I can tell you right away that mine is the doggy dry bag. I LOVED the idea of this for my shaggy Shih Tzu pup, who attracts dirt and water on his walks like a mop. Reality hasn't stacked up! Have just used it for the first time and it turned my normally placid pup into a raging, snarling beast! He hated being put in it and not being able to feel his feet, and wriggled straight back out. Oh dear, not one of my better buys (and a fairly pricey mistake too) ...
What about you?