@Foxgloveleaf the pate is squidgy but solid, almost rubbery? I cut it into tiny cubes and put in my treat pouch.
Dried sprats are another good option, mine will turn himself inside out for sprats!!
Cocktail sausages cut up small (slice and then quarter each slice)
Little bits of chicken breast. Cut up tiny as bingo prizes and add kibble to to treat pouch, the chicken flavour adds to the kibble.
Arden Grange Liver pate in a tube also a high value one
Primula cheese in a tube.