Eyeshadow cream

5 replies

OntheupsoIam · 07/12/2025 10:26

A few years ago, Benefit used to do some amazing eyeshadow creams in pots. They were a bit shimmery but great for everyday, easy to apply and stayed put all day. They were discontinued and I’ve never found anything as good. Does anyone have any recommendations for a cream eyeshadow with a bit of shimmer? Thanks

OP posts:

EdinaMonsoon · 07/12/2025 10:40

MAC used to do them. Might be worth a look? Otherwise Chanel have cream eyeshadow in a pen style applicator which is super soft and blendable even on my crepey eyes!

myladyjane · 07/12/2025 11:09

I got one from morphe (in Superdrug) the other day. Quite like, pretty long lasting which is my issue with cream shadows but maybe too matte for what you need.

Original poster

OntheupsoIam · 07/12/2025 11:19

Thank you both - I’m off out to the shops later!

OP posts:

TheLongRider · 07/12/2025 11:24

Cheap versions - Maybelline Colour Tattoo 24 hour pots do exactly what they promise. The shade range isn't great. Revlon Colourstay is another good budget option. ELF also do eyeshadow pots - again they do not budge or crease. I use a white one as a base for more intense powder shadows.

RockGirl · 07/12/2025 11:25

Have you looked at Trinny London?

Flip