[spoilers sorry, look away if you don’t want to know!]
I watched the last few episodes the other day, and for a series that was so sensitive and nuanced in S1&2, I just couldn’t help notice how stereotyped the final episodes were, especially in how it collapsed all the older women into caricatures of the good or bad mum.
Jean, who used to be interestingly complex, turns into her Earth-mother wise advice mode at the close of ep 8. Maureen is the perfect mum, silent and unobtrusive and smiley with a lovely hug. Emily (who has been disappointingly written into just a comic character this season, ends up also in the position of surrogate mum, coming to watch Adam’s dog show.
Erin is a Bad Mum (overlaboured yet again), but it’s okay because she’s also a caricature of a Tart-With-A-Heart straight from the Eastenders scripts of the 2000s, and she ponies up the cash for Maeve, and anyway now Elsie and Maeve have surrogate Good Foster Mum Anna, who is also quiet and smiley and makes tea. Meanwhile Hope is Bad, so naturally, she is punished by the fact she can’t have children (bit of an obvious narrative move there). Eric’s mum lied so is also Bad, but she gives him a hug so that’s all okay. And Lily’s mum appears in a downtrodden quiet voice and a 1960s tweed coat and Morris Minor for all the world like a character from Call The Midwife, just in case we don’t get the point that Good Mums should be quiet and wise and selfless. Even Jackson’s hot lesbian sports bootcamp mum, one of the now interesting older female characters in previous seasons, just appears in only one scene, to offer him some wise platitudes and smile a beatific mumsy smile.
Is it just me or was anyone else just a bit
at all these caricatures of the Good Woman/Good Mum who is always smiley and quiet and wise? Seems to go completely against previous seasons where the older female characters had a depth and complexity to them. I like the series, but I really hope they can do a bit more in S4.
On another note - Gillian Anderson clearly hadn’t quite shaken off her Maggie T voice this season
Jean was really slipping into PM mode a few times here and there!