Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Telly addicts

A programme about the strange people on Trip Advisor....

107 replies

Pagwatch · 31/10/2011 21:08

Channel 4. On now.

They all look exactly as you would expect..

Grin
OP posts:
Hullygully · 01/11/2011 15:59

If I did I would only write nice things unless it really was unspeakably horrid. It is their lives.

GetOrfMo1Land · 01/11/2011 15:59

I have never written a review, or read one (other than to read the frothing beserkers for a laugh)

Hullygully · 01/11/2011 16:02

They are trainspotters, those reviewers at heart. They should go and watch trains and let the pore ol b&bs muddle along.

KatieMiddIeton · 01/11/2011 16:08

I always think the Brit Landlady is a unique tourist experience. Like going to see Tower Bridge or Stone Henge.

Bill Bryson says it well in Notes From a Small Island page 3-5 here

BecauseImWorthIt · 01/11/2011 16:08

I'm sorry. I can't resist it. Look at this beauty:

just come back today,all English stuck out side in run down streets. hotel staff not helpful, food disgusting, HUGE QUEUES at bars. only small plastic cups allowed.AND ARFTER 11PM DRINKS COST 1 EURO. POOL TABLES 2 EUROS.all pools in the shade, on a steep hill. only to drinks per person at a time. food cold all the time trus food crapp, dont waist your money go somewhere else. but resort ok

Room Tip: dont go walls very thin up hill

DamselInDisarray · 01/11/2011 16:11

Just watching this now.

The Norfolk couple are nuts. And they read even positive reviews as if they're insults. Bizarre.

That cleepthorpes guy is just so pathetic. Of course they won't change the sheets if you don't ask them to. And the need to list every single thing that happens. I feel really sorry for the people who work in his supermarket.

ElderberrySyrup · 01/11/2011 16:11

I have only ever written one review and it was very nice; the people were lovely and had put in every effort, and it was nice to have the chance to share that.

I don't agree that people should only write nice things. It would be quite nice to have been warned about certain things - not a rant necessarily, but 'This place needs to invest in new mattresses' (dh ended up getting his sleeping bag out of the car and sleeping on the floor) or 'This holiday cottage really needs a sofa.'
Specially if the owners are the type who couldn't care less and never bothered to ask if everything was ok.

KatieMiddIeton · 01/11/2011 16:14

Extract below where Bill has just got off the ferry boat from France and is looking for somewhere to stay. This could be a TripAdvisor review were it written in text speak and abridged to Landlady is a bitch and place is a shit hole. Do NOT stay here.#

I didn't know how early one could decently begin asking for a room in England, so I thought I would leave it till midmorning. With time on my hands I made a thorough search for a guesthouse that looked attractive and quiet, but friendly and not too expensive, and at the stroke of ten o'clock presented myself on the doorstep of the one I had carefully selected, taking care not to discompose the milk bottles. It was a small hotel that was really a guesthouse, indeed was really a boarding house.

I don't remember its name, but I well recall the proprietress, a formidable creature of late middle years called Mrs Smegma, who showed me to a room, then gave me a tour of the facilities and outlined the many complicated rules for residing there - when breakfast was served, how to turn on the heater for the bath, which hours of the day I would have to vacate the premises and during which brief period a bath was permitted (these seemed, oddly, to coincide), how much notice I should give if I intended to receive a phone call or remain out after 10p.m., how to flush the loo and use the loo brush, which materials were permitted in the bedroom wastebasket and which had to be carefully conveyed to the outside dustbin, where and how to wipe my feet at each point of entry, how to operate the three-bar fire in my bedroom and when that would be permitted (essentially, during an Ice Age). This was all bewilderingly new to me. Where I came from, you got a room in a motel, spent ten hours making a lavish and possibly irredeemable mess of it, and left early the next morning. This was like joining the Army.

DamselInDisarray · 01/11/2011 16:23

Oh dear, that John guy is a twat. Yes, he should have said something at the time. He didn't want to because then he couldn't bitch about it online.

ReadyToDrinkYourBlood · 01/11/2011 17:45

This thread has made me realise that I need to seek this out online. There should be a klaxon that sounds when such brilliance airs.

uniCorny · 01/11/2011 19:08

Didn't tethers have a trip advisor war with a b&b that were horrible to her mum?

uniCorny · 01/11/2011 19:08

...that horrible man that pretended that he couldn't understand the waitress. Twat.

Georgimama · 01/11/2011 21:04

I quite liked the look of the porny hotel (from its website it appears to be a proper hotel really, not a guesthouse, as it does lunches, dinners and afternoon teas) and should pass muster as our vehicle approaches as we have a Range Rover.

I have to say there are clearly frothing beserkers on tripadvisor, I have looked up hotels I have stayed in and had a perfectly lovely time and other people (mostly Americans I have to say) have slated them.

Nancy66 · 02/11/2011 07:39

I think TA has given people totally unrealistic expectations.

You shouldn't expect to get your sheets changed every day in a £50 a night b&b - a £300 a night 5 star - yes.

the TA reviewers they featured were all misfits - getting off on their tiny bit of power

That said the Norfolk couple were clearly not cut out for the leisure industry

TwoIfBySea · 02/11/2011 08:32

I've reviewed the Portuguese hotel we stayed at simply to counter the likes of reviewer that were on the show. Felt I needed to inject a bit of common sense in amongst the egg-and-chips brigade. You want 5-star then pay for it!

I do read Trip Advisor but it is very obvious which reviews are from the nit-picking, getting-excited-about-refilling-coffee-sachet crowd. Some do give good advice.

The Norfolk couple were a bit extreme but then the woman who had slated them didn't seem capable of defending her viewpoint which makes it curious as to why she took part in the programme. She came across as very self-important.

The men...well, were there no trains to spot that day? Reminiscent of that other Cutting Edge classic from a few years ago where this man had an office in his house dedicated to complaints. He would count the slices of bread in a loaf & any difference from the previous one, off would go a strongly worded rebuke.

Nice that the one who holidayed with his nan explained about his flaking skin. Of course that's the problem of the unsuspecting B&B owner who then has to clean up after him.

TwoIfBySea · 02/11/2011 08:32

I've reviewed the Portuguese hotel we stayed at simply to counter the likes of reviewer that were on the show. Felt I needed to inject a bit of common sense in amongst the egg-and-chips brigade. You want 5-star then pay for it!

I do read Trip Advisor but it is very obvious which reviews are from the nit-picking, getting-excited-about-refilling-coffee-sachet crowd. Some do give good advice.

The Norfolk couple were a bit extreme but then the woman who had slated them didn't seem capable of defending her viewpoint which makes it curious as to why she took part in the programme. She came across as very self-important.

The men...well, were there no trains to spot that day? Reminiscent of that other Cutting Edge classic from a few years ago where this man had an office in his house dedicated to complaints. He would count the slices of bread in a loaf & any difference from the previous one, off would go a strongly worded rebuke.

Nice that the one who holidayed with his nan explained about his flaking skin. Of course that's the problem of the unsuspecting B&B owner who then has to clean up after him.

ripstheirthroatoutliveupstairs · 02/11/2011 09:16

I recorded this and watched it last night. The retired Police officer who pretended not to be able to understand the spanish waitress and her cereal offers. Just twattishly rude IMO. Did him and his mate really drink ten Buds or was it Norfolk cardiac mans cooking?
The twunt who wants people to guess about his skin condition. I've never heard of one where you need to change bedding daily, but I am not a dermatologist. The best bit about him and his shaky hands was his Nan.
The couple who visited St Ives That was a who was the most awful toss up.
Man with stuffed tiger head and porn. I wouldn't mind a visit to his place. The mature student who reviewed it was a cunt I'd say.

GetOrfMo1Land · 02/11/2011 12:50

Yes that retired copper was obnoxious - it was patently clear what the spanish waitress said, he just wanted to make a (vile) point.

cocoachannel · 02/11/2011 13:54

Loved this programme.

Interesting to see the man from the Eltmore Inn, who managed to reduce a friend of mine to tears when she stayed there...

DH and I use and add to TripAdvisor quite a lot. We started using it when we took an extended honeymoon and travelled for a year. It was useful to us so we did our bit and reviewed the places we stayed. The majority of our reviews were positive; we did have the odd shocker, but complained at the time of the stay not just online!

I do wonder whether anyone reads the LONG reviews the people of the programme were submitting. A couple of paragraphs is normally enough!

GetOrfMo1Land · 02/11/2011 15:52

ooh cocoa what did that bloke do to make your mate cry?

GetOrfMo1Land · 02/11/2011 15:58

Has anyone read the tripadvisro review that the bloke gave for the Eltermere Inn?

Here it is third one down by stu bec

It is actually a very good review imo - they concentrated on the negative snippets in the programme (re the erotic pictures and taxidermy) but the review on the whole is very positive, and is complimentary about the owner and his vision.

It's a shame that they didn't allude to this in the programme.

DamselInDisarray · 02/11/2011 16:06

The review two down from that one is hilarious though. Dog excrement-no thank you.

GetOrfMo1Land · 02/11/2011 16:20

Yes I did laugh at the dog excrement. Mind you I think his responses to some of the reviews are very funny.

ElderberrySyrup · 02/11/2011 17:39

What about this response:

'I'm sorry this reviewer didn't enjoy Eltermere, I'd say 99% of our guests come to experience the glorious outdoors here in Elterwater. However, if, like this reviewer, you prefer to spend your day shopping in Bowness & eat ethnically elsewhere, drink take-away wine in front of your TV, then Eltermere, regrettably, is not for you.'

GetOrfMo1Land · 02/11/2011 18:01

Oh god I didn't see that!

I had best not book to go there, he wouldn't let me and my polyester cleavages over the threshold Grin