Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Joseph thread - is there one yet ? if not....

1000 replies

binker · 15/04/2007 19:07

Can I say that I like Chris B - not the one who was ousted last night...

OP posts:
Molesworth · 05/05/2007 22:31

Ben's voice isn't that great (although it has improved) but for general chutzpah he's the best.

I think Lee should win though.

Also like Lewis, Keith and Rob (but not for Joseph)

Can't bear Craig or Daniel (Jeffrey Archer resemblance can't be brushed under the carpet)

rachfran · 05/05/2007 22:33

I am so happy that Chris B has gone, his teeth are too white and his voice is too weak.
I am warming to Keith too but my favourite is Lewis although he is very angular!

Molesworth · 05/05/2007 22:34

Lewis is v likeable, but I did agree with the panel that his performance tonight was lacklustre.

lyrabelacqua · 05/05/2007 22:34

But bloody Craig the caberet singer stays yet another week! Aaaaaaargh!!!!

lyrabelacqua · 05/05/2007 22:35

And i was just warming to Mr Superbrightteeth.

Molesworth · 05/05/2007 22:35

He's just shit isn't he?

rachfran · 05/05/2007 22:36

Lewis didn't perform well tonght i agree but he is very likeable and I could imagine him being Joseph

lyrabelacqua · 05/05/2007 22:40

And can any of you really see the general public paying good money to look at that funny little munchkin Keith on stage for two hours? i think not.

Molesworth · 05/05/2007 22:41

strange eye/teeth thing going on with keith it has to be admitted

Smutti · 05/05/2007 22:42

Me, no. But I would pay good money to look at Lee or Daniel.......mmmm (what's wrong with nice anyway?)

BoingBoing · 05/05/2007 22:43

Nooo, it's Lee all the way. He had a dismal performance this week, as did, errr, everyone else except Keith, who for the first time I didn't hate (his hair ffs!), maybe it's that he didn't wink? But at least Lee had the charisma to pull off a very duff sing.

And we got some light relief with the Les Mis thing, which was simply hysterical. Methinks, as a self-confessed Lee fan, he won that one on fitness! Lee fit? Wayyyy yeah!!!!!

Not sure who deserved to go though, they were both shocking. But I'd have got rid of Craig as I just don't like him (and WHAT a scary mother). Chris? I just don't like his teeth, but I've been beaten up on another site about that by someone who's sister works for his dad the dentist, who does her family's teeth or something.... so nuff said!!!

All round though, a piss poor show with only Keith outstanding. Here's hoping for next week.. give us a few show tunes.

Molesworth · 05/05/2007 22:43

Daniel?

Daniel "long lost son of Jeffrey Archer" Boys?

No way

roisin · 05/05/2007 22:43

I thought Lee was superb tonight - both individually and in the group. IMO he is head and shoulders above the rest.

purplemonkeydishwasher · 05/05/2007 22:44

let's be honest. it doesn't really matter who wins. people will pay to see the show.
right, rachfran?

Molesworth · 05/05/2007 22:44

Yeah I'd like some show tunes too

Is there such a thing as reverse orthodontics? Chris needs to have his teeth snaggled

compo · 05/05/2007 22:49

I'm loving Daniel, Keith and lee. I thought Lee's comments were way too harsh

lyrabelacqua · 05/05/2007 22:50

I've never seen such enormous teeth. What was his dentist thinking (presumably they're fake).

Molesworth · 05/05/2007 22:51

They can't be real; no one on earth has teeth that huge, that even, or that white.

lyrabelacqua · 05/05/2007 22:51

And i won't be able to look at Daniel the same way again now the Jeffrey Archer comparion's been made. He needs to lose the cheesy grin if he's gonna stay in it.

BoingBoing · 05/05/2007 23:03

Oh God, Jeffrey Archer, now that's the kiss of death....

But I'm gonna defend Lee. Who of the other Joseph's give a monkeys what the rest think? Come on, it's a kill or be killed situation here, non-one's there to make friends. It's not the Apprentice where Katie & wotsisname have a thing. He's already been in the real world of musical theatre, he know's how it works. And the guy's a total sweetie - how cute was he with the judges? And he never whinged or whined about his bad throat or the doctor etc. Yes, he wasn't great tonight, but he was in good company.

Molesworth · 05/05/2007 23:07

Completely agree that Lee stands out from the rest (as Connie did last year).

InTheseShoes · 06/05/2007 07:54

Although I don't think that Chris is Joseph, he really wasn't the poorest tonight - that was Ben by a long mile, Craig was also quite weak. The reality of it is that we are just watching to see which order Craig, Ben, Rob are eliminated until we get to the final four, Lee, Daniel, Lewis and Keith. All of those four could have the chance to win because they all have a USP - Lee and Daniel in thier professionalism and good looks, Lewis with his boy band appeal (one for the Nans - why do you think Nana Jean is the most focussed upon rather than his mum?) and Keith as the "ordinary boy made good, from Tesco to Ticket Sales" element. Really, it's up to the public then, and although Connie did win the Maria competition deservedly as the most competent and talented performer, this competition is a different kettle of fish, because it's about men, not women. Mainly it will be women/gay men voting and watching, if a straw poll of my friends is anything to go by, and they are influenced by different factors than men. For Maria, they will have been voting for talent (maybe for underdog/bit of a back story as well, e.g. Helena, Abi, Siobhan) but on Joseph, there's a real appeal in all of the potential last four to different people. A lot of people will really love the appeal of Lewis, he has that David Beckham/Westlife look. For me that is a massive turn off about him. Daniel also leaves me cold, whereas Lee IMHO is absolutely gorgeous, as well as being the most talented and likely to win. My integrity makes me question whether he SHOULD win though, as I don't like the thought of being manipulated. I am impressed by Keith, his looks don't repell me at all, and I like the whole rags to riches aspect, although I'm probably manipulated there too.

I do think it's a more open competition than Maria, partly because the standard is higher, but mainly because of the uncertainty of the voting dynamic.

If only I thought as much about politics as I do about ADWD...

MrsFish · 06/05/2007 09:10

Lee to win, he is a dreamboat and a very talented one too

bluesky · 06/05/2007 09:47

I thought Rob was appalling, weak and flat and you could barely hear him.

And then at the end Zoe said Lee was flat??!! Way too harsh.

Think they need some better songs.

Lewis does some a little down, he has lost his sparkle.

But beware of Keith, he is becoming judges favourite.

Come on Lee!!

BoingBoing · 06/05/2007 10:51

Rob was the vocal equivalent of nails on a blackboard.

Zoe was just bitchy, nasty and bang out of order with Lee, especially if you compare how easy they were on Rob's vocals. I think there MUST be something else going on there.

And I'll only allow Keith to win if he gets a haircut!

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.