Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

HP7 - So, who is it that does magic in this book who has never done it before?

14 replies

hockeypuck · 26/07/2007 12:29

Just finished HP7 - great book.

But was going through my mind about the spoilers issued beforehand and that JK Rowling said "x many people will die" blahdeblah etc and also "someone who has been in it before and not performed magic will perform magic" we had a whole thread about this in April/May, thinking it was petunia or someone.

Actually I was fully expecting it to be Dudley after he was quite nice to Harry in the beginning I thought he'd come back at the end and help him or something.

So who was it?
Did I miss it?

OP posts:
damewashalot · 26/07/2007 12:35

can't think of anyone.

Pruners · 26/07/2007 12:36

Message withdrawn

hockeypuck · 26/07/2007 12:53

What was Enid's name change? Did I miss that one?

OP posts:
Pruners · 26/07/2007 13:14

Message withdrawn

TheArmadillo · 26/07/2007 13:16

Kreacher's done it before I'm sure.

Don't think the Blacks would have kept him on otherwise.

I think she forgot or edited it out personally.

Steward · 26/07/2007 13:22

Not sure but it may have been a red herring. She also said Harry wasn't a horcrux but was.

SixKindsOfCrisis · 26/07/2007 13:27

did we ever see crabbe do magic before his fire thing in the room of requirement. And by the way, what a lame idea it was that voldie somehow 'didn't know' that others could use the room of requirement.

TheArmadillo · 26/07/2007 13:28

but if Crabbe actually couldn't use magic before then he wouldn't be at Hogwarts.

Think you're right Steward.

Pruners · 26/07/2007 13:52

Message withdrawn

Triwizardcupcakes · 26/07/2007 18:07

we hadn't seen Aberforth do magic previously.

skay · 26/07/2007 19:52

Was it Luna.

She stunned someone in the Ravenclaw Common room. And then she said that she had only ever stunned anyone in the DA Club when Harry was there.

PhoenixSongbird · 26/07/2007 20:26

Can't be Luna, everyone at Hogwarts will have done magic, and she's in Ravenclaw! Don't you remember the Gryffindor hat?

allmytimeonmumsnet · 27/07/2007 10:28

So it has to be someone that didn't go to Hogwarts!

janeitebus · 27/07/2007 14:54

Think Cupcakes is right. Hadn't thought of him, thanks Cupcakes.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page