Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

Our Girl and Captain James Addicts XLIII

999 replies

Ilovelblue · 23/09/2017 18:02

Still going strong and waiting out for Series 3.

Our Girl and Captain James Addicts XLIII
OP posts:
Thread gallery
18
Ilovelblue · 10/10/2017 22:11

I see Elvis has changed his scarf from his Kenyan escapades. Sorry, that really is trivial.

OP posts:
Nickel45 · 10/10/2017 22:13

I'm liking Maisie at the moment, although she is quite gobby! Ditto to the accent though mini. Unfortunately DS unearthed a massive spider 10 mins in, so spent the rest of the ep sorting that and him out .... Will catch up now! Kids!!!!?!!!! Back later ......

Rhubarb01 · 10/10/2017 22:17

Thanks for that Minicooper. I think the actress is Australian? I reckon she's gone for a generic Londonish accent.

Yes, the authoritative Georgie is lacking in humour but CJ keeps telling her to deal with it. I would have thought putting her on a charge or giving her some really rubbish job to do would have been more effective. To be honest, I can't quite work out why Maisie's in Two Section and needing mentoring if she was considered good enough to be sent on a special mission to Syria with Elvis's outfit.

Ilovelblue · 10/10/2017 22:21

When Molly was new into Two Section, you really felt for her with the way she put her foot in it all the time and the way CJ treated her at first. I just feel that Maisie is very irritating and Georgie has to take a firm hand. I don't warm to Maisie at this point.

OP posts:
Rhubarb01 · 10/10/2017 22:26

I'm a bit concerned by the way Maisie has put ideas into the head of that little girl about going out into the big wide world.

I think the difference between Maisie and Molly was sheer confidence. Molly was trying to fit in and getting it wrong whereas Maisie just thinks she knows it all. I agree ilove that her attitude would surely have been sorted at basic training or she'd have been out. You can't answer back like that all the time and get away with it. I suppose she'll end up saving the day and toning it down.

MiniCooperLover · 10/10/2017 22:28

Why did Maisie take her braids out and suddenly have a perfectly coiffed hair style?

Ilovelblue · 10/10/2017 22:29

Even though Georgie is her mentor, the way Maisie was behaving, I was surprised that Kingy or CJ didn't step in when they witnessed some of her conversations.

No doubt she will save the day somewhere along the line, yes.

OP posts:
passthecremeeggs · 10/10/2017 22:29

Bit disappointed. Script seems oddly forced and didn't really flow for me. Seems a world apart from the original standalone episode and the first series which were so well written. Agree about CJ seeming a bit down in the dumps - and with seemingly no command of his soldiers...?! I don't believe for a second Maisie would get away with anything she's got up to this episode. And she's really annoying. Looks like there may be a bit of a repeat of theme - mouthy new girl comes good by (at a guess) saving Georgie, also becomes emotionally attached to local girl in trouble. But a good ending and will definitely keep watching.

passthecremeeggs · 10/10/2017 22:30

Also - Georgie - still WAY too much makeup!

Ilovelblue · 10/10/2017 22:31

Ah MiniCooper, I remember a similar discussion that in series 1, Molly always looked perfectly coiffed, even when they were in the bunker before CJ got shot. I'd have loved to know how to do Molly's French plait. If I'd done it, it would be falling out in 5 minutes flat

OP posts:
Firegirl · 10/10/2017 22:34

So hello everyone. I checked back to see if you were all still posting now series 3 is on and it's so great that you are all still very much here and going strong. I agree that this series so far seems a bit more like series 1 than 2, and I have to admit that it sent a shiver down my spine to hear CJ's voice first tonight before we saw him again. He's much more the CJ that I remember from series 1, all shouty! I miss Molly. I think this new character is perhaps supposed to be similar in that she questions authority and wants to do her own thing but she doesn't seem to have the intelligence and common sense that Molly had. Anyway, I hope you don't mind me coming back on your thread to post but it's so good to be able to talk about CJ again!

Rhubarb01 · 10/10/2017 22:35

I didn't notice the hair minicooper but I will have another look at the episode probably tomorrow and check it out. I did notice that Georgie had gone for a small bun now instead of that plaited arrangement that Molly used to have.

I did think that two section were being a bit insensitive when they were helping to build the funeral pyres. I know they're not the brightest of sparks but I would have thought they might keep the black humour or any humour down at that point.

Flowerfan · 10/10/2017 22:35

Hi
Well first impression is I think I’m going to like it. I also cannot believe Maisie would get away with her attitude we shall have to ‘wait out’ and see who wins. CJ in charge again but I agree he does not look happy and did say so “I like an enemy I can see”
However a good start and now another wait
Goodnight

Ilovelblue · 10/10/2017 22:37

The more the merrier Firegirl! Three years and still going strong.......

I'm just watching it again and am laughing at the scene with the baby goat and CJ stroking the goat's ears.

Anyway, need to get ready for bed. I may break a habit and take the laptop with me to see what everyone else's views are.

OP posts:
Rhubarb01 · 10/10/2017 22:40

Hi firegirl great to hear from you.

Yes, stroking the baby goat's ears was cute - wonder if it was in the direction or just instinctive? I'd have stroked the goat too. I love goats!

wibblywobblyfish · 10/10/2017 23:52

I'm a bit of a lurker but I've loved both s1 & s2. Wondering how much Elvis is going to feature especially as he is the main attraction for me Grin. Thought the scene with her mum in the cafe was awful.

purpleme12 · 11/10/2017 01:27

I watched the series with Molly in and really liked it. But I haven't seen the one with Georgie in so tried it tonight but just the character of Georgie didn't do anything for me. I'm not really bothered about her. I was about Molly.

TRish47 · 11/10/2017 04:17

Hello
Due to living across the other side of the world I have not seen the start of this series yet! However reading some of the reviews on different forums, there seems to be a mixed reactions. Mainly about missing Molly,to Georgie’s makeup,and gobby Maisie! Does CJ feature or Elvis? For me they would be the main attraction Wink.
I feel for TG as living up to series1 must be hard. At the risk of repeating myself Molly was OG.
Lovely to see so many new and returned posters xxxxxx Flowers

Ilovelblue · 11/10/2017 07:30

Wibbly Elvis is pretty easy on the eye isn't he? I thought the scene with her Mum was pretty gratuitous to be honest.

OP posts:
Ilovelblue · 11/10/2017 07:39

TRish CJ featured a lot more than in the previous series. Not very bossy though. Elvis was only in the opening scenes in Syria so I'm hoping he appears more next week.

OP posts:
MissEliza · 11/10/2017 07:52

I quite enjoyed this as something to watch on a Tuesday night but Michelle Keegan really is a rotten actor and Ben Aldridge has been really sidelined. Angry

chipscheeseandgravy · 11/10/2017 09:24

Loved the first series, second was okay, third is not great.
Not a fan on Georgie, it’s like the writers have tried to write her as molly, but it’s not worked.

Flowerfan · 11/10/2017 11:29

Morning
I have just been reading the comments in Daily mail on line and I know I am biased but I don’t understand a lot of the criticism!
This is a drama, entertainment and for a lot of us eye candy IT IS NOT A DOCUMENTARY. So watch it as such and enjoy it for what it is
That’s my predjudiced rant finished!!!😏🤷🏼‍♀️

SoEverybodyDance · 11/10/2017 12:50

So nothing will ever match the strange love we seem to have for the more nuanced characters and subtleness of series one. I get that. But this wasn't so bad a start.

I like the setting, it seemed true to the life of a marginalised Asian village. That young girl looks like she's going to be taken off to be a sex worker in India. That happens a lot, I like it that TG raises these issues, we need more of them on TV.

But the village (and the episode) lacked the intensity of somewhere in the aftermath of a devastating earthquake, I thought. I was expecting lots of villagers out digging in the half light, there's that famous press photo of that little boy kneeling over his father's grave, hugging his neatly folded trousers. I expected more of that, but here, most of the villagers were going about their normal daily business, looking sullen. Perhaps that's budget.

I can't get into Georgie Laine. She's too cold, humourless, critical and automatic. MK's acting and perfect appearance makes it worse. She doesn't join in with the banter, her mentoring is a bit shit. If I was working with her, I think I'd end up hating her. She's far too up her own arse to get involved with a local, I think.

So thank God for that new recruit, Maisie, (Dawes 2) although her character could be a lot more nuanced and subtle to be honest. She's no sugar tits though! Hopefully she will be given the space to develop into someone interesting. Perhaps she'll end up having an affair with CJ. He needs something to divert him from being authoritarian and a bit dull. But thank you for the goat stroking scene, which we are all bleating over!

Somewhere I read it being described as something like Our Girl crosses Grange Hill. That's a bit unfair, but it does need some life shaking into it. We need more to 2 section for example than just throwing boxes and bantering...

Anyway, nice to see some of the old people back on here, as well as some new people! Roll on Episode 2!

MissEliza · 11/10/2017 15:04

She's far too up her own arse A very succinct description of Michelle Keegan. I really don't know how the producers thought she was a suitable replacement for Lacey Turner

Swipe left for the next trending thread