Butternut Box vs Different Dog

[Mummyme87]

I have an 11wk old mini Daxie and looking to move her from Royal Canin wet and dry to something like Butternut Box and Differwnt Dog.

They are both well reviewed and similar in price. Does anyone have any experience with either? Tried both?

I feel we have too much choice what did the breeder feed?
Why change?
WE use Burns for a Dandie Dinmont, cant fault it

Hi
Yes I have tried both. My dog got bored of both!
Both are good - Different Dog looked more appetising while Butternut seemed full of pulses. You need a lot of freezer space for both.
They are both so expensive! I now buy Barking Heads and Pooch & Mutt and mix it with rice and bone broth for a bit more taste. DDog generally eats that no problem and if he turns his nose up occasionally I don't feel like I've just wasted loads of money.

We fed Butternut for the first year and people used to comment on how shiny DDog’s coat was which they no longer do since we changed to dry food! I liked the head start it gave her when she was growing most, but changed when she grew bored of it. I’m afraid I haven’t tried Different Dog but interested to know about it so might look it up .
I don’t like the idea of just giving ours processed food full time although we now Mostly do and think there’s a lot to be said for fresh food too.