x- factor- ANOTHER new thread!!!

[NosfeRaahhTu]

just in case...

yeah but he's crap, even for a little boy and in fact he's 15/16 and should be able to sing better than that if he were to be a singer but he isn't so it doesn't matter how old he is because he must not give up the day job!

rhydian on xtra factor and same difference

Ok, just caught up.
Alex - fantastic. Should definitely be in the final
Ruth - tries to make everything into a rock track and I didn't like her version of a fairly forgettable song
JLS - not their best week but hope they get through
Rachel - ruined a great song. She should go.
Diana - I like her but not sure I'd want a whole album and this wasn't her best week
Eoghan - did ok and works the crowd through charisma and trying to look cute. Voice is not the best.

Rachel should definitely go as she was out of tune. Really painful.

One thing that interests me is that if you listen to the godawful 'hero' single, out of all of them, i find i can only recognise Diana, Austin, and Rachel- the rest all sound the same!

not sure what that means...
mulled wine IS quite alcoholic...[pissed emoticon]

Unfortunatly, I don't think Rachel will be in the bottom two this week.

I think it will be JLS and Diana.

I thought the audience gave a particularly crap performance during Never Forget

Nosfe. - i totally know what you mean re. recognition of voices on Hero. They were the prominent ones for me too. I thought the same thing!

Naboo, it struck me when i heard it because i know that not a lot of people get the appeal of Diana- but she stands out. And since the prize is a record contract, surely someone who DOESN'T sound like everyone else should win?

But i will concede, the past 2 weeks have not been good for her...

arrrrgh - she is awful!

like a puppet on a string......

ruth and eoghan bottom two I think.

My favourite is Diana, though the backing track was terrible.

I agree totally Nos. Diana was my fav all the way through, but i've gone off her a bit (which i thought i might do). Hope she picks it back up for next week. Very distinct voice.

pleaase god, let rachel go now, its been ages since we been told she will be better next time. she is can sing one song lets face it.

Same Difference- aaaggghhhhh!!!

are they miming??

the woman looks like a he-she

oh bloody hell, they're BACK

HSM has a LOT to answer for...

miming!!!

Lord she has a terrible haircut!!!

SAME DIFFERANCE MIMING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11

they are plastic so they def have to be miming

She could gurn for England...

she's dressed like alice in wonderland

they are well miming- nobody does aerobic dancing and holds a note- bollocks!

its very HSM isnt it lol