Clinique Take the Day Off balm vs Take the Day of Cleansing Oil?

[Britpopbaby]

I am looking to repurchase the balm and saw the cleaning oil and thought this might be better with regard to how much to use. Anyone got any thoughts? Is the oil as good as the balm?

The balm is better

I much prefer the balm and find I use a lot less compared to the oil. I really dislike the oil on my eyes and feel it is not as effective at removing mascara as the balm and also leaves a greasy residue.

its worth trying the Body Shop camomile cleansing balm, it’s superb!

Tried and prefer the Clinique one!