“I don't know how to explain it, but there doesn't seem to be the same structure or feel of the show ,or something, as there use to be a couple of years ago.“
The show has been going for 20 years and they’ve been pushing the “this year is the best year ever” every year for the last several years. That’s what has led to the hyperbole and over marking. A 10 score doesn’t have the same value anymore. Because of that, instead of keeping it fresh and interesting, the “best year ever” spiel and the hyperbole has led to it being predictable and repetitive.
I think the other three judges need to take a leaf out of Craig’s book and be more consistent. Also dolling out high scores early in the series is a mistake as it leaves the judges nowhere to go later in the series.