Well-researched, entertaining book: here you will find the answer to your questions such as why southerners' dinner is different to northerners' dinner, and how afternoon tea is different to high tea (and why one is common and the other one not). DNF because it's very very long and not IMHO the sort of book that works read straight through - it has dozens of short chapters and would be ideal to dip into. Not possible with a library book - it has gone back.
DNF Democracy for Sale: Dark Money and Dirty Politics, Peter Geoghegan
Another well-researched and very readable book. I got about 5 chapters in and had to give up as it was making me feel unspeakably angry and bleak. Our current Government and their friends and associates feature prominently among the bad guys here, using loopholes, anonymous organisations and secret money transfers to buy influence and evade scrutiny. A perfect companion piece to Christopher Wylie's MindF#ck for those who enjoyed that. But right now, I just couldn't.