For my DD aged 16, dark brown or tan, suede or leather fine. Obviously she wants something fashionable, also she is 5'10", a size 8 (in clothes) and doesn't need a wide leg, and neither does she have particularly wide feet. It seems an impossible task. Fashion boots only go up to an 8. A lot of the styles seem to be catering for a fetish market or at the other end of the scale people who want something more classic. Or they assume that everyone tall has big calves and wide feet. I wonder how fashion models ever have nice footwear - do they have them made? DD has several nice pairs of smart trainers, and we could get school shoes but actual other shoes can be tricky.