Late to this thread (in part, because I was busy mouthing off and completely failing to be funny on the loony ones yesterday 🙄)
You all know me well enough to expect a long rambling comment that has little relevance to anyone else's situation but here's my contribution.
I used to be very tolerant and polite about loose dogs running up, we would try to avoid situations because that is our way. However, all that changed when Algy was attacked and injured/traumatised at 16 weeks old. There was lasting damage for him and for me and I became dog phobic to the extent that in 7 years I never once walked him by myself. This had nothing to do with his behaviour, he was not aggressive, it was entirely down to my fear of dogs.
When Brie first started going out I was terrified but I toughed it out. In part because I was out to prove a point to myself and my chap, in part because female PMD are more independent/dominant/assertive than males.
Now she's big I have less fear. She could probably hold her own against all but a Bully, Cane Corso or Kangal if she was pushed. I'm still petrified of a lot of other dogs (particularly Labradors) but it's gradually getting easier.
What has changed, however, is my attitude. I've gone from outwardly polite whilst inwardly seething, to standing no messing. It's not desirable and I wish it wasn't the case but it's how it is. That is just my instinctive defence mechanism post dog-attack.
I think I've described before that I had to physically restrain the attacking dog, lifting it by its collar. The incident was 11 years ago and I suspect that could land me in trouble if I did it these days.
I do get verbal now. I'm ashamed to say it and I need to try to control it better. Especially after seeing Bupster's perspective here and knowing that Bill is a complete sweetheart. Sorry but I might have effed at you 😞It's about perceived threat in the heat of the moment. I'm really the last person that should feel that; my dogs are always on the lead and they don't bark anywhere away from their own territory, but their sheer size and bulk is overwhelming for some people. I promise I will work on my dog tolerance and stop the Keira Knightley-esque "will you control your fucking dog!" responses.
One thing about having giant dogs can be that people with the tiny breeds see your dog as fair-game for their little ones to snap and snarl at. Almost as if it's bear-baiting. They view it as tiny little Fido being brave and will even laugh 😡but it's really horrible for the big dog and slightly terrifying for its owner because if the biggun defends itself by warning the snapper, it is immediately labelled dangerous. I'm not anti small dog but some of them do seem to get away with behaviour that would be considered dangerous in a larger breed. We really have to tread carefully at all times these days.
So, for obvious reasons, we do live in fear of off-lead dogs rushing up and I would say that YorkshireFelix has every right to feel the same was about Vinny being harassed. I honestly don't know if I would get hold of someone's dog or not, it might just be that instinct kicked in, as on that previous occasion but these days I'm not sure I'd risk it. You can certainly tell people off though, to some extent. For us, it's mostly avoidance, but there will, inevitably, at some point, be a dog that has a go at Brie and potentially pushes her into responding. For me that's the bigger worry, given her size...
Sorry for the essay, folks 😊