I'd like a sequel to Blubber, by Judy Blume: 20–30 years later, during the Halloween period, a glamorous, grown-up Linda tracks down Wendy, Caroline & Jill, and slaughters them! (It would be particularly apt, as the original story commences @ Halloween.) I did once suggest that on a website, but Judy herself said the sequel I had in mind would probably be too gruesome for most readers.
Are there any books which make you feel "I'd like to know what happens next in the characters' lives"?