Started MFP'ing in March 2013. Had two fairly big bouts of falling off the wagon, which took me 8 months off schedule, but today sees me down from 202 to 167 pounds.
Have been struggling for last 2 months to get past 173 pounds, then decided to heed advice on MFP forums and increase daily calories. Six pounds has dropped off since 1 September and now that I've added 150 calories back in, I'm losing about 1/3 pound a day. So yes, the BMR/TDEE calculators have a point...for me, anyway.
Now need another 7 pounds to get to my original goal, which was to achieve BMI of 23 and see where the land lies thereafter.
Thank you to people on here who helped get me back into the routine after Wagon Fall Off 1, kind words and encouragement helped tremendously. And thanks to everyone on the Shred and C25K threads, too.