We Are All Completely Beside Ourselves - suitable for 16yo?

[mummybare]

She's into animal rights. Is it suitable?

Cheers!

It is moving and sad but sometimes it's good for us to be challenged and provoked into thinking more about things. I say she should read it.

Oh yes, absolutely. It's a great read! Does she know the "twist"? Makes it far more powerful if she doesn't, but it's not really something you can 'unremember'?

She's not my dd - extended family - but I saw a review and thought of her so I might get it for her for Christmas. I think I will. Thanks for the advice.

Yes, but its crap

In what way, Brillo?

It just felt like someone was giving me a really tedious lecture on animal rights where nothing much happens.

Very suitable. A great read.

Yes, totally suitable for a 16 y/o. I thought it was an enjoyable easy read, I knew the 'twist' before hand and it didn't spoil it at all for me.

100% yes.

I can't think of any book that would not be suitable for a 16 year old.

I see your point, BringMe, but I wouldn't want to get her something with a lot of sex/violence/animal cruelty. It would be different if she were deliberately seeking it out, but it's a difficult age, isn't it? Some 16yos are so much more mature than others and it's difficult to know where to pitch these things if you only see them a couple of times a year. I think she'll like the book in this case though.

Oh I didn't realize it was a gift. Yes, in that case I probably wouldn't give American Psycho or Last Exit To Brooklyn. . I really enjoyed this book and one of the things I liked most was the animal rights angle as it is so thought-provoking so this could be right up her street.

I think it would be fine for a 16 year old.

I found it an interesting read, though I almost gave up, especially just after the 'twist' was revealed.