Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

What we're reading

Find your new favourite book or recommend one on our Book forum.

Still obsessed with Harry Potter

1002 replies

BandofMothers · 21/06/2007 10:25

Hope there aren't now about 10 of these cos we've all opened at the same time.

OP posts:
MrsWeasley · 03/07/2007 17:41

harry isnt a horcrux, it doesnt make sense but was good to ponder it for a while.

persephonesnape · 03/07/2007 19:13

a teenage snape in love would be a 'horrible thing' because of the desperation and disbelief that someone could actually love him. I do see him as a bullied unloved child who loved someone who rejected him for his nemesis. Severus loves potions and hogwarts and still holds a flame for Lily..

How many days now?

LazyLine · 03/07/2007 19:27

Too many!

Snape is my favourite character. Easily the most interesting.

rosmerta · 03/07/2007 20:03

17 days, 3 hours, 56 mins, 40 secs to go!

Out of curiosity, how would you rank the books, best to worst? Mine would be:

OotP
HBP/GOF
PoA
PS
CoS

rosmerta · 03/07/2007 20:29

Has anyone done the predictions thing at the Leaky Cauldron website? It takes ages but you can stop & come back to it.

Anyway the reason I mention it is that one of the last questions is: Will Harry use the Draught of Living Death to go through the veil?

persephonesnape · 03/07/2007 20:41

gasp hadn't thought of that!

and if he could bring one person back - would it be James, Lily or Sirius...?

rosmerta · 03/07/2007 20:45

Or Dumbledore?

MrsWeasley · 03/07/2007 21:10

but you cant come back from the veil, can you?

persephonesnape · 03/07/2007 21:10

eeeee! but no, he'll gp for sirius i think - never knew his mum and dad and got a bit pissed off with dumblydore...

...the deathly hallows prediction thing is fine! so far i like luna being a descendant of ravenclaw!

MrsWeasley · 03/07/2007 21:14

I CANT WAIT ANOTHER 17 DAYS TO FIND OUT
AGHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH

janeite · 03/07/2007 21:18

In reply to Rosmerta's question:

POA
HBP
OOTP
PS
COS
GOF

I've just re-read OOTP and am now half way through HBP again. I really can't make up my mind about Snape anymore. With each re-reading it seems to become more complex. I feel that he MUST be a goodie because for him to be evil would in a way discredit DD's memory, though I still think that both Sirius and Dumbledore are going to be "reachable" in some way in book 7. Both the veil and Fawkes intrigue me there, as I think each of them will offer harry some sort of link to those he needs most, as it were.

And guess what I've spent this evening doing? Making a phoenix costume for dd2 ready for the book launch! Am v proud of it; all those flames/feathers lovingly coloured in! She won the cpmpetition last time, so we have a lot to live up to - lol!

persephonesnape · 03/07/2007 21:19

oh! oh! (deathly hallows prediction thingy update!) (there are 37 pages of this, so bear with me...)

aunt petunia refers to 'that dreadful boy' when harry is talking about azkaban and dementors. might not have been james! MAY HAVE BEEN SEVERUS!!

eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee! pop!

lilibetpotter · 03/07/2007 21:33

Hadn't thought of the Draught of Living death but that is such a good idea

who woudl he bring back? I think he would go for his dad after James's patronus saved him in POA

rosmerta · 03/07/2007 21:39

lol persephonesnape! There's still lots more to go!

I think if you've died you can't come back through the veil but maybe Harry will go through to find something out and if he's only pretending to be dead surely he can come back?

rosmerta · 03/07/2007 21:41

Just read that David Yates (who's directed OotP) has signed up to direct HBP as well, hope he's good

rosmerta · 03/07/2007 21:56

Dh has finally agreed to go see OotP, just booked our tickets!

YIPPPPPEEEEEE!!!!!!

MrsWeasley · 03/07/2007 22:14

I cant put them in any decent order, I've tried and then changed it so many time.

I like different things about each book! I hated getting to the end of book 4 because it felt like harry was hurting so much with no happy end in sight. It was a long sad wait for number 5!

persephonesnape · 03/07/2007 22:27

waterstones has mock-up copies at their till - like actual books but with blank pages.

i bet one of them is real! but i'm too embarrassed to start leafing through them all...

AlbusPercivalWulfricBrianSun · 03/07/2007 22:31

POA definitely my fave.
BTW MrsW call me SSMummy - is much easier. Just intrigued me that the colour of her eyes is important!
Just rereading HBP and they mention the word 'lucky' all the way through. Lucky re. Ron at Quidditch (when Harry pretends to put the FF in Ron's drink), lucky that Harry thought of a bezoar when Ron was poisoned, lucky Katie Bell only touched the necklace through a small hole in her glove. Made me think luck might be important and it would be comething V would discredit as not in his control. And doesn't Harry mention luck when he's telling the DA how he's fought V?

BandofMuggles · 04/07/2007 08:05

I think you can't bring people back thru the veil, but most people don't go thru the veil, they just die. Maybe because Sirius actually went thru it he will be able to come back thru it?????
Maybe he's in a sort of limbo.

I always read posts and think of things I want to say then forget them
I think Lily and Snape perhaps had a connection over the potions thing, and I think Lily did like James in the pensieve as Harry said he thought he saw her trying not to smile.

BandofMuggles · 04/07/2007 08:13

I was wondering last night when Harry won the Felix potion if he might use some against V.

TransfiguratingLily · 04/07/2007 08:55

Dew, I thought that if Harry/ his scar was a horcrux it was an accident. That V had done the neccesary spell but because he was making too many horcruxes which are so evil, when faced with the opposite thing...self sacrificing love, he didn't have the strength to kill Harry.
I thought if Harry's scar was a horcrux Voldemort didn't realise it would explain some of V powers being in Harry, scar burning, telepathic link etc.

Would explain why their wands locked and they couldn't kill each other because if they kill the other, they also must die...So it is Harry's protection but also stops him killing V. So Harry has to unhorcrux himself and lay himself bare before he can kill V??

And the last word is 'scar' apparently, so thought maybe he ends up without a scar and less magical powers... Not sure of course....

Now Dew never mind that...are you going to give birth whilst reading the Harry Potter book? And are you going to call the baby Harry or Harriot?

TransfiguratingLily · 04/07/2007 09:00

And he was telepathically connected to the snake who's a horcrux.....

lilibetpotter · 04/07/2007 09:25

It was on the news this morning that JKR is going to write an episode of Dr Who!

(Hostage, what Hostage?)

I do not live in the real world - sorry!!

AlbusPercivalWulfricBrianSun · 04/07/2007 10:06

Big poster of Ron and lucious Lucius in Waterloo makes me smile every morning.
They showed loads of the film on Breakfast which was great. Am v. much looking forward to it.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread